Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[glow]

...What are you even talking about?

As for Cake I found their tone gut towny but they'd been very lackluster and I think she was the one who said I reminded them of Endless last game which I am...definitely going to want explained that feels like really bullpoop shade thrown my way.

idk i'm scatterbrained rn but what i'm t r y i n g to say is, u want to vote for someone who stated they won't be here which we rly shouldn't do? unless you aren't trying to vote shawo.

& lol.

 

[Antonio]

Regarding your question, there's not a town motive for not answering the question therefore it doesn't make sense. You said it yourself that it was an easy question. Finally, regardless of alignment, people always have a motive behind their actions. There's no logic without reason, I believe the saying goes.
----------------------------------------
Regarding my previous questions that appeared to come off as nothing, there was a post similar to the Bolded above that stuck out to me. It's almost exactly like that because it's a weird mindset for someone who is Town aligned to have. If you guys can still find a post like that, let me know.

The point being with my question is that a majority of people sort of agree that Mafia have to consider a town perspective. However, there's is no absolute truth towards how town aligned people should play. We don't know who is Town so it's impossible to come to a conclusion on what an overall town behavior should be.

The only people who know who's town aligned is Mafia. It's easy for mafia to come up with a conclusion on how town should behave because they are aware who is Town. They are the informed minority so they are more likely to have a solid interpretation of the game in the back of their minds.

Am I making myself clear?

I'm not letting this post die on page 39

 

[Geoni]

Here's to hoping the dentist doesn't eat away at the time I have left today too much.


I might be able to post a thing or two while waiting. But in the mean time I think people should gather a list of people they trust voting with and people they are willing to vote for. So there's some actual cohesion going on and we can start boxing wolves off.

 

[Dinosaurz]

Blackmailer is a weird mechanic

 

[glow]

you mean one of us loses a vote? what about it?

what were your final day numbers?

because if its in a LYLO situation then we just lose since mafia will steal a town vote. hope that makes sense

4 hour sleep brain

 

[MyLifeIsCake]

Oh cool I manifested Cake. Explain what you mean with that comparison.

More in style than tone your post reminded me of how endless made huge text walls analyzing every player. Not AI enough for me yet but remember when someone commentated how strange it was that the one player making these huge complicated reads would have been a treat to the maf and yet somehow they weren't night killed?

 

[glow]

chop...LO

 

[Damniel]

what were your final day numbers?

because if its in a LYLO situation then we just lose since mafia will steal a town vote. hope that makes sense

4 hour sleep brain

oh i didn't really think of that

hm

 

[Antonio]

Can yall not ignore my post thx

 

[Dinosaurz]

I like the word elimination makes me think we’re in big brother x

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2020

Can yall not ignore my post thx

No

 

[dedenne]

Regarding your question, there's not a town motive for not answering the question therefore it doesn't make sense. You said it yourself that it was an easy question. Finally, regardless of alignment, people always have a motive behind their actions. There's no logic without reason, I believe the saying goes.
----------------------------------------
Regarding my previous questions that appeared to come off as nothing, there was a post similar to the Bolded above that stuck out to me. It's almost exactly like that because it's a weird mindset for someone who is Town aligned to have. If you guys can still find a post like that, let me know.

The point being with my question is that a majority of people sort of agree that Mafia have to consider a town perspective. However, there's is no absolute truth towards how town aligned people should play. We don't know who is Town so it's impossible to come to a conclusion on what an overall town behavior should be.

The only people who know who's town aligned is Mafia. It's easy for mafia to come up with a conclusion on how town should behave because they are aware who is Town. They are the informed minority so they are more likely to have a solid interpretation of the game in the back of their minds.

Am I making myself clear?

yes u made urself clear.

 

[Damniel]

If we mischop today and rest of game:

5 v 3 on D4

If we dont chop today and mischop rest of game:

4 v 3 on D5

 

[Antonio]

yes u made urself clear.

Therefore Daniel solid opinion regarding how Town should be acting is impossible to come up with if they are townie since we aren't aware of who is Townie.

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2020

I think we should be discussing this as I believe we should vote off damniel today.

 

[Damniel]

volt and hikari are at the most bottom rn. dedenne guava and cake are also down there tbh but more from lack of presence than actual wolf motivated behavior

 

[voltairenism]

honestly this is barely a read list just my thoughts on players

daniel - i think hes actively solving the game and trying to see all options, which feels town to me
ace - i see the parallels with other games where he was town and I dont think hes faking it either. his game as mafia lacked confidence
geoni - reads feels rushed so i cant say for sure. wish he would hear me tho im kinda getting sad lol
cake - wait is it all cake? always has been
they are uh ok i dont know, I cant see parallels with kingmaker but I also dont know much about them
dedenne - feels like good ol town dedenne that would get chopped d1 for *check notes* parroting reads or something, I can't say for sure though
glow - always so helpful pls spare braincells. strongest townread prob
guava - ??!?!??@??!?@?
shawo - eh i was more certain abt him being town before snapping at geoni. i cant see why, and I am not sure if it is town driven
dino - act as just lost town. it was criticized for spreading their posts too much but I think it was fine
alek - also a strong townread. all of the question thing and paranoia feels town
hikari - idk anymore. I feel like they disappeared bc of not knowing how to recover too and I see town do that frequently so it kinda rings a bell

is it all
im on mobile btw

 

[dedenne]

Therefore Daniel solid opinion regarding how Town should be acting is impossible to come up with if they are townie since we aren't aware of who is Townie.

knowledge of how town have acted from previous games? experience? wouldnt those factor into him knowing how town should act?

 

[Damniel]

Therefore Daniel solid opinion regarding how Town should be acting is impossible to come up with if they are townie since we aren't aware of who is Townie.

?????

 

[g u a v a]

just to clarify I suggest guava bc whether alignment she is she always will keep being brought up and causing conflict but I dont really like this idea either

i actually yelled “WOW” out loud when i read this

 

[Damniel]

im saying town are unpredictable while wolves make more calculated decisions??? i said guava being weird and not wanting to contribute is not necessarily a wolf motivated move?

 

[Antonio]

knowledge of how town have acted from previous games? experience? wouldnt those factor into him knowing how town should act?

Those should be irrelevant because those games consist of different individuals with different playstyles. Plus, people stated that they don't tend to play way every game so having a solid opinion regarding towns behavior is hard to come up with unless you are an informed minority.