Almost forgot to do these! To be honest, I don't have super strong feelings about any of the jocks. Even the ones I like I'm not SUPER excited about. But, I think Samson and Teddy are really cute. Mack, too. And Coach has grown on me since I've had him in my town!
And, Pierce. His design is not my favorite BUT I have fun memories with him. Back in the original game, he lived in my BFF's town, and when we picked our "boyfriends" she picked him as hers (back then, sometimes the jocks could have kinda flirty dialogue as I remember it... also, we were dorky preteens). Then, he moved and she was sad. THEN he showed up in my town and she was legit annoyed with me for a minute, like I "stole" her boyfriend
She got over it quick, of course, but it was funny, and for some reason I remember that. Dunno if she would. He ended up living in my town for a really long time! I... don't actually remember him moving out?
For that reason, I'd definitely take Pierce in my town!
Also, I know Genji tends to be popular... but I just can't get that excited about him for some reason.