• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

MyLifeIsCake said:
^^ I always try to start D1 with a joke or some less serious conversation, there is little to contribute when there hasn't been any deaths, especially for this style of game. Voting ealry D1 is always a shot in the dark and I don't know if its worth just voting someone on a hunch esp if they haven't posted yet. I'd like to hear from everybody before I make a decision yet. Imo D1 is the worst day for gathering info and I feel bad for whoever gets chopped without getting to contribute much to the game
(that was me a few games ago :<)
Click to expand...

white text mafia confirmed
 
Damniel said:
giving something for people to respond to just for the sake of them to post something doesn’t do much good. the only somewhat good question there is on who you read best, but even that and all other questions are just fluff

if you have an opinion to make, do it anyways. a RQS should not need to prompt that
Click to expand...
Jesus christ dude, I'm aware that you want to take control of the narrative regarding this game to look townie but can you not devalue my attempts at gathering others perspectives on this game because you want to do whatever you have been doing, thx. It's too late now to gather those opinions because damniel puts false doubt into the requests so I'm going to tackle damniels statement above.

First of all, this isn't because I "wanted people to post just to post", it was to gather opinions. I wanted to see people's current opinions, especially opinions that haven't stated? Second, the first 3 questions were filler because everyone regardless of alignment would respond honestly to those questions then they would most likely, psychologically answer the 4/5 questions with honesty. Then I would question their opinions and determine for myself if they are coming from a town or mafia perspective. Finally, we could've have gathered more opinions if prompted then if it wasn't prompted.

You ruined my attempted man, now I can't catch any.
Post automatically merged:

Those grammar mistakes, UGH!
Post automatically merged:

Alek said:
You ruined my bait man, now I can't catch any.
Click to expand...
Post automatically merged:

Alek said:
it was to gather opinions. I wanted to see people's current opinions, especially opinions that haven't stated.
Click to expand...
 
explosiveness from alek is an early town sign

i mean, you didn't really have to admit your own reasoning for it. you couldve ignored my response or say its still good to answer. epona has also been anti RQS and cake was the only one to agree with me, is this AI of cake? not really, she did in fact state her opinion so far
 
Damniel said:
explosiveness from alek is an early town sign

i mean, you didn't really have to admit your own reasoning for it. you couldve ignored my response or say its still good to answer. epona has also been anti RQS and cake was the only one to agree with me, is this AI of cake? not really, she did in fact state her opinion so far
Click to expand...
It wasn't the matter of being Anti-rqs, is the matter of putting doubt into my attempts. A simple "it's still good to answer" wouldn't have gone to anywhere because of everyone's doubt.
Post automatically merged:

The only way to disprove your unnecessary doubts was to come forward with my intentions. Regardless, it's too late and asking for a prompt now would lead to some dishonesty.
 
Alek said:
It wasn't the matter of being Anti-rqs, is the matter of putting doubt into my attempts. A simple "it's still good to answer" wouldn't have gone to anywhere because of everyone's doubt.
Click to expand...
i hate RQSs so i wouldve opposed anyone who tried to post one. you didn't really need to already admit defeat so early when only two people chose not to respond to it, but no big deal really. i think you overestimated the influence I have on people already when no one seems to trust me yet
Post automatically merged:

like you didn't need to disprove me really, ignoring me wouldve worked
 
Damniel said:
i hate RQSs so i wouldve opposed anyone who tried to post one. you didn't really need to already admit defeat so early when only two people chose not to respond to it, but no big deal really. i think you overestimated the influence I have on people already when no one seems to trust me yet
Click to expand...
Maybe because you have an influence on me that I'm assuming others have it aswell. I mean, I don't trust you either but you do have an larger impact on this game compared to others due to your experience. That's just my perspective of things. Trust and Impact don't really correlate either.
 
eh i think you couldve just still left it up and could conclude that people not answering either dont like QRSs or were agreeing with me (either of which i dont find helpful in formulating a read). But now to your own admission to the intention behind it, there's def no reason for anyone to answer it anymore

people will give opinions if they want to say something, or you could just ask them directly if its not clear. Town will usually always answer truthfully on their current opinions and a wolf will answer the first 3 truthfully but HAS to lie about their opinions, so i dont see the logic. I dont really see that much benefit to a RQS this late, even with the reasoning you provided, but the explosive reaction matches up with previous Alek town plays so im fine with that for now i guess
Post automatically merged:

anyway off the class will be back in a few hours
 
Regardless of if you think I should've stuck with it, I don't see it working as much when there was too much doubt that couldn't be disproven unless I came forward. Even if I stuck with it, the people here would've stuck with their opinions and it if I said "just go with it", people would've just assume I'm up to something and would most likely lie.

Mafia would've also been most likely to not come up with an opinions or come up with an opinion that lack a proper reason then to lie with a reason.

Anyways, I have too much doubt on my mind.
 
Guys if I go afk it’s because I’ve been banned or something (idk if new tbt shows if ur banned).
also my reads rn. I think Daniel is sus just because of the way he’s trying to control everyone seems fish to me.
 
MyLifeIsCake said:
^^ I always try to start D1 with a joke or some less serious conversation, there is little to contribute when there hasn't been any deaths, especially for this style of game. Voting ealry D1 is always a shot in the dark and I don't know if its worth just voting someone on a hunch esp if they haven't posted yet. I'd like to hear from everybody before I make a decision yet. Imo D1 is the worst day for gathering info and I feel bad for whoever gets chopped without getting to contribute much to the game
(that was me a few games ago :<)
Click to expand...
IM SORRY

Dinosaurz said:
Did voting geoni really have any meaningful outcome
Click to expand...
it was BAIT why did i wake up to dan repeating himself over and over

Damniel said:
I found hikari’s reactions a little bit odd! they didnt seem to be questioning ace at all, which is interesting to vote for later!
Post automatically merged:

note* not vote. but i did indeed just vote hikari!
Click to expand...
why is anyone questioning ace lol i mean i said my reasoning on why but everyone else just accepted it's good ol town ace i guess? even the ones that dont really know him?

also what happened i didnt read all this wall texts
 
Dinosaurz said:
Guys if I go afk it’s because I’ve been banned or something (idk if new tbt shows if ur banned).
also my reads rn. I think Daniel is sus just because of the way he’s trying to control everyone seems fish to me.
Click to expand...
why are you always getting banned
 
Alek said:
why are you always getting banned
Click to expand...
i Cannot speak


i just want you guys to be aware so it doesn’t effect the game if I bounce. Like effect the reads or anything it’s out of my control. That’s all.
Post automatically merged:

Cause I know inactivity can effect reads on people
 
@DinoTown is there a mafia that leads the kill and if yes are they the one who that the clues will talk abt
Post automatically merged:

im just thinking how mafia will work around the clues thing
 
voltairenism said:
@DinoTown is there a mafia that leads the kill and if yes are they the one who that the clues will talk abt
Post automatically merged:

im just thinking how mafia will work around the clues thing
Click to expand...
Yes, there is a maf that leads the kill and the clue will be for them.
 
ok so, mafia will probably have their most sussed one leading the kill. thoughts?
Post automatically merged:

also these are roles for semi open. one of them is not included obvs but I dont know much abt balancing game to know who

ofc the goon would be the one to lead the kill if there is one in mafia team

-Regular Goon
-Godfather
-Mafia-aligned Role Cop
-Blackmailer - a blackmailed person's vote will not be included in the final vote tally of the day.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

EvilTheCat6600
Goodbye And Good Riddance To My Second Island
Replies
0
Views
220
EvilTheCat6600
EvilTheCat6600
Alolan_Apples
Island Improvements Questionnaire:
Replies
9
Views
306
Asarena
Asarena
Plum Pudding
Question regarding Harvey's Island
Replies
5
Views
158
J087
J087
mayor.lauren
Buying Cataloguing?
Replies
0
Views
86
mayor.lauren
mayor.lauren
Jeremy
  • Locked
  • Poll
Besting Blunders - Community Voting
Replies
4
Views
884
ShawnFuzz
ShawnFuzz
Back
Top