Mafia Improbable Role Mafia 3 - Endgame

[Chris]

@Antonio - what're your thoughts on the game so far?

 

[Antonio]

@Antonio - what're your thoughts on the game so far?

I have only read punchy posts w/ a few surrounding it and everything during night 1 phase. Saturday is cleaning day, will state my opinion once done.

 

[unravel]

I have only read punchy posts w/ a few surrounding it and everything during night 1 phase. Saturday is cleaning day, will state my opinion once done.

Arent you supposed to post 1 liner?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Petition to lynch either of the following: either Kayla or Byngo

 

[Chris]

Arent you supposed to post 1 liner?

Punchy lied about the post requirement.

 

[Byngo]

The fact that Farobi randomly sussed Byngo, proceeded to say Punchy was more sus and then vote for Waffles

Interesting that he also did that with u

so i actuslly tr punchy/antonio because if they were scum, id think antonio would?ve upheld punchys charade. scum antonio/anyone would be too concerned about backlash from revealing the one liner thing was a lie to actually break it

i already tr kat, lockets been a little more iffy but tbh farobi focusing on post restricted people makes me want to tr her. just cuz if farobis scummate was pretending to have a restriction, I?d think he wouldn?t sus them at all. creates too much of a connection, especially when he most likely knew he was gonna die

so heres where im at

town
kat
punchy
waffle
locket

null: everyone else

i would like to know y people think im so sus other than not rlly contributing tbh

 

[Antonio]

What's is tr?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hold up, forgot to look it upm

- - - Post Merge - - -

couldn't find it, does tr mean town read?

 

[Locket]

couldn't find it, does tr mean town read?

yeah it does

give me a couple minutes and i'll get my opinions on people

 

[Arstotzkan]

@Antonio yea
TR is town read
I agree with natty, and my gut
says the push on you is scum's greed

All we can glean from Punchy's lie
was that he didnt want to make a long post
There's a few reasons I can think why town!Punchy does this
Like maybe he considered his role more important than most

That being said, antonio
for you to ask
for us to not compare you to punchy
is an impossible task

you both held the same slot
so both of you give information
as to your role's meaning
so that we can take the right action

I cant quite place it
But something's off to me about Dad
Other than that, when I get the chance
I wanna look at the pressure Antonio's had

 

[Antonio]

@Antonio yea
TR is town read
I agree with natty, and my gut
says the push on you is scum's greed

All we can glean from Punchy's lie
was that he didnt want to make a long post
There's a few reasons I can think why town!Punchy does this
Like maybe he considered his role more important than most

That being said, antonio
for you to ask
for us to not compare you to punchy
is an impossible task

you both held the same slot
so both of you give information
as to your role's meaning
so that we can take the right action

I cant quite place it
But something's off to me about Dad
Other than that, when I get the chance
I wanna look at the pressure Antonio's had

Yes, we held the same role and position but as I previously stated before, punchy gameplay made zero sense. His actions made no sense and his behavior didn't reflect with the information I got in the direct message from Ness. Like for example, the one liner. There's nothing in direct message about one liners or me having post requirements (idk if there's a term).

So I'm going to say this again, punchy did not understand his objective and was doing his own thing. He didn't handle his game properly and his game play didn't make sense. His reactions doesn't reflect with what I have in direct message therefore it shouldn't count against me, who just started.

Also, nice poem.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Just because it didn't reflect your PM
Doesn't mean it's not important
He still did those things with your role
So examining it'll still warrant

Why are you so intent
on separating yourself from his play?
If you want to be a separate entity so bad
Then maybe you give thoughts and look at something other than how you're not what he was today

 

[Antonio]

Because in the last few games, punchy gameplay has been very misleading. Plus, his gameplay don't correspond with my direct message from Ness. Anyways, I will write things once I'm done cleaning up, right now it's breaktime.

 

[cornimer]

Interesting that he also did that with u

so i actuslly tr punchy/antonio because if they were scum, id think antonio would?ve upheld punchys charade. scum antonio/anyone would be too concerned about backlash from revealing the one liner thing was a lie to actually break it

I know I'm town though
But that's a good point you make about punchy/antonio.

 

[Dolby]

What I'm not understanding from the lynch ( and I'm not even there yet, I'm still bouncing back and forth between both Improbable games ) is why are we clearing the people who voted Farobi ? Wasn't Farobi a lost cause from the beginning so people would have no choice but to vote him anyways ? Wouldn't it make more sense for a mafia team to bus him at that point to earn Town cred ? I'm really not seeing it the same way here and I don't understand what I'm missing out on to be able to connect those dots ? How come they are getting cleared for voting someone who was told they received a red alignment from a day cop ?

A disturbingly low amount of people actually voted for Farobi. He wasn't in the lead until I voted 3 and a half hours until day actually ended

I can confirm that Punchy was using reverse psychology or I believe he was. There's literally nothing in my DM stating anything about one liners just something about protecting.

Farobi pushed Punchy a lot, being his main target. Their's wasn't a scum v scum interaction. Moreover, I feel that maf!Antonio would have kept with the charade for fear of being sussed for dropping it. I kinda think that Punchy is third party, but in no way is a shot/lynch on Punchy's slot justified at this point. Solid townlean.

Moreover, does scum, with one vote on them and doubt in the "day cop's" claim vote on their teammate in an attempt to get the lynch off of them? No. There was hope for the maf team that the lynch could be taken off of Farobi at that point in time, and for a mislynch to happen.

What is your read on Tina rn? Particularly her response to me about Kayla being too quiet and expanding on some random meta **** I threw Kayla's way?

She hasn't really given me any reason to think she's scum with maybe the exception of pushing Punchy/Antonio here. Plus her vote kinda solidified Farobi's lynch, so over TL. Basically she did all the right actions during the Farobi lynch that I'm not so concerned currently with the sus on Punchy, which is the one thing that I haven't liked about her play so far

Random thought, but the times that you've been online have sucked so far this game. Not meaning that I think it's sus in any way or it's a reason to be pushed, but you've never been online at a time which you could give a genuine reaction to ongoing events

Townlock:Waffles
Townleans(Ordered): Kat, Punchy/Antonio, Vanessa, Tina
Nullish(unordered): Locket, Byngo, Dad
Implied third: Heyden
Sus: Glow, ILY

Ily is more sus than Glow in my view at the moment. There are quite a few problems with that big post of hers that I don't want to dive into right now

 

[cornimer]

Yeah Dolby/Byngo/Waffles are all right that Farobi's push on Punchy didn't feel like scum vs scum, it felt like him going after an easy target to get the lynch off of himself. Still don't know why he lied about his post restriction but w/e I agree he probably isn't scum

 

[Chris]

I don't actually remember Punchy v Farobi. Don't know if that was when I skimmed to catch up or when drunk or both. Will reread D1 when I've a chance.

 

[Chris]

* details of, that is.

I just remember him saying of the 4 post restricted Punchy is most likely scum.

 

[Dolby]

I feel like I'm the only one participating right now and I personally find it very frustrating

Anyway, again, two people who I find personally sus, Glow and Iloveyou. Both of their plays are subpar, and in Glow's case I can't help but feel that it's intentional, but anyway, here's my analysis of their behavior, and I was going to see if Farobi mentioned them in any of his posts while I'm doing so, but it doesn't look like he did in my brief, cursory read-through of his posting

Glow

hi friends. i can't really share much about myself. if i survive long enough, hopefully during this day phase, i will reveal the contents of this by sharing the encryption password. it has a calculated 33.3% chance of confirming me, a .7% chance to bring d2 lylo, and a 66% chance to make dad deathtunnel me til endgame

EnCt2b4cd04701b286a313b89c84ed33a3a3835d9da02b4cd04701b286a313b89c84e3TMzz/wvGAI
znm0w0FolEjFM9nnrTwyL9lre8uqurJH6IwEmS

Decrypt it at https://encipher.it

Not going to go into this. Obviously a joke

ok i know i was being a meme but u guys have to crack my code coz i can't out my reads in thread...........

...
No
This is not town
She is literally just providing an excuse to not contribute here

what

didn't this start yesterday or is my sense of time severely ****ed

- - - Post Merge - - -

farobi seems like town 2 me

Main bulk of where my sus comes from, but her ONLY read during D1 was defending Farobi and trying to move the lynch off of him WHEN THE HEAT WAS COOLING DOWN ON HIM. At the time, nobody was in the thread who was able to make a concise case in favor of lynching Farobi, so Glow comes in and tries to take the heat off of him. Yes, she follows up with this, acknowledging that his claim is sus

ohhhh nvm farobi's claim is bad lolzz

- - - Post Merge - - -

acctually idk i still think he's town????

lets policy dad >:3

But continues to defend him. Someone (probably her) could argue that she should be clear, because what scum would defend their teammate after they're already lynched right? And I feel that she tries to use logic like that to clear herself everygame regardless of alignment, but it falls apart because there was already confusion over what cycles had been used, and if there was time to get the lynch off of Farobi in the thread

And votes for Waffles as well, big nono

Every other post is a ****post not worth what little energy went into making it

Iloveyou

I get the poems, the 20 posts max and the one-liners .. but how is posting in different colours even a restriction in any way ?

Posting this to say that ILY/Locket is an unlikely team

Ooh. So you just want Farobi to die for fun ? Lols Well what happens if he gets lynched though and not just framed ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, GLOW LMAO shout out to Karen

- - - Post Merge - - -





Also, Heyden goes from wanting to look at godfathers to then wanting a lynch between those 3. So in my opinion he seems the most okay to just lynch anyone. Its kinda like how MogYay was last game on Day One ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I don't know, I'm trying

shrugs

First real thoughts of the game are made to cast doubt on the legitimacy of Waffles's claim. Following up, she goes after Heyden for a really inconsequential switch D1, which looks bad because it's a. unimportant as he wasn't really serious with his first suggestion and b. He's claiming third now


Anyway, I particularly don't like the direction that this post goes, because it seems to point out all people who I feel are town and widen the sus net. Responses to it are in bold

For some reason this game is a lor harder to follow than Tina's game, for me personally. It's definitely not about feeling defeated or stressed. ^^ I'm genuinely lost and I probably do need more experience before joining other games from here on out.
Nothing here

What I'm not understanding from the lynch ( and I'm not even there yet, I'm still bouncing back and forth between both Improbable games ) is why are we clearing the people who voted Farobi ? Wasn't Farobi a lost cause from the beginning so people would have no choice but to vote him anyways ? Wouldn't it make more sense for a mafia team to bus him at that point to earn Town cred ? I'm really not seeing it the same way here and I don't understand what I'm missing out on to be able to connect those dots ? How come they are getting cleared for voting someone who was told they received a red alignment from a day cop ?
NOPE
NOPE
Did you even read the vote thread, or the thread in general? Many people, INCLUDING YOU cast doubt on Waffles claim. Farobi was in no way a lost cause and didn't even lead in the votes until I stepped in. He could have been saved,
and I think mafia tried to do that. What do I see here? Widening the net and trying to make what should be our clears not so clear. In the end, only four people voted for Farobi, that's probably less than half of all town members, and Glow attemtped to save him from the lynch as well. Bottom line, MAF COULD HAVE SAVED FAROBI, and I think they would want to. The purpose of this? Again, cast doubt on the alignments of myself, Vanessa, and Tina

Also, I don't think Antonio is doing one-liners ? Unless those role restrictions are specifically made for the day phase ?

Actually ok
And I still don't get why Heyden wasn't brought up more from others because I found he played the most suspiciously during Day One due to what I had posted. He seemed the most okay to just lynch anyone and jumped on what other people brought up in the thread.

Well, again, he's claiming third, and I think his play aligns well with that alignment(wanting everyone gone except for himself, plus he's kinda put a night 2 ultimatum on his own actions). But this doesn't look good for you. You point out myself, Tina, and Vanessa indirectly, and directly Punchy/Antonio and Heyden. What do I see in that group? Not mafia
Also the only thing that lines up with the whole colouring text restriction ( since I questioned it earlier ) is that it existed before. So I'm guessing since no one else has the role she has to be telling the truth ? I just don't get why it's automatically seen as Town though ? To me her role seemed the fakest like I said. But also if we're judging based on counterclaims, wouldn't that mean chances are Punchy is telling the truth ( even if Antonio is following the one-liner rules ) too since no one else said they had that role ? Why is he still the most likely to be faking out of everyone ? Just because he was the last to post ?
Again, going after Locket. Only thing I like about this post, but to many people who I am confident are town are pointed it, either directly or indirectly, through this post

- - - Post Merge - - -

I would also appriciate it if more people would post their thoughts on all players before the end of night, particularly Locket, Glow, and ILY

I lowkey think their's a possibility that Antonio (or Glow) is actually jester, but w/e, I'm trying to get maf

 

[glow]

i am 1/3 of the way to reaching my wincon

 

[cornimer]

I would also appriciate it if more people would post their thoughts on all players before the end of night, particularly Locket, Glow, and ILY

Fine

PunchyDaHufflepuff/Antonio - town or TP because of what me and several people said before (seemed like Farobi picking on weak targets and not a bus)
Arstotzkan - I don't think her role clears her as town but I have liked her questioning of people and contributions. So townlean
Locket - null. I can't recall any information or stances she has actually posted. I believe the colour role is legit but it could be any alignment. Agree with Dolby that she is not teamed with Kayla
Dolby - townlean. I've agreed with everything he has said thus far, and he was the main push for Farobi
heyden - where did he hint he was third party? I missed that
byngo - slight scumlean. I liked her point about Antonio exposing Punchy's lie being town, but like I said before Farobi's random sus on her (compared to his more developed sus on Punchy) seemed like a weak bus. Yes I saw he threw my name out there too but I'm town, and I feel like he would've wanted to distance himself from his teammate somehow since he knew he was going to get lynched.
Unravel - town or TP, I've explained why already
Tina - townlean, but not as strong as Dolby and Kat. Points for voting for Farobi, and I've liked most of her stances
Dad - I can't remember anything he's posted tbh which is unusual for him
iLoveYou - I agree with Dolby and Tina's points about her so scumlean.
glow - obviously attempt to save Farobi, as well as acting as Karen 2.0, looks pretty sus. In the last few games, town glow has mistakenly tried to get the vote off of mafia before (eg: Rune in american politics mafia) so that alone is not a reason to sus her imo, but her posts about it were weird in general. So slight scumlean

- - - Post Merge - - -

I should've bolded names oops

- - - Post Merge - - -

i am 1/3 of the way to reaching my wincon

:thinking:

 

[iLoveYou]

I hope you win Glow

- - - Post Merge - - -

:}

- - - Post Merge - - -

:}