• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

Why couldn't my question get top-paged smh
Post automatically merged:

Everyone not Dan/Shawo, gun to head, if there was one mafia between Dan and Shawo who do you think it is? Neither is not an acceptable answer.
 
Everyone not Dan/Shawo, gun to head, if there was one mafia between Dan and Shawo who do you think it is? Neither is not an acceptable answer.
If one was mafia, I'd go with Dan; I think there's more mafia motivation for his claim given that his wagon had a chance of going through + his reaction to shawo's claim was very accepting of there being possibly two doctors. If someone straight up CC'd me, I'd immediately be suspicious of them. Shawo would I think be trying harder to push as a "town" leader and hard CC if he was mafia, because otherwise what's even the point of the claim
 
Everyone not Dan/Shawo, gun to head, if there was one mafia between Dan and Shawo who do you think it is? Neither is not an acceptable answer.

Damniel, but you already know this.

Why not Shawo, the lack of reaction, unless you told him, I don't see mafia not even saying wait a second. Not a single vote for Shawo is worrying after that claim.
 
If one was mafia, I'd go with Dan; I think there's more mafia motivation for his claim given that his wagon had a chance of going through + his reaction to shawo's claim was very accepting of there being possibly two doctors. If someone straight up CC'd me, I'd immediately be suspicious of them. Shawo would I think be trying harder to push as a "town" leader and hard CC if he was mafia, because otherwise what's even the point of the claim
can the same not be said for shawo, who said there could be two doctors and I could be town?

Ive outlined why i went along with it for a bit
 
can the same not be said for shawo, who said there could be two doctors and I could be town?
to be fair, you have a valid point there. I do find it extremely odd that both of you did it; I get the thing with thinking the other could be Lucky, but it's just weird to me when it would definitely not be my reaction, even if admittedly I'm not the type to make big plays and plan like that lol
 
to be fair, you have a valid point there. I do find it extremely odd that both of you did it; I get the thing with thinking the other could be Lucky, but it's just weird to me when it would definitely not be my reaction, even if admittedly I'm not the type to make big plays and plan like that lol
i mean you saw how i was willing to fake claim masons last game lol
 
If Shawo wants to be pro-town and it's another fake claim from him he can admit he's bullpooping. As it stands I'm not giving his reasoning a D3 pass because that feels like it's exactly what it's potentially engineered for. And if it's wolf-shawo-engineered it means he has a really low opinion of our mechanical understanding, and I don't think he has that low of an opinion of me?
Post automatically merged:

Re: vote thread

Dedenne > Arcadia
Post automatically merged:

We're not making Arcadia a competing wagon anyways though. Nor myself. And I'd like to get to the bottom of this doctor nonsense if both remain hard on their claims.
Post automatically merged:

Speaking of voting you 18+ Americans better register to vote!!!!
Post automatically merged:

Before I forget: Ace literally said his reason for deathtunneling me was because of my catchup posts being 'behind on the threadstate' which is just an echo of the bullpoop Shawo spouted D1 against me.
 
Last edited:
if shawo enters a direct CC with me, the conflict will be resolved either way i guess. though i won't let myself die first
Post automatically merged:

i voted arcadia to see how she'd react to it but haven't had a need to change it yet. mostly waiting to see shawo at this point
 
I really need for Shawo to definitively come back and admit if he's faking or hardclaiming doc because as it stands my two trusted townies (Arcadia and Epona) think Dan looks worse than Shawo and my other trusted townie (Alek) is set to be modkilled.

And this whole debacle is making me forget how much I'm still not a fan of guava.
 
I mean my entire thesis was that dan was mafia here but then the whole lucky fakeclaim dawned on me. Which u can see in real time with my ‘oh. Wait’ right before I went to buy my new TV lol
Post automatically merged:

Still don’t really see the merit in voting there today though
 
Yeah but if Shawo were doing it I woulda thought he'd do it at EoD because bait? That would be the Shawo thing to do.
Post automatically merged:

How has this already surpassed the page count for Karen mafia by middle of day 2? Where was this energy in my game? >:0
 
Yeah but if Shawo were doing it I woulda thought he'd do it at EoD because bait? That would be the Shawo thing to do.
Post automatically merged:

How has this already surpassed the page count for Karen mafia by middle of day 2? Where was this energy in my game? >:0
Cause I wasn’t in your game :love:
 
Back
Top