Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[Damniel]

geo, please tell me the wolf motivation for shawo claiming, if you believe im town as well

This felt like an unfaked moment where Alek lacked the information a member of the mafia team would have had so I feel the townread reinforced.

what. dino literally announced it in signups

 

[Geoni]

Anyways, the interesting thing about the daniel/dedenne interactions is that Daniel was Ace's d1 tunnel (til they claimed doc) followed by dedenne.

If you assume that 1/2 are mafia, then how you read the hard push is up to you. I mean Ace has done almost nothing but tunnel (not even with much of a backing.)

But if you assume that Ace is mafia, does that mean you're treating Daniel/Dedenne as both town? Or is the ace push a buss so that when they die/their tunnel dies, they can potentially "clear" one of their tunnel targets for being the hard tunnel.

In b4 you lead this onto me. Ace didn't remotely treat his wolf partners that way last time anyways.

 

[Dinosaurz]

I have been contributing and asking questions. Putting my reads on members.

like I have been vocal idk where you’re coming from honestly

 

[Damniel]

I have been contributing and asking questions. Putting my reads on members.

like I have been vocal idk where you’re coming from honestly

early D1 dino wasn't that great but I think the EoD and SoD behavior reads more of a player on their own, so a town

Post automatically merged: Sep 23, 2020

hikari's slot im cool with letting be so we give the sub a chance

 

[shawo]

? Do you mean like any posts. or just big posts.

Well usually I don't remember small posts, or the exact wording of big posts, but I guess in this case what I'm saying is. I have a general (if at least flawed) idea of what most of the people in the game think and why. For you, and guava, and alek, I don't really have any clue what your reads/takes have been.

I usually use this as a defacto mafread, because the idea goes "if someone isn't posting content that's meaningful enough for me to care, then they're probably mafia."

I don't necessarily think the inverse is true, unless it's a new player.

 

[Geoni]

geo, please tell me the wolf motivation for shawo claiming, if you believe im town as well


what. dino literally announced it in signups

Because it gives him a means to come off as towny, to put it simply. I don't trust a second doc being in this for a second.

 

[shawo]

I don't actually think you're mafia insomuch, but I still think the reason I mafread you in the first place is valid. I've not seen any posts from you that feel particularily towny, if you wanted me to put a word to it. But I guess to give you credit, I also haven't seen a post that makes you explicitly mafia.

I'm much more inclined to go alek if I had to choose between the three of you rn.

But I think my current largest SR is epona.
Still waiting for her response to my post before I vote.

 

[FinalArcadia]

Dino, Alek, Geoni, and Volt are top townreads btw

Epona I'm not super concerned with either but I do think some valid points have been brought up about Epona's posts so I may need to reread some of their content

really not sure how to unpack the shawo/dan situation with the doctor claims, need to think on that more but I agree that it's probably something to be resolved later on (as in, not where votes need to be going atm) instead of now so we don't risk losing a doctor.

Ace is almost so suspicious that they loop back around to being fine, mainly on account of me not being sure why they'd draw attention to their self with the extreme tunneling on specific players when all it takes is one dying and potentially flipping town (or, if they wanted to clear a partner, accidentally getting their partner killed if people actually followed their tunneling) for things to go wrong

Dedenne I wouldn't be opposed to voting, but I'm kinda wondering if what I mentioned before about being framed through the clue could be a possibility; I'd mafia lean more on guava than Dedenne and prefer that

whoever else is left, I don't have enough opinion on off the top of my head

 

[Damniel]

Because it gives him a means to come off as towny, to put it simply. I don't trust a second doc being in this for a second.

im good with solving him later but this motivation is kinda the WIFOM route and more tinfoily. im not into tinfoils for D2

Post automatically merged: Sep 23, 2020

But I think my current largest SR is epona.
Still waiting for her response to my post before I vote.

she's a european so youre gonna wait a while

 

[Dinosaurz]

It almost 3am I’m going to bed lol good point daniel

 

[Damniel]

shawo alek is really trying to push their own plans that dont really end well for one reason or another and is generally explosive, which i think matches more of town meta. wolf alek i find is more passive and doesnt make bold moves but instead blends in pretty well

 

[Ace Marvel]

I have been contributing and asking questions. Putting my reads on members.

like I have been vocal idk where you’re coming from honestly

Don't worry about it this is me 99% of the time, just have fun.

 

[Geoni]

This quote I think is one of the worst offenders.

@Geoni Can you explain how you reached this conclusion?

From what I can tell you just seperated a list of 6 into 3 groups of 2 and went. Yes, these are mafia.

There wasn't much of a basis. Dedenne/Guava is supported with your previous posts but me/ace doesn't really make much sense as a team. Unless you think both me and Ace voting you means we're both mafia? And arcadia epona?

I mean I think I'd like you to explain this post specifically because it just looks like bull lmao.

Post automatically merged: Sep 23, 2020

Daniel we need to kill ace right now he knows too much.

You didn't read what I said about Ace EoD? Not only that but your vote on me was based on a really poorly constructed meta case and Ace doesn't even explain his sus/tunnel on me with any analysis at all and he pushed wagons on really thin reasoning when I watched him wolf.

Ace doesn't fit with guava if guava is wolf because the wagons were so close and he avoided bussing let alone interacting much with his team, hence why the world's are splitting for me a bit.

 

[Ace Marvel]

You didn't read what I said about Ace EoD? Not only that but your vote on me was based on a really poorly constructed meta case and Ace doesn't even explain his sus/tunnel on me with any analysis at all and he pushed wagons on really thin reasoning when I watched him wolf.

Ace doesn't fit with guava if guava is wolf because the wagons were so close and he avoided bussing let alone interacting much with his team, hence why the world's are splitting for me a bit.

Your both a wolf villager and a wolf, and this time wolf does not cancel the other wolf.

 

[shawo]

Spoiler: Epona looking kinda sus

(idk why but I looked up if whitney had pointed ears even though Daniel's image is... whitney... with pointed ears.)

 

[Ace Marvel]

Also killing glow is so old school, I can totally see the older players being in the mafia team.

 

[shawo]

So you think two mafia are pushing you with both a... badly constructed meta case and no case at all?

 

[Damniel]

Spoiler: Epona looking kinda sus

(idk why but I looked up if whitney had pointed ears even though Daniel's image is... whitney... with pointed ears.)

good sir this is Fang

 

[shawo]

hm.

So it seems.

 

[Damniel]

Also killing glow is so old school, I can totally see the older players being in the mafia team.

why do you think this, killing glow asap was a 2016 thing and you joined recently