• Guest, can you feel the love in the air? Valentine's Week at The Bell Tree has begun with a new mini-event featuring four activities to enjoy -- new and returning collectibles are up for grabs! Dive in to the love here.

Mafia Improbable Role Mafia 3 - Endgame

frick is day ending in like less than 12 hours cause i gotta sleep soon. Among those 4 custom text-role people i feel punchy is the least likely to be true and a bit of byngo too. But tina did raise a good point that these could be passive roles. I retract my read on dooby and waffles pretty securely for now but im still drawn to thinking that one of those 4 (byngo, punchy, locket, kat) has to have fake claiming scum in its tracks considering how easy it is to slip by and claim having so and so as passive roles.

punchy, buddy, i vote for your lynch as is customary :lemon: half placeholder, half so i wont get scolded for non voting. But imo among the four ur raising more scum flags from the nature of your role.
 
I retract my read on dooby and waffles pretty securely for now but im still drawn to thinking that one of those 4 (byngo, punchy, locket, kat) has to have fake claiming scum in its tracks considering how easy it is to slip by and claim having so and so as passive roles.

All four post-restricted roles were made (or implied) within the first four hours of day before everyone had posted. I mean I didn't come in myself till the eighteen hour mark. I feel like if it were being faked that they would have waited 'til everyone posted so as not to overlap. So even if not all are town, I think the restrictions are real. The last of the claims was Punchy's, and his posts show that he had awareness of who had/hadn't posted if he thought I was talking through Ness.
 
@Tina - ok, seems fair. Restrictions may be inherent regardless of alignment. I think that should likely be the case since if ness made all those 4 text passive roles as town it'd be easier to narrow down scum. I'm not confident that these people be cleared however based on a passive rule they "must" follow, except for kat cause i think shes seeming pretty town

- - - Post Merge - - -

Sorry if my thought isnt coherent. its late night and i probably need sleep
 
No, you made sense!

I saw it asked but didn't see an answer so - Ness, are we on a 24/24 cycle?
 
Yeah, personally I'm willing to lynch Farobi bc I don't that Ness would have a lyncher two games in a row, and Farobi's response wasn't so much a defense but an attempt to discredit the investigation itself.

Thoughts as I read back
The role description says once you frame someone the next day your target gets killed :lemon:

- - - Post Merge - - -



IM LEGIT SERIOUS
Ok, actually kinda less comfortable bc waffles seems to be describing a role cop. Waffles, what did you mean with the bolded

my scum lean is dooby and waffles

I find it weird how Farobi goes from agreeing with me to having me in his top two sus in two posts. Yeah, I know he had a grievance with me "plugging to establish my townieness", but his reason to sus me is as follows.

dolby because he's making too much sense oWo
waffles was more a joke read but if u want reasoning shes trying to lynch a randtown!



A-ahh! I have to uh.. see my pl-plans first... Do-don't worry! I will be back at a more.. convenient.. time. ;)
No, that's not a reason to sus someone. That's him floundering trying to justify against the person who he's sussed. He even admits that Waffles is a random suspicion

That being said, I actually kinda have some concerns about the timeline of Waffles claim. She claimed at day start, but didn't vote Farobi for three hours later, but claimed to received her result when the game started. I'd expect her to have voted and began to push immediately. However, she did wait to seriously claim until after she voted, so I'm going to look back and try to see if she's been a cop before in a (recentish) game.

However, Farobi is really acting differently, so yeah, I trust waffles over Farobi

Im hella legit day cop its even green text smh

Credit for being the first to say this

Waffles did you come to this game just to tunnel me :^( if youre town then you're wasting time trying to put me up for lynch and town efforts too. If youre scum then eh, it'll make more sense but i doubt it atm. I'll be in the thread for a couple hours but i cant answer yet because im in a thing, but lay out some things so i can respond to ur suspicions.
As I said this before, I don't like this. It dismisses the possibility of Waffles being a day cop when she has seriously claimed, and the possibility of Farobi himself being a miller.

I get you are serious but how can rest of town agree to this? Im just as curious as to why you hold these suspicions on me
Delibratly not pushing Waffles and pretending to act confused. While I also see some reason to doubt waffles claim, Farobi's method of defending himself does not sit right with me. His attempts, again, focus on him defending from the possibility of having been inspected, and dismissing Waffles as a fake claim. I think he'd at least consider the possibility of him being a miller

Well by the time I receive role pm it did says I could investigate before day 1 starts and so I decided to send an action to investigate you and it says "Farobi is not innocent ( ͡? ͜ʖ ͡?)"

It's cheesy I know
eh
ehhhhhhhhhh

I guess one way to confirm what your role does is to inspect yourself in Day 2 phase and see what it reveals to you. Or inspect me again if it's the same thing but that's probably just gonna waste your inspect if your role is what I think it is. But hey, variety of options my dude.
Isn't even doubting the legitness of Waffles claim, despite the result. He's playing for time here

Kat is still my definitive townlean.
I want to say Waffles is town as well, because this is extremely odd for any third-party or maf to be doing
I kinda like how Locket flowed into the game wither her colored text
If one of the post-restricted people is sus right now it's Punchy right now for me honestly, but I haven't seen good reason to really sus any of them
Glow and ily have both been uncharacteristically silent.


Farobi is the person that I most suspect right now. I actually like his vote on Punchy, and will say that I don't think that him/Punchy are teammed, but waffles claim and his weak as **** response which consists of him dismissing the inspection, first by saying that Waffles is fake claiming, then saying that it's a bad result without elaborating in the options just seems like maf play (particularly the first bit)
 
I get the poems, the 20 posts max and the one-liners .. but how is posting in different colours even a restriction in any way ?

its not really i just have to type in color tbh

Well by the time I receive role pm it did says I could investigate before day 1 starts and so I decided to send an action to investigate you and it says "Farobi is not innocent ( ͡? ͜ʖ ͡?)"

this sounds like such a fake message but at the same time its totally something ness would say

I still think of the four implying these sorts of roles (whoever was posting in coloured text hasn't confirmed though) Kat is the most likely to be town.
i replied to one of dolby's quotes asking me if i had to and yeah it is part of my role
 
I don't really trust Waffles but I voted Farobi to determine if we should ignore her "investigations" for the rest of the game or not, and also there isn't really enough material to vote for anyone else imo
 
@Dolby on the same page regarding Farobi's attitude to the inspection. Unravel's remark about her role colour is also why I am confident she is town.

@Locket you wrote it in white so I didn't catch it until I went back and realised! Had to quote to read it as I'm on mobile.
 
Ya, to be honest I'm very confused and lost in this game. I kinda regret joining and maybe a replacement would be best to help you guys have a better game ? Every time I think i'm on to something, someone says it is actually normal. Like I really thought Locket was faking the coloured text because I don't see how it is a restriction as much as the other three. Literally everything up to now looks so fake I can't even navigate myself through this game or provide helpful posts.
 
Ya, to be honest I'm very confused and lost in this game. I kinda regret joining and maybe a replacement would be best to help you guys have a better game ? Every time I think i'm on to something, someone says it is actually normal. Like I really thought Locket was faking the coloured text because I don't see how it is a restriction as much as the other three. Literally everything up to now looks so fake I can't even navigate myself through this game or provide helpful posts.

Take a look at IM2. That's where we are all getting our info from.

http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?443471-Improbable-Role-Mafia-2-Endgame
 
ok i know i was being a meme but u guys have to crack my code coz i can't out my reads in thread...........
 
ok i know i was being a meme but u guys have to crack my code coz i can't out my reads in thread...........

If you’re gonna say you’re a role that can’t put out reads that’s bull
 
ok guys I need to replace
I won't be back until Sunday afternoon, I'm sorry! inb4 Farobi susses me because I'm replacing
 
It's only Friday I don't think any of us would be mad if you just didn't show up during night phase. Stay!
 
It's only Friday I don't think any of us would be mad if you just didn't show up during night phase. Stay!

nono I won't have access to anything electronic

- - - Post Merge - - -

ok guys I need to replace
I won't be back until Sunday afternoon, I'm sorry!

and also this should count as one line, if I were to put it on one line then it would be a one liner
 
Back
Top