Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[Damniel]

tbh dino you needed to put the specifics of these roles in the OP

 

[Dinosaurz]

If you’re vig just shoot hikari and then tell us you were vig after

 

[Damniel]

i cleared the majority of my role through questioning and if youre going to be open about the exacts of each role, it needs to be already listed

Post automatically merged: Sep 23, 2020

learned*

 

[Antonio]

Everyone, answer this question!!!

Are you the doctor? Damniel claimed doctor. Can you CC if you're here?

1. @FinalArcadia (Lolly)
2. @voltairenism (Coco)
3. @dedenne (Anhka)
4. @Ace Marvel (Colton)
5. @guav@ (Monique)
7. @Damniel (Vesta)
9. @Dinosaurz (Pietro)
10. @Hikari (Poncho)
11. @Geoni (Dobie)
12. @epona (Whitney)
14. @shawo (Raymond)

Bringing these questions to the next page.

Answers so far:
9. Can't CC

 

[g u a v a]

i think the pointed ears clue is bait. it narrows the pool down to ~50% (7/12) but it distracts from the other half of players. given that maf know the clue b4 hand like, wouldn't you want to maximize the impact of the clue?? go for something just general enough to cast a wide net of sus but not so specific that u can immediately figure out who it is???

+ its v curious how colton has pointy ears, but not in an obvious way, which is feeding my susses on ace. & re: arcadia, yes i was serious abt sussing volt/ace, it seems too (s)chummy.

 

[Damniel]

alek i think you need to accept that im the only doc claim. maybe ask shawo. but no one else wouldve just let me keep going on like this for this long. you gotta just put that tinfoil hat down

 

[Antonio]

i cleared the majority of my role through questioning and if youre going to be open about the exacts of each role, it needs to be already listed

Post automatically merged: Sep 23, 2020

learned*

Doesn't that go against your earlier statement that you can't protect yourself? The statement that was posted before DinoTown said they could protect themselves. If you "cleared the majority of my role through questioning", why didn't you ask that beforehand?

Post automatically merged: Sep 23, 2020

alek i think you need to accept that im the only doc claim. maybe ask shawo. but no one else wouldve just let me keep going on like this for this long. you gotta just put that tinfoil hat down

Not until I get direct answers from everyone, srry.

Post automatically merged: Sep 23, 2020

@guav@ can you CC damniels claim?

 

[Damniel]

Doesn't that go against your earlier statement that you can't protect yourself? The statement that was posted before DinoTown said they could protect themselves. If you "cleared the majority of my role through questioning", why didn't you ask that beforehand?

i was aware i could protect myself. i lied

 

[g u a v a]

mfw i c dis:

 

[Damniel]

like as mafia i could equally just have asked host if doc could self protect. anyone can ask. i would never fake claim a role if I didn't know the specifics if i could

 

[Antonio]

i was aware i could protect myself. i lied

Oh yeah, I forgot. It was an attempt to fool mafia, you stated.

Post automatically merged: Sep 23, 2020

View attachment 321899
mfw i c dis:
View attachment 321900

I love your memes but can u answer my question.

Post automatically merged: Sep 23, 2020

like as mafia i could equally just have asked host if doc could self protect. anyone can ask. i would never fake claim a role if I didn't know the specifics if i could

I can vouch for this. He did it last game when i hosted.

 

[Dinosaurz]

Alek will never accept

 

[Damniel]

View attachment 321896

i think the pointed ears clue is bait. it narrows the pool down to ~50% (7/12) but it distracts from the other half of players. given that maf know the clue b4 hand like, wouldn't you want to maximize the impact of the clue?? go for something just general enough to cast a wide net of sus but not so specific that u can immediately figure out who it is???

+ its v curious how colton has pointy ears, but not in an obvious way, which is feeding my susses on ace. & re: arcadia, yes i was serious abt sussing volt/ace, it seems too (s)chummy.

i mostly agree with this

host claimed clues aren't meant to mislead, but all we know is that at least one of the wolves if in half of the playlist. this clue is too broad to go solely off that

 

[Antonio]

Alek will never accept

I will accept though when I get answers from everyone. Never is a stretch and you know it.

 

[epona]

@epona do u rlly think guava and dedenne are high priority chops today?

guava no dedenne yes

If the vig is killed, their target will not die.
If vig and Mafia share a target, the target will essentially die twice.

sigh ok don't claim if you exist


@Alek i am officially NOT doctor
but you really have to stop holding ppl to interrogation it clogs the thread

 

[Antonio]

@Alek i am officially NOT doctor
but you really have to stop holding ppl to interrogation it clogs the thread

This would be my last interrogation.

 

[g u a v a]

I love your memes but can u answer my question.

no ur obviously baiting and ill have none of that

 

[Ace Marvel]

I can't CC doctor. @Alek

 

[FinalArcadia]

Are you the doctor? Damniel claimed doctor. Can you CC if you're here?

No, I'm not doctor

 

[Damniel]

vig can just shoot tonight and claim right after. probs shoot a LHF so we dont stay fixated on that but ill leave that up to you

@DinoTown vig kills usually always go through, this is the first time it doesnt and that should be in the OP. i think you need to post the exacts of every single role in the OP if any one of us can ask privately