Mafia June 2020 Mafia Game Thread [DAY 2 ENDS AT 6/20 5PM PST]

@epona why the slight town lean on lothiline?

looks to me like a nervous townie who isn't quite confident enough to make actual bold statements but is trying to respond to things/participate in the conversation to be helpful anyway

their posts just aren't reading like scum to me
 
prelim readlist

town:
epona

townleans:
ness
daniel

slight townleans:
lothiline
aerious

null:
pinkshade
fefirly
shawo
toads
frogslime
heyden (true null bc no posts yet)
bianca

null but leaning more scummy than the above nulls:
sensai
teddy345
punchy
mayor leaf
glow


i think that's everyone. to be honest i don't feel like i have anything concrete on anybody atm, the majority of the above is pure gut feeling lol but just wanted to put it out there to see if it generates any discussion

can you expand on the slightly more scummy nulls? particularly glow and punchy?
 
I think leaf is town.

Also toads posts were highly antagonistic, and I think there's a major difference between "voting someone because I think the antagonism wasn't justified at the point in the game we were in", versus voting someone because they were being antagonistic.

I will admit that the posts I've made were cherrypicked, but they were also 4 posts in order around when I was around, hence why I chose those posts.

Toads also has a lot better posts after that point - so I'm going to start looking at the other people who've made an attempt to scumread me for "being weird."

Also there was mostly a major shift in tone because I didn't have time to fully write out my sentences, I'll refrain from checking forum mafia while I'm at work unless it's reaching end of day.
Post automatically merged:

I think there's a good chance what ace is doing right now is scum-motivated.
I'd probably look back at their reaction to a random quickvote (mine) and reference it to the equivalent of them doing the same.

However, the fact that ace didn't just attempt to jump on me makes me want to think they aren't mafia, so I guess the next question would be.

"Why are you so sure on glow given how few posts she's (anyone's) made this game?"
 
I think leaf is town.

Also toads posts were highly antagonistic, and I think there's a major difference between "voting someone because I think the antagonism wasn't justified at the point in the game we were in", versus voting someone because they were being antagonistic.

I will admit that the posts I've made were cherrypicked, but they were also 4 posts in order around when I was around, hence why I chose those posts.

Toads also has a lot better posts after that point - so I'm going to start looking at the other people who've made an attempt to scumread me for "being weird."

Also there was mostly a major shift in tone because I didn't have time to fully write out my sentences, I'll refrain from checking forum mafia while I'm at work unless it's reaching end of day.
Post automatically merged:

I think there's a good chance what ace is doing right now is scum-motivated.
I'd probably look back at their reaction to a random quickvote (mine) and reference it to the equivalent of them doing the same.

However, the fact that ace didn't just attempt to jump on me makes me want to think they aren't mafia, so I guess the next question would be.

"Why are you so sure on glow given how few posts she's (anyone's) made this game?"

Glow is the answer, join my wagon.
 
I really don’t understand why anyone is suspicious of glow

tbh for me it's because two of her three posts are townreading me off the bat which i'm wary of

definitely not considering voting for her or anyone really until i see more. it's been a slow day so far, a decent enough amount of posts but the content is a whole lot of nothing really
 
Haven't read a whole lot of posts, and probably won't be able to till later, I'll be back before the lynch though, whenever that is.

I read all of Mayor Leafs posts and I really like them. That's really all I can say about it, I feel like some of their earlier posts were super genuine, and even if the quality of their like, last post wasn't the highest, I still think they're probably one of the towniest people here.

Then again, everyone who I don't recognize has their posts blend together to me.

So this isn't at all a final read.
 
Ace looks like they're digging for reactions, so the question is are they pretending to do it as mafia or doing it as town?
 
Ace looks like they're digging for reactions, so the question is are they pretending to do it as mafia or doing it as town?
Thank you very much! AHHHH no it's useless.

Townish:
Mayor
Epona
Ness
 
Toads also has a lot better posts after that point - so I'm going to start looking at the other people who've made an attempt to scumread me for "being weird."

Also there was mostly a major shift in tone because I didn't have time to fully write out my sentences, I'll refrain from checking forum mafia while I'm at work unless it's reaching end of day.
Are you just done with toadsworthy now? What changed?
 
I'm not taking the horns down
7MaiExG.png
 
Thank you very much! AHHHH no it's useless.

Townish:
Mayor
Epona
Ness
why unvote and comply with us after people start thinking your intentions are leaning on scum? who do you think is mafia as of current?
 
i think that's everyone. to be honest i don't feel like i have anything concrete on anybody atm, the majority of the above is pure gut feeling lol but just wanted to put it out there to see if it generates any discussion
I agree, (and mostly agree with your list, but Shawo is a little on ths scummy side for me)
@epona why the slight town lean on lothiline?

.. also y’all keep spelling my name wrong..
 
Bianca Eeny, meeny, miny, moe, threw me off, and Daniel kind saying it was possible, so I'll have them at null.
Post automatically merged:

why do i have an emoji
Because I'm decorating with "stickers"
 
Back
Top