-
Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.
Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins
- Thread starter DinoTown
- Start date
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
I'm not sure, I was going to back to EoD because I feel how there was 2 votes on lile 5 people was really weird. I didn't like how Ace was lying to save cake, felt like he knew she was going to flip town and buddy up but I'm not sure. His tone feels really like usual town though but I am basically reconsidering
epona would be second sus but it's a mixed bag honestly.
dedenne feel soooo weird this game but it's such an easy wagon
and thats basically it honestly
epona would be second sus but it's a mixed bag honestly.
dedenne feel soooo weird this game but it's such an easy wagon
and thats basically it honestly
DinoTown
Festive Fossil
Yes they can. Except the blackmailer themselves
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
I asked that already, they can.
Post automatically merged:
I want to get a masters in library science in case you guys wanted to know.
Post automatically merged:
in the op it states they can't bm themselves
I just thought of something - if the mafia know what the hint is going to be in advance, it's possible that the options were.
1. Pointed ears.
2. Round ears (or something).
3. Color red.
Obviously I haven't looked into the specifics, but the person who chose the kill could be the group that had the least amount of mafia in it.
Say for example, there's 1 mafia who's in pointed ears (out of 6) and 2 mafia in round ears (out of 4) and 1 person who's red (out of 2) then obviously the mathematical best kill would be the 1 mafia in pointed ears.
Something along those lines could mean something? Like maybe it's best to lynch outside of pointed ears like Daniel was saying, due to the fact that the hint chosen should be the one MOST beneficial to mafia.
I'm not sure how much it matters but the mafia knowing the hint makes the hint so much less useful.
1. Pointed ears.
2. Round ears (or something).
3. Color red.
Obviously I haven't looked into the specifics, but the person who chose the kill could be the group that had the least amount of mafia in it.
Say for example, there's 1 mafia who's in pointed ears (out of 6) and 2 mafia in round ears (out of 4) and 1 person who's red (out of 2) then obviously the mathematical best kill would be the 1 mafia in pointed ears.
Something along those lines could mean something? Like maybe it's best to lynch outside of pointed ears like Daniel was saying, due to the fact that the hint chosen should be the one MOST beneficial to mafia.
I'm not sure how much it matters but the mafia knowing the hint makes the hint so much less useful.
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
Damniel [2]: Ace Marvel, Alek, Hikari
MyLifeIsCake [2]: glow, volt
Hikari [2]:Damniel, Dinosaurz, Damniel
Guava [2]: FinalArcadia, Geoni
Geoni [1]:Damniel, shawo
Dinosaurz [1]: epona
No Elim [1]:Damniel, dedenne
shawo [1]: MyLifeIsCake
Alek [1]: guava
Epona [0]:shawo
Volt [0]:Damniel
at this point, there was cake, hikari, guava and daniel. the thread was hectic
let's say one of cake, guava daniel and hikari are mafia. since they all had "good" reasoning to be sus, at any point a mafia fellow could come up and change their vote and explain why with some bs. (the blackmailer exists, it probably is more of a final days tactic, like easy win gg so if it came in place it would be a little too obvious). anyway, also, if any of cake, guava daniel and hikari are mafia, they are set for the chop within one votes, so it's better to set someone else for it. well so it was cake.
- important to note: after this, dino voted their vote to guava, their motive appeared after guava showed up for no real apparent, some guava post was sus or something. their vote was previously on hikari. fits the criteria.
- ace moved his vote to geoni after this. turned 360 after the doctor claim. his reasoning was.... hm... anyway, even so that geoni said that they felt that ace did that so a teammate could place their vote, it doesnt fit the criteria right now. honestly, they might even back out because geoni said something, but that's a little tinfoil hat
- daniel voted to cake. he did that to save himself.
- guava and dedenne voted on cake. dedenne didnt have that much of a reason at this point. guava didnt really said why she sus cake.
ok so the other way around
- i was confused and voted cake with glow. this is sus, but I know I'm town, you don't, but I gotta be consistent
- ace, alek had clear tunnel on daniel. hikari didnt like how daniel was controlling town (i think?) but it was basically an omgsus. alek and ace were very vocal about their wagon so it could be an easy place to put a vote.
- dino jumped on hikari wagon. they agree'd with me that hikari was weird to sus dino right at the beggining. i assumed i took it too far, but dino thought it was good enough for a vote
- guava was voted by finalarcadia and geoni. final's reasoning feel were a bit weakier than geoni imo. yall gotta iso and decide for yourselves. the second person to vote is weirder in this analysis though, but with low posts from final, geoni probably didnt even know final voted guava so whatever
so with all this.... i feel that dino it's the one that stands out the most. but with all this, it means that dino was saving some one else... so hikari, guava, cake or daniel
for now, lets say daniel is actually doctor, so it's not him. i dont feel like hikari/dino is w/w at all. cake was town. that lefts guava. and.... i dont know....
honestly with all this..... mafia could have just not done this at all lol but well there it is
MyLifeIsCake [2]: glow, volt
Hikari [2]:
Guava [2]: FinalArcadia, Geoni
Geoni [1]:
Dinosaurz [1]: epona
No Elim [1]:
shawo [1]: MyLifeIsCake
Alek [1]: guava
Epona [0]:
Volt [0]:
at this point, there was cake, hikari, guava and daniel. the thread was hectic
let's say one of cake, guava daniel and hikari are mafia. since they all had "good" reasoning to be sus, at any point a mafia fellow could come up and change their vote and explain why with some bs. (the blackmailer exists, it probably is more of a final days tactic, like easy win gg so if it came in place it would be a little too obvious). anyway, also, if any of cake, guava daniel and hikari are mafia, they are set for the chop within one votes, so it's better to set someone else for it. well so it was cake.
- important to note: after this, dino voted their vote to guava, their motive appeared after guava showed up for no real apparent, some guava post was sus or something. their vote was previously on hikari. fits the criteria.
- ace moved his vote to geoni after this. turned 360 after the doctor claim. his reasoning was.... hm... anyway, even so that geoni said that they felt that ace did that so a teammate could place their vote, it doesnt fit the criteria right now. honestly, they might even back out because geoni said something, but that's a little tinfoil hat
- daniel voted to cake. he did that to save himself.
- guava and dedenne voted on cake. dedenne didnt have that much of a reason at this point. guava didnt really said why she sus cake.
ok so the other way around
- i was confused and voted cake with glow. this is sus, but I know I'm town, you don't, but I gotta be consistent
- ace, alek had clear tunnel on daniel. hikari didnt like how daniel was controlling town (i think?) but it was basically an omgsus. alek and ace were very vocal about their wagon so it could be an easy place to put a vote.
- dino jumped on hikari wagon. they agree'd with me that hikari was weird to sus dino right at the beggining. i assumed i took it too far, but dino thought it was good enough for a vote
- guava was voted by finalarcadia and geoni. final's reasoning feel were a bit weakier than geoni imo. yall gotta iso and decide for yourselves. the second person to vote is weirder in this analysis though, but with low posts from final, geoni probably didnt even know final voted guava so whatever
so with all this.... i feel that dino it's the one that stands out the most. but with all this, it means that dino was saving some one else... so hikari, guava, cake or daniel
for now, lets say daniel is actually doctor, so it's not him. i dont feel like hikari/dino is w/w at all. cake was town. that lefts guava. and.... i dont know....
honestly with all this..... mafia could have just not done this at all lol but well there it is
I voted guava to save Daniel after the doctor claim.
i still wanted to lynch hikari but Daniel was set to be lynched
Ugh used wrong words sorry! smh
My memory not good rn I’m tired haha I’ll come back in the morning sorry guys
i still wanted to lynch hikari but Daniel was set to be lynched
Post automatically merged:
Ugh used wrong words sorry! smh
Post automatically merged:
My memory not good rn I’m tired haha I’ll come back in the morning sorry guys
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
my conclusion contradicts the premise lol in sum if you are mafia, you didnt vote to save anyone
??? Ok???
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
basically i took too long on this so im posted even if im wrong lol
Before I read volts post I need to write mine.
So a line I found really interesting on day 1 was.
Daniel saying that Dedenne seemed to be parroting everything they said. The reason this stuck out is because this is a pretty easy "these two aren't both mafia together line."
But other than that I actually went back and checked Dedenne's ISO to say if that was true -but it seems like the entirety of dedenne's game has been responsive, for better or for worse. Nothing I read really made me feel like Dedenne was maf, but nothing they did made me really feel like they were town.
I do think that if Daniel does turn out to be maf it means Dedenne is hard town, just because of that one line.
So a line I found really interesting on day 1 was.
Daniel saying that Dedenne seemed to be parroting everything they said. The reason this stuck out is because this is a pretty easy "these two aren't both mafia together line."
But other than that I actually went back and checked Dedenne's ISO to say if that was true -but it seems like the entirety of dedenne's game has been responsive, for better or for worse. Nothing I read really made me feel like Dedenne was maf, but nothing they did made me really feel like they were town.
I do think that if Daniel does turn out to be maf it means Dedenne is hard town, just because of that one line.
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
you couldnt voted guava to save guava LOL
What
Similar threads
