voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
i think they sent goon no matter what
-
Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.
Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins
- Thread starter DinoTown
- Start date
DinoTown
Festive Fossil
I'd like to point out that the mafia are actually told what the clue is beforehand - it feels unfair to drop one of them in it like that without giving them a chance to prepare a strategy for working around it.
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
if there is more than one goon, so yeah I think the least suspected one
Dinotown said what the clue, so that suggests only one clue?
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
hm
Post automatically merged:
yea this clue doesnt do much imo
Post automatically merged:
perhaps someone sees value in it, but im gonna focus on EoD rn
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
i got the impression that it was someone heavy, but with the pointed ears it doesnt make much logic.
but i did scream OMG ITS ****ING RAYMOND ISNT IT
but i did scream OMG ITS ****ING RAYMOND ISNT IT
If mafia are told what the clue is before, does that suggest there are multiple clues there could of been? Could there been a more specific one?
and they just chose the person to kill who was more vague
does that make sense
Or after they chose mafia are told what the clue would be?
idk doesn’t make sense to me lol
and they just chose the person to kill who was more vague
does that make sense
Post automatically merged:
Or after they chose mafia are told what the clue would be?
idk doesn’t make sense to me lol
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
actually i will to an extent
i didn't protect myself. who i protected didn't die like i thought, but im not gonna think to hard about that rn
Geoni
You're doing great!
Didn't feel like wasting hours making a big massive SoD wall full of isos and crap but this is what I got from looking at EoD a few minutes before EoN:
Final Day 1 Votecount
The first thing I want to address is this:
@dedenne care to explain why this happened so soon after guava's vote and to get Cake over her near EoD? How confident were you in guava's towniness over Cake? Cause this felt teamed and you're both in my PoE.
Okay but why were you waiting? Something about this post didn't sit right with me dedenne.
@Alek why didn't you want to vote for guava or even me here if you thought the cake wagon was going to flip villa? You were stuck on Dan and he was a blue claim that wasn't moving.
My point on Ace still stands in that I think that he was trying to push a wagon on flimsy and downright unexplained reasons on me when Shawo had his vote locked there and that it feels like opportunistic him the way he was last game but I will say that he doesn't feel teamed with guava for it yet if that makes sense, but at the end of the day he doesn't fit into that world unless he's gutsier than he was as mafia last game and was trying to dillute the votepool with maintaining a wagon on me but I think if my wagon was meant to protect guava as a teammate that he'd sheep Cake? I can't say for sure but that's just something I'm not worldbuilding at the moment. I am however still gonna consider that he and Shawo were potentially teamed in a different world than the one I was looking at EoD (volt/guava/dedenne). Glow could easily fit into either of these worlds I might add but they didn't interact. But I do recall glow saying something good about Shawo? One thing I didn't like is that you were memeing at EoD which shows you weren't concerned about what's going on and that tends to be a wolftell ime. Also I don't know why you were intent to deny Dan's doc claim at a time when it felt unnecessary and that also feels like something done to maintain doubt.
Epona being on Dino which is a wagon that wouldn't happen is also questionable when she was asking if we should vote cake. Especially with wagons almost tied, if one of them was wolf it feels avoidant? I still feel good about epona but this is what stood out from her EoD.
Oh I'm pretty okay with Dan's EoD I think, ridiculously early claim aside.
Reading through SoD post and RIP glow. I'm going with the pointy ear thing being a clue which means team has to have one of these people:
Arcadia
Dedenne
Ace
guava
epona
shawo
Final Day 1 Votecount
The first thing I want to address is this:
@dedenne care to explain why this happened so soon after guava's vote and to get Cake over her near EoD? How confident were you in guava's towniness over Cake? Cause this felt teamed and you're both in my PoE.
Okay but why were you waiting? Something about this post didn't sit right with me dedenne.
@Alek why didn't you want to vote for guava or even me here if you thought the cake wagon was going to flip villa? You were stuck on Dan and he was a blue claim that wasn't moving.
My point on Ace still stands in that I think that he was trying to push a wagon on flimsy and downright unexplained reasons on me when Shawo had his vote locked there and that it feels like opportunistic him the way he was last game but I will say that he doesn't feel teamed with guava for it yet if that makes sense, but at the end of the day he doesn't fit into that world unless he's gutsier than he was as mafia last game and was trying to dillute the votepool with maintaining a wagon on me but I think if my wagon was meant to protect guava as a teammate that he'd sheep Cake? I can't say for sure but that's just something I'm not worldbuilding at the moment. I am however still gonna consider that he and Shawo were potentially teamed in a different world than the one I was looking at EoD (volt/guava/dedenne). Glow could easily fit into either of these worlds I might add but they didn't interact. But I do recall glow saying something good about Shawo? One thing I didn't like is that you were memeing at EoD which shows you weren't concerned about what's going on and that tends to be a wolftell ime. Also I don't know why you were intent to deny Dan's doc claim at a time when it felt unnecessary and that also feels like something done to maintain doubt.
Epona being on Dino which is a wagon that wouldn't happen is also questionable when she was asking if we should vote cake. Especially with wagons almost tied, if one of them was wolf it feels avoidant? I still feel good about epona but this is what stood out from her EoD.
Oh I'm pretty okay with Dan's EoD I think, ridiculously early claim aside.
Reading through SoD post and RIP glow. I'm going with the pointy ear thing being a clue which means team has to have one of these people:
Arcadia
Dedenne
Ace
guava
epona
shawo
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
wow someone was ready
the Alek/Daniel back and forth was honestly weird to read back on and it's why i'm less suspicious of daniel now because it still looks like town/town (albeit unproductive town/town) to me
one of the main reasons endless, ace and i didn't even use our quicktopic except literally to discuss mechanics stuff like kills is because endless made the point at the very beginning, which i agreed with, that town are more likely to slip up and have wolftells than wolves are bc town are uninformed, chaotic and totally unpredictable
so if we just let town do that it would work out in our favour
so obviously i agree with daniel that there's no prescribed way for town to behave and i couldn't see the point that alek was making at all that only a wolf could know that because i feel like anyone who's played a game as either alignment would know that. town is messy and makes no sense which is why town often loses
which brings me to:
i hadn't been in the thread for literally hours when you posted this so idk where it came from but i'm definitely not ignoring you, i don't think anyone is. i read every post in the thread and consider everything that is said
Sometimes people don’t respond to posts bc they don’t see the merit in or agree with what you’re saying, and they don't feel the need to comment on it
I think you’re definitely town but I’ve been on a totally different wavelength with you this game. I don’t understand or agree with the points you’re trying to make, and instead of dropping them when people don’t align with them/feel it necessary to interact with them, you bump them up and try to force people to interact with them which is fruitless and ends up in arguments within town which i think is counter-productive
i just felt it necessary to address this bc i don't want you to feel like it's people ignoring you or for you to take it personally
one of the main reasons endless, ace and i didn't even use our quicktopic except literally to discuss mechanics stuff like kills is because endless made the point at the very beginning, which i agreed with, that town are more likely to slip up and have wolftells than wolves are bc town are uninformed, chaotic and totally unpredictable
so if we just let town do that it would work out in our favour
so obviously i agree with daniel that there's no prescribed way for town to behave and i couldn't see the point that alek was making at all that only a wolf could know that because i feel like anyone who's played a game as either alignment would know that. town is messy and makes no sense which is why town often loses
which brings me to:
i hadn't been in the thread for literally hours when you posted this so idk where it came from but i'm definitely not ignoring you, i don't think anyone is. i read every post in the thread and consider everything that is said
Sometimes people don’t respond to posts bc they don’t see the merit in or agree with what you’re saying, and they don't feel the need to comment on it
I think you’re definitely town but I’ve been on a totally different wavelength with you this game. I don’t understand or agree with the points you’re trying to make, and instead of dropping them when people don’t align with them/feel it necessary to interact with them, you bump them up and try to force people to interact with them which is fruitless and ends up in arguments within town which i think is counter-productive
i just felt it necessary to address this bc i don't want you to feel like it's people ignoring you or for you to take it personally
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
DinoTown
Festive Fossil
Each member has a clue, they are told of all options, they can pick who the killer is. This way they can plan around all potential options.
Similar threads
