• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

what was the last game that geoni was town? I haven't seen him as town so I don't have anything for comparison. his tone feels strange to me but that should be a good thing since I only saw him as mafia lol
 
wait that game is the one that shawo talked abt to back up that geoni is mafia wait what

i may need the re-read the last few pages i was too sleepy
Post automatically merged:

ok no he was talking abt kingmaker lol
 
ah here i am again, not knowing who to vote.
right now my town leans are dan, alek and liam, everyone else apart from ace is a null. ace i still need to reread up on so hes a slight maflean for now. i am open to vote on any of the nulls given theres actually,, a good reason.
 
ok i dont think there is enough to chop hikari
actually i dont think there is enough to chop anyone but thats how d1 goes right
maybe we should just take the L and chop guava?
dang u gotta love d1 chop
Post automatically merged:

can we make this thread chaotic three hours before Eod instead of 30 minutes before EoD please
 
can everyone try to write at least 1-2 lines about the whole playerlist? colored reads aren't rly necessary but i'd like to get a feel for where everyone is at in a singular post

1. FinalArcadia (Lolly) - i hATE when players say they don't want to read the game (they stopped at page 12). early townvibe read on cake but wasn't sure why. then went to search back into the game for the reason, couldn't find it but explained it nonetheless. this felt natural to me actually but i didn't like the explanation
2. Voltairenism (Coco) - very towny one liners.
3. Dedenne (Anhka) - trying to be wary on dedenne since i've misread in the past. however the below inconsistency really bothers me:

dedenne said:
what. how is not answering a question where you said if anyone wishes to reply ai? im not sure im following here
Click to expand...
dedenne said:
also u refusing at first to answer aleks question, imo maf wouldnt refuse as it might make them more sus.
Click to expand...

why is it not AI but then a reason to townread dan?

also dedenne pls answer what traits you are seeing from daniel's meta that makes you think he's town in this game, i'm def curious on that as well

4. Ace Marvel (Colton) - love the strong conviction on daniel, not sure if it's right but i think it's a good sign and i don't think he'd be making a hard push on someone like daniel as mafia
5. guav@ (Monique) - i always kinda tone-tr guava so yeah i don't have much to say on the posts she's made other than she a true queen
6. Alek (Stitches) - a bit wonky but town to me rn nonetheless.
7. Damniel (Vesta) - i need to compare an ISO of this game to a prev. i honestly don't think he's playing the same as from what i remember so that's why i'm extra curious on why dedenne said that?
8. MyLifeIsCake (Cherry) - cake's reads post is LACKING that analytical genuine tone that i remember them having in the past. like yes, post count was low in those games too but they had a quippy speech pattern in their reads that i recall was bleeding town. i really do NOT see that this game.
9. Dinosaurz (Pietro) - some decent posts sprinkled in i think. i liked the way he gave his read on alek tho i don't agree with the way he said it lol
10. Hikari (Poncho) - decent tone but kinda bad posts. worth a re-read. not aligned with dinosaurz
11. Geoni (Dobie) - oBviOuS sCuM. seemed to take issue with people randomly townreading me during the reads game, fair enough but i don't think he's tried to sort me yet? also i want to ask what meta i have from his pov?
12. Epona (Whitney) - girl u seem tired idk why tho. ik after i've flip mafia i'm relieved to play as town idk about u tho. most of your posts seem kinda aloof
13. glow (Daisy)
14. shawo (Raymond) - not aligned with geoni. not aligned with epona. playing more lowkey this game so it's kinda weird lol
Post automatically merged:

also i need to vote bc i have to study UGH
 
alright i didn't want to bring this up too early since I wanted discussion on voting to still happen. but EoD is getting closer and there still isn't a general idea for a wagon. I actually think no chopping is a very valid option here

if we assume there's 3 mafia (based on the 3v12 games i played on MU made for balance), here's the numbers with no chop today v a mischop, in the worst case scenario that mafia get out a kill each night and we mischop each day:

mischop today and each day after- lose at a D4 mischop w a succesful N4 kill
not chop today and mischop each day after- lose at a D5 mischop

you can check the numbers for yourself, but not chopping today actually buys us another day. normally i wouldn't really bring not chopping up, but our opinions seem to be too splintered and personally im not super confident in anyone either. I think A D5 chop is better than a D1 chop, since we can work with the flavor clues to give us a bit more guidance. So i dont think that not killing anyone here means we have nothing to go off of D2, since we'll have flavor clues and the reads that've already come out

thoughts?
 
i’m gonna go get food and still put out my current reads on everyone. i still need we should give our reads out
 
Damniel said:
alright i didn't want to bring this up too early since I wanted discussion on voting to still happen. but EoD is getting closer and there still isn't a general idea for a wagon. I actually think no chopping is a very valid option here

if we assume there's 3 mafia (based on the 3v12 games i played on MU made for balance), here's the numbers with no chop today v a mischop, in the worst case scenario that mafia get out a kill each night and we mischop each day:

mischop today and each day after- lose at a D4 mischop w a succesful N4 kill
not chop today and mischop each day after- lose at a D5 mischop

you can check the numbers for yourself, but not chopping today actually buys us another day. normally i wouldn't really bring not chopping up, but our opinions seem to be too splintered and personally im not super confident in anyone either. I think A D5 chop is better than a D1 chop, since we can work with the flavor clues to give us a bit more guidance. So i dont think that not killing anyone here means we have nothing to go off of D2, since we'll have flavor clues and the reads that've already come out

thoughts?
Click to expand...

I know it's just one vote, but coming from the person set to be killed, is kinda of opportunistic, but if most players agree, I'm good with it, I have yet to see a no kill in action.
Post automatically merged:

Damniel said:
i’m gonna go get food and still put out my current reads on everyone. i still need we should give our reads out
Click to expand...
Quite the contrary, if we go the no kill route, we should NOT put our reads out, that is giving mafia ammo to chose their kill tonight.
 
Damniel said:
alright i didn't want to bring this up too early since I wanted discussion on voting to still happen. but EoD is getting closer and there still isn't a general idea for a wagon. I actually think no chopping is a very valid option here

if we assume there's 3 mafia (based on the 3v12 games i played on MU made for balance), here's the numbers with no chop today v a mischop, in the worst case scenario that mafia get out a kill each night and we mischop each day:

mischop today and each day after- lose at a D4 mischop w a succesful N4 kill
not chop today and mischop each day after- lose at a D5 mischop

you can check the numbers for yourself, but not chopping today actually buys us another day. normally i wouldn't really bring not chopping up, but our opinions seem to be too splintered and personally im not super confident in anyone either. I think A D5 chop is better than a D1 chop, since we can work with the flavor clues to give us a bit more guidance. So i dont think that not killing anyone here means we have nothing to go off of D2, since we'll have flavor clues and the reads that've already come out

thoughts?
Click to expand...

um are you taking the blackmailer into consideration here??????????
 
voltairenism said:
ok i dont think there is enough to chop hikari
actually i dont think there is enough to chop anyone but thats how d1 goes right
maybe we should just take the L and chop guava?
dang u gotta love d1 chop
Post automatically merged:

can we make this thread chaotic three hours before Eod instead of 30 minutes before EoD please
Click to expand...
just to clarify I suggest guava bc whether alignment she is she always will keep being brought up and causing conflict but I dont really like this idea either
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

EvilTheCat6600
Goodbye And Good Riddance To My Second Island
Replies
0
Views
220
EvilTheCat6600
EvilTheCat6600
Alolan_Apples
Island Improvements Questionnaire:
Replies
9
Views
306
Asarena
Asarena
Plum Pudding
Question regarding Harvey's Island
Replies
5
Views
158
J087
J087
mayor.lauren
Buying Cataloguing?
Replies
0
Views
86
mayor.lauren
mayor.lauren
Jeremy
  • Locked
  • Poll
Besting Blunders - Community Voting
Replies
4
Views
884
ShawnFuzz
ShawnFuzz
Back
Top