Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[Antonio]

Oh?

What posts make you think that? I haven't side by side ISO'd either combos yet but what I will say just off the top of my head is that I mindmelded with epona when epona found Volt potentially TMI-y about something? Her Ace read? I'd have to glance back. If it actually was Ace I don't absolutely share that mindmeld anymore due to how Ace has actually been but that points against Ace in a team with Volt maybe.

The Ace read, as I remember. Ace behavior is suspicious since he started acting weird because it's obvious that his actions are intentionally different then to how he played last game. It feels like he is switching his meta on purpose to not appear as Mafia. I don't know how ppl can TR him.

Regarding the Dedenne and Damniel, Dedenne has came to Damniel's defense atleast twice throughout the game. Once when I was pressuring him for an answer and a second time when I laid out my reason to sus him. I feel like Damniel can come to his own defense so I'm curious why Dedenne came to his defense more then once? It's odd, to say the least.

 

[Geoni]

Dan we should play GTH again at some point today, maybe like this time tomorrow, once there's more interactions on the table? Kinda sad I didn't get to participate.

 

[dedenne]

was Cake's posting something you saw as mafia motivated in comparison? you said before you were waiting for a reason to vote someone and were willing to vote anyone in your nulls, but was guava's lack of content town enough that you functionally saved them over anyone else you didn't have strong feelings about one way or another?

yeah, i wouldve rathered a cake elim than guava elim, esp when cake asked who dan was gonna protect, and the whole pointless discussion or no discussion sounded kinda off.

 

[Damniel]

Dan we should play GTH again at some point today, maybe like this time tomorrow, once there's more interactions on the table? Kinda sad I didn't get to participate.

we can do rn too tbh. i feel like all of us read EoD and are pretty active rn

 

[Dinosaurz]

I would shoot all of you

 

[Damniel]

degene is not a priority imo

Post automatically merged: Sep 23, 2020

degene is not a priority imo

dedenne

 

[FinalArcadia]

If mafia knows what kind of clues are going to be given out and likely would choose the most suspected member to put in the kill, dedenne makes sense being that - after the day ended and how it played out - dedenne would reasonably fall under suspicion with how the votes worked out

BUT if they knew the clues, is it possible that mafia chose the person to put in the kill specifically to incriminate someone like dedenne with pointed ears, knowing exactly what I mentioned above that dedenne was likely going to get suspected after D1??

on another note, epona seems like a strong player, so I feel like if they were mafia, they wouldn't kill Glow - who had suspected them - and then mention today about how they thought solving Glow could solve the game? like, I wouldn't keep drawing a connection to Glow if I was maf!epona, idk

 

[dedenne]

im down for gth, depends how long it takes tho. im kinda sleepy

 

[Geoni]

The Ace read, as I remember. Ace behavior is suspicious since he started acting weird because it's obvious that his actions are intentionally different then to how he played last game. It feels like he is switching his meta on purpose to not appear as Mafia. I don't know how ppl can TR him.

Regarding the Dedenne and Damniel, Dedenne has came to Damniel's defense atleast twice throughout the game. Once when I was pressuring him for an answer and a second time when I laid out my reason to sus him. I feel like Damniel can come to his own defense so I'm curious why Dedenne came to his defense more then once? It's odd, to say the least.

I plan on ISOing Dedenne at some point given the stuff I pointed out about her EoD so I guess I'll find those defenses.

To be fair he's always pretty towny in his posting style, even when he was mafia for his first time. It could be defense, yeah. I'm OTF about Volt right now as I'm back and forth glancing at EoD + this SoD? Gonna let her simmer maybe.

 

[Antonio]

I plan on ISOing Dedenne at some point given the stuff I pointed out about her EoD so I guess I'll find those defenses.

To be fair he's always pretty towny in his posting style, even when he was mafia for his first time. It could be defense, yeah. I'm OTF about Volt right now as I'm back and forth glancing at EoD + this SoD? Gonna let her simmer maybe.

Regarding his meta, this is literally the first time he has ever done something like this so it drastically differs from all his previous games, to the point that it's intentional.

 

[voltairenism]

I feel like clue can work in mafia's favor when near eod they use it to push a town wagon that coincidentally has pointy ears

 

[Damniel]

If mafia knows what kind of clues are going to be given out and likely would choose the most suspected member to put in the kill, dedenne makes sense being that - after the day ended and how it played out - dedenne would reasonably fall under suspicion with how the votes worked out

BUT if they knew the clues, is it possible that mafia chose the person to put in the kill specifically to incriminate someone like dedenne with pointed ears, knowing exactly what I mentioned above that dedenne was likely going to get suspected after D1??

on another note, epona seems like a strong player, so I feel like if they were mafia, they wouldn't kill Glow - who had suspected them - and then mention today about how they thought solving Glow could solve the game? like, I wouldn't keep drawing a connection to Glow if I was maf!epona, idk

interesting perspective but half the players are pointed ears so im not gonna go crazy on that rn

i think town glow is just a threat in general, so i could see a team def agree on killing her even if it makes one of them slightly bad. i think epona is one that could shake that off anyways too

 

[Geoni]

If mafia knows what kind of clues are going to be given out and likely would choose the most suspected member to put in the kill, dedenne makes sense being that - after the day ended and how it played out - dedenne would reasonably fall under suspicion with how the votes worked out

BUT if they knew the clues, is it possible that mafia chose the person to put in the kill specifically to incriminate someone like dedenne with pointed ears, knowing exactly what I mentioned above that dedenne was likely going to get suspected after D1??

on another note, epona seems like a strong player, so I feel like if they were mafia, they wouldn't kill Glow - who had suspected them - and then mention today about how they thought solving Glow could solve the game? like, I wouldn't keep drawing a connection to Glow if I was maf!epona, idk

In regards to that point on epona I'm partial to agree with you on that? I mean epona could very well just WIFOM that but right now I want to use Occam's Razor.

 

[Dinosaurz]

I think we should go through glows post now that we have hindsight. She could of said some useful stuff which is why mafia whacked her

 

[Damniel]

im not gonna limit myself to chopping only within the pointed ears group, maybe later on if the clues point more but rn i find it too broad

 

[Geoni]

im down for gth, depends how long it takes tho. im kinda sleepy

Like 22 hours from nowish maybe.

 

[voltairenism]

If mafia knows what kind of clues are going to be given out and likely would choose the most suspected member to put in the kill, dedenne makes sense being that - after the day ended and how it played out - dedenne would reasonably fall under suspicion with how the votes worked out

BUT if they knew the clues, is it possible that mafia chose the person to put in the kill specifically to incriminate someone like dedenne with pointed ears, knowing exactly what I mentioned above that dedenne was likely going to get suspected after D1??

on another note, epona seems like a strong player, so I feel like if they were mafia, they wouldn't kill Glow - who had suspected them - and then mention today about how they thought solving Glow could solve the game? like, I wouldn't keep drawing a connection to Glow if I was maf!epona, idk

thats a good point so im bumping akjhgakj

 

[Dinosaurz]

im not gonna limit myself to chopping only within the pointed ears group, maybe later on if the clues point more but rn i find it too broad

That’s why I said we could use it to eliminate players too

Post automatically merged: Sep 23, 2020

Eliminate the pointy ears

 

[Antonio]

I think we should go through glows post now that we have hindsight. She could of said some useful stuff which is why mafia whacked her

We should also go through cakes post aswell. I'll probably ISO tomorrow morning.

 

[voltairenism]

thats a good point so im bumping akjhgakj

chat too fast it didnt need any bump