-
Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.
Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins
- Thread starter DinoTown
- Start date
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
i read volts post
cake/guava/me. Obvs cake is town. If you believe im mafia than that means I claimed to save myself, so my partners didn't need to support me at all. guava was pushed alot and has the most wolf influence in it if it was to save her
we know that cake's wagon was led by glow (town)
Ace and alek tunneled me with hikari just randomly joining in. I dont think ace or alek are mafia tbh. if hikari's slot is mafia, they didn't push my wagon they just joined and dipped
i think guava's wagon was primarily pushed by geo. no one really defended her but me and ace. she could've easily died with a blitz vote
imo, guava is town and wolves just let it happen
at the very least guava is not a wagon i think we should default to
cake/guava/me. Obvs cake is town. If you believe im mafia than that means I claimed to save myself, so my partners didn't need to support me at all. guava was pushed alot and has the most wolf influence in it if it was to save her
we know that cake's wagon was led by glow (town)
Ace and alek tunneled me with hikari just randomly joining in. I dont think ace or alek are mafia tbh. if hikari's slot is mafia, they didn't push my wagon they just joined and dipped
i think guava's wagon was primarily pushed by geo. no one really defended her but me and ace. she could've easily died with a blitz vote
imo, guava is town and wolves just let it happen
Post automatically merged:
at the very least guava is not a wagon i think we should default to
I'm not sure how much the guava counterwagon matters here. If it was TvT then mafia could just vote whoever, if it was TvM then the vote was super close and there was a potential for the wagon on cake to have been mafia lead.
I could go into that but I think most people have already talked about it. Mostly the (big a screenshot by Geoni).
I still don't necessarily think Geoni is town, notably I think I noticed Epona defending Geoni (more like deflecting off) was odd. Like she engaged in what I was saying, said my line of thinking was logical, but suddenly d2 she townreads Geoni. I mean obviously a lot of thought happened between EoD and SoD2, but I still think it was an odd switch to not really be explained. Particularily...
These two posts I noticed while reading the ISO seem kinda contradictory. Epona says she scumread Glow for a sec, (at least I'm interpreting it that way, this ones a little ambiguous.) But follows it up that Daniel's dream towncore existed in Epona's mind?
I'm going to have to say that Epona has played a pretty lackluster game, and the fact that this is potentially a slip (in the sense that Epona forgot her own reads between posts on d2) means I kinda want an explanation because there's a good chance Epona is just hard mafia.
The interesting thing about Epona being hard mafia is that it doesn't actually mean Geoni is mafia or town, not that they have to be teamed or anything. Since there's been more than a few times where mafia just decides to townread someone, not with any particular reason. (usually that's a dead give-away.)
I could go into that but I think most people have already talked about it. Mostly the (big a screenshot by Geoni).
I still don't necessarily think Geoni is town, notably I think I noticed Epona defending Geoni (more like deflecting off) was odd. Like she engaged in what I was saying, said my line of thinking was logical, but suddenly d2 she townreads Geoni. I mean obviously a lot of thought happened between EoD and SoD2, but I still think it was an odd switch to not really be explained. Particularily...
These two posts I noticed while reading the ISO seem kinda contradictory. Epona says she scumread Glow for a sec, (at least I'm interpreting it that way, this ones a little ambiguous.) But follows it up that Daniel's dream towncore existed in Epona's mind?
I'm going to have to say that Epona has played a pretty lackluster game, and the fact that this is potentially a slip (in the sense that Epona forgot her own reads between posts on d2) means I kinda want an explanation because there's a good chance Epona is just hard mafia.
The interesting thing about Epona being hard mafia is that it doesn't actually mean Geoni is mafia or town, not that they have to be teamed or anything. Since there's been more than a few times where mafia just decides to townread someone, not with any particular reason. (usually that's a dead give-away.)
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
geoni pls lead a chop on me i feel too humiliated to stay here
reverse psychology let’s go baby
Ace Marvel
Merry & Happy
Crazy theory: Daniel took a shot, since more people would believe him to be a doctor to out the real doctor and mischop them, since no one claimed, Shawo did, meaning both of them are team and are gaining towncred, but in reality we don't have a doctor.
This quote I think is one of the worst offenders.
@Geoni Can you explain how you reached this conclusion?
From what I can tell you just seperated a list of 6 into 3 groups of 2 and went. Yes, these are mafia.
There wasn't much of a basis. Dedenne/Guava is supported with your previous posts but me/ace doesn't really make much sense as a team. Unless you think both me and Ace voting you means we're both mafia? And arcadia epona?
I mean I think I'd like you to explain this post specifically because it just looks like bull lmao.
Post automatically merged:
Daniel we need to kill ace right now he knows too much.
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
MyLifeIsCake [5]: glow, volt, Damniel, guava, dedenne
Guava [4]: FinalArcadia, Geoni, Dinosaurz, MyLifeIsCake
Geoni [2]: shawo, Ace Marvel
Damniel [2]: Hikari, Alek
Dinosaurz [1]: epona
epona made a passing comment on "Do we vote cake" which was the most off comment IMO from EoD. also no real push on dino today and onto dedenne instead
my and guavas votes were self pres, so NAI there. Dedenne just went on cake and i dont really remember why tbh, but she expressed not being sure on anything at that time
Volt was actually very fluid with voting. they suggested several possible blitz wagons, which i kinda like since maf doesnt usually do things like that since uncontrollable voting is bad for them
Final had an weak TL on cake, so i can kinda get why she didn't vote cake. at the very least she's not teamed with guava since this vote is too close to comfort. geo mainly sussing guava i find is rlly weak since i think he's well aware she's just a wagon everyone tends to default to, and didn't express a strong SR on anyone else. Dino i dont really remember, but given cake was town, it wouldn't make any sense for him to vote guava if she's mafia. i think these votes mean guava is likely town tbh
shawo explains geo's vote long before and was a parked vote. ace i dont really know where the sus comes from since i only remember him believing he was my partner
i think hikaris vote on me is poorly explained and alek had tunnel vision on me
i think epona dino vote is bad and in general her EoD behavior isn't great, but her SoD2 behavior is a bit better
Guava [4]: FinalArcadia, Geoni, Dinosaurz, MyLifeIsCake
Geoni [2]: shawo, Ace Marvel
Damniel [2]: Hikari, Alek
Dinosaurz [1]: epona
epona made a passing comment on "Do we vote cake" which was the most off comment IMO from EoD. also no real push on dino today and onto dedenne instead
my and guavas votes were self pres, so NAI there. Dedenne just went on cake and i dont really remember why tbh, but she expressed not being sure on anything at that time
Volt was actually very fluid with voting. they suggested several possible blitz wagons, which i kinda like since maf doesnt usually do things like that since uncontrollable voting is bad for them
Final had an weak TL on cake, so i can kinda get why she didn't vote cake. at the very least she's not teamed with guava since this vote is too close to comfort. geo mainly sussing guava i find is rlly weak since i think he's well aware she's just a wagon everyone tends to default to, and didn't express a strong SR on anyone else. Dino i dont really remember, but given cake was town, it wouldn't make any sense for him to vote guava if she's mafia. i think these votes mean guava is likely town tbh
shawo explains geo's vote long before and was a parked vote. ace i dont really know where the sus comes from since i only remember him believing he was my partner
i think hikaris vote on me is poorly explained and alek had tunnel vision on me
i think epona dino vote is bad and in general her EoD behavior isn't great, but her SoD2 behavior is a bit better
FinalArcadia
☆ princess of jurai ☆
I didn't even know that there was a vote on me because I click the notifications to go straight here and literally have not seen the vote thread except once this phase lol
Not really sure what to acknowledge though without you noting why exactly the vote is on me. I get that I could come across like lurking mafia because I don't post super often, but (sorry, I know I've mentioned the site I'm from a lot, it's just very different than here in style) I'm still trying to get used to things when I'm from a forum where getting even just 40+ pages for an entire mafia game's worth is high activity at this point
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
im sorry im not a native english speaker so it feels really when i cant explain myself. just forget about it
I think the last two I'm going to write a post about are Alek and Dino.
I said on d1 that I thought dino was mafia because they didn't post any content.
Then they continued to not post any content after acknowledging that, and someone said that they were town because of it.
I don't really think that makes sense, but I do think the dino scumread was probably a bit rushed.
Because alek is ALSO a bunch of filler. (and guava but they said they'll try today.)
Alek's iso didn't really feel reminiscent of the state of the game. If anything their first post (in iso) which they tried to get everyone to look at over and over again was a high effort post, and after that there was a lot of content that didn't really matter.
I've made a similar complaint about Geoni, but I do think they've made.... better(?) posts after catching up to the thread. Which was cool I guess. But I just feel like a lot of Alek's posts come out as "related to the game but not really helpful" kinda similar to... what you'd expect from mafia who wants to post something of value but is a bit awkward about it.
It also kinda reminds me of their game from my very first mafia on this site. Where they were mafia.
Lastly - I said I kinda townread hikari but I'm going to wait for their sub before I give any ~official~ opinion about it.
Finalarcadia idk. They were the one who said that (albeit pretty good) dino line. But I don't have much in the way of an opinion about them.
So yeah, glow's my only townread, ask me anything.
I said on d1 that I thought dino was mafia because they didn't post any content.
Then they continued to not post any content after acknowledging that, and someone said that they were town because of it.
I don't really think that makes sense, but I do think the dino scumread was probably a bit rushed.
Because alek is ALSO a bunch of filler. (and guava but they said they'll try today.)
Alek's iso didn't really feel reminiscent of the state of the game. If anything their first post (in iso) which they tried to get everyone to look at over and over again was a high effort post, and after that there was a lot of content that didn't really matter.
I've made a similar complaint about Geoni, but I do think they've made.... better(?) posts after catching up to the thread. Which was cool I guess. But I just feel like a lot of Alek's posts come out as "related to the game but not really helpful" kinda similar to... what you'd expect from mafia who wants to post something of value but is a bit awkward about it.
It also kinda reminds me of their game from my very first mafia on this site. Where they were mafia.
Lastly - I said I kinda townread hikari but I'm going to wait for their sub before I give any ~official~ opinion about it.
Finalarcadia idk. They were the one who said that (albeit pretty good) dino line. But I don't have much in the way of an opinion about them.
So yeah, glow's my only townread, ask me anything.
FinalArcadia
☆ princess of jurai ☆
ngl, this was an a thought that crossed my mind too, but no doctor seems even wilder than having two
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
check the wolf chat i have a counter plan
oh wait
yea this is better
Post automatically merged:
if no one claimed, why not let me be the only doc claim then lol
Geoni
You're doing great!
Either of y'all give my posts analysis to reach this because I don't recall it and idk, just feels like there is usually more paranoia about me. I townlean both of you fwiw but I wouldn't mind knowing how you reached this?
I was going to delete this from the quote group I got for this post but I'm keeping it just for the sake of it not aging well cause I woulda told you to just wait for him to claim something.
They can act as town leader but not someone like guava so yeah. I'm still here on that.
@Alek please don't do this again, just wait for someone to cc and if nobody does just assume uncc'd. I know when I'm wolfing I find prs by seeing how everyone handles talking about or and I don't think you mean harm by it but it can be harmful.
If DinoTown is baiting as a host what game did I even join lol?
Why does this feed your susses on Ace and Arcadia alone like...what was your read there before cause I don't have that readslist right in front of me.
You yes-manning the volt/Ace thing is concerning to say the least.
Big old bullpoop right here.
I'd still be willing to vote Shawo today.
It really depends on whether or not mafia knows what the clue will be ahead of time. They'll send whoever can handle being in the group affected by the riddle regardless of them being godfather or mafia pr. Speaking of which a godfather not mind it at all if it baits an inspection onto them, especially if they know the clue beforehand. Feels like you are going in a strangled direction with the information we have.
Veto'd
Same applies to this in regards to the 'mafia has to blackmail them' thing. If you know something is super stupid you're just performing.
This felt like an unfaked moment where Alek lacked the information a member of the mafia team would have had so I feel the townread reinforced.
If I don't consider it content then it's not content!
But yeah I haven't actually iso'd you since that one time d1, and I wasn't here for EoD to make any large assumptions.
but man it's like, when I skimread the thread, usually it's really easy to tell who's been participating in the thread based on who I remember. And I do not remember a single post from you.
Like at all.
But yeah I haven't actually iso'd you since that one time d1, and I wasn't here for EoD to make any large assumptions.
but man it's like, when I skimread the thread, usually it's really easy to tell who's been participating in the thread based on who I remember. And I do not remember a single post from you.
Like at all.
Ace Marvel
Merry & Happy
Because no one really bought your claim and it open the perfect window to do something like this, specially something Shawo has no problem doing.
Geoni have you considered catching up to the thread before you make a big wallpost that's not relevant to the state of the game :')
Even if you want to vote me there's no point, going in docs is suboptimal, there's no RB so at the very least, you can get me IF daniel ever dies.
I mean I think this wallpost has the same issue as all of your previous wallposts. Where you talk about stuff that's so far back and trying to keep it relevant... and then it's just... not? I feel like you've brought up topics we've already talked about and it's genuinely hard to get a read on you for it.
Echoing thoughts is usually an sr, but in your case it's hard to read because I genuinely do not think you have caught up to page 81 yet. You're just.... posting.
Even if you want to vote me there's no point, going in docs is suboptimal, there's no RB so at the very least, you can get me IF daniel ever dies.
I mean I think this wallpost has the same issue as all of your previous wallposts. Where you talk about stuff that's so far back and trying to keep it relevant... and then it's just... not? I feel like you've brought up topics we've already talked about and it's genuinely hard to get a read on you for it.
Echoing thoughts is usually an sr, but in your case it's hard to read because I genuinely do not think you have caught up to page 81 yet. You're just.... posting.
? Do you mean like any posts. or just big posts.
Similar threads
