Mafia June 2020 Mafia Game Thread [DAY 2 ENDS AT 6/20 5PM PST]

[g u a v a]

i'm failing to see why dan is pushing so hard on sensai. it's not feeling pro town because they haven't been as big a distraction as toad. i understand wanting to avoid potentially eliminating the wrong person but sensai just seems wishy washy not scummy. not town reading them at all but i'd rather town reach a more logical consensus.

My intention here is to save punchy, would you let me join your toads wagon?

permission to jump ship granted. why do you want to save punchy?

 

[shawo]

Like I figure cady is a sub, but who for.

 

[Damniel]

what have i done other than not do anything for like 90% of the day

exactly. you only come in to try to lead town in the chaos of EoD when you you've tried doing that the whole day

 

[Aerious]

Can I join I'll take anything possible

im cackling holy ****

Exactly this, sorry Punchy I tried, but I wasn't able. I honestly think we are killing town here.

who is scumleaning to you? you've tried to say me and toads and try for a wagon w/o providing any evidence as to why punchy is town

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I've said Shawo but this was overlooked earlier

alright then advocate for it

imo shawo/toads was pretty v/v

 

[Ace Marvel]

permission to jump ship granted. why do you want to save punchy?

Because helpful, not really, but I see a lot of me in his play style, just more agro.

 

[N e s s]

Look I'm just going to be blunt, we have hardly discussed Aerious this entire phase and I think it's extremely freaking careless to be starting this wagon an hour before we're about to end Day 1. We get hardly any information from the Aerious wagon, this is just ASKING for chaos in 10 minutes before EoD. What we should be doing is establish a civil coalition on what we currently have and work off of that Day 2, I don't want to see panicking 10 minutes before Night 1 starts and you blitz someone random.

If any of you switch to Aerious just because punchy said "zomg she has aggressive tone" I will hit each and every one of you with a shoe. This is a complete non-case with the only point of reference being that she is "weird" for arguing with toadsworthy.

Anyway I think it should be SensaiGallade. I really don't know why anyone thinks that this is town for whatever reason:

I asked that earlier and Ace said they were trying to get a rise and reaction out of people

I doubt anything I say will change the bandwagon on me so it is what it is, voting Punchy even if I feel like he isn't scum.

They literally admitted they don't care if Punchy is town or scum, I really don't get how you're all seeing this is okay. I read this as Sensai being resigned and is there only stand left to survive, almost like they were banking on Punchy not being here for EoD.

I don't know if Punchy is town or scum, but I find myself aligning more with it being Sensai now. And we're sure as hell not going to be doing some random crap just because Punchy is saying the same thing with every post he makes. Stop it with the commotion and go with what we've been talking about this entire phase.

 

[Ace Marvel]

vote: CADYCAT!

 

[Damniel]

i'm failing to see why dan is pushing so hard on sensai. it's not feeling pro town because they haven't been as big a distraction as toad. i understand wanting to avoid potentially eliminating the wrong person but sensai just seems wishy washy not scummy. not town reading them at all but i'd rather town reach a more logical consensus.

toads and aerious drove each other to the brink of both wanting to sub out i think its just an emotional tunnel fight

 

[shawo]

I think daniel is mafia tbh

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

Don't have time to reread but I hate how they're playing end of day.

 

[epona]

what have i done other than not do anything for like 90% of the day

that is fiarl

Look I'm just going to be blunt, we have hardly discussed Aerious this entire phase and I think it's extremely freaking careless to be starting this wagon an hour before we're about to end Day 1. We get hardly any information from the Aerious wagon, this is just ASKING for chaos in 10 minutes before EoD. What we should be doing is establish a civil coalition on what we currently have and work off of that Day 2, I don't want to see panicking 10 minutes before Night 1 starts and you blitz someone random.

If any of you switch to Aerious just because punchy said "zomg she has aggressive tone" I will hit each and every one of you with a shoe. This is a complete non-case with the only point of reference being that she is "weird" for arguing with toadsworthy.

Anyway I think it should be SensaiGallade. I really don't know why anyone thinks that this is town for whatever reason:

They literally admitted they don't care if Punchy is town or scum, I really don't get how you're all seeing this is okay. I read this as Sensai being resigned and is there only stand left to survive, almost like they were banking on Punchy not being here for EoD.

I don't know if Punchy is town or scum, but I find myself aligning more with it being Sensai now. And we're sure as hell not going to be doing some random crap just because Punchy is saying the same thing with every post he makes. Stop it with the commotion and go with what we've been talking about this entire phase.

hard hard agree with everything in this post

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

WOW that messed up. the first bit was supposed to say 'that is fairly damning'

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Look I'm just going to be blunt, we have hardly discussed Aerious this entire phase and I think it's extremely freaking careless to be starting this wagon an hour before we're about to end Day 1. We get hardly any information from the Aerious wagon, this is just ASKING for chaos in 10 minutes before EoD. What we should be doing is establish a civil coalition on what we currently have and work off of that Day 2, I don't want to see panicking 10 minutes before Night 1 starts and you blitz someone random.

If any of you switch to Aerious just because punchy said "zomg she has aggressive tone" I will hit each and every one of you with a shoe. This is a complete non-case with the only point of reference being that she is "weird" for arguing with toadsworthy.

Anyway I think it should be SensaiGallade. I really don't know why anyone thinks that this is town for whatever reason:

They literally admitted they don't care if Punchy is town or scum, I really don't get how you're all seeing this is okay. I read this as Sensai being resigned and is there only stand left to survive, almost like they were banking on Punchy not being here for EoD.

I don't know if Punchy is town or scum, but I find myself aligning more with it being Sensai now. And we're sure as hell not going to be doing some random crap just because Punchy is saying the same thing with every post he makes. Stop it with the commotion and go with what we've been talking about this entire phase.

no!

they led the toads argument on and on and on until he wanted to sub out

toads did keep feeding the fire but that's toads

i can see sensai saying that like an hour ago i really hadn't done that much

sensai not trying is more town ai then scum ai imo

 

[g u a v a]

toads and aerious drove each other to the brink of both wanting to sub out i think its just an emotional tunnel fight

i guess the reason i dont fully buy this is more of a game mechanic question. if i were to say "whatever im gonna replace out" in thread but then never follow through with DMing the host, would the host take this request seriously?

 

[epona]

I think daniel is mafia tbh

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

Don't have time to reread but I hate how they're playing end of day.

if sensai is the elim and he flips town i will be looking at daniel tomorrow

 

[Aerious]

no!

they led the toads argument on and on and on until he wanted to sub out

toads did keep feeding the fire but that's toads

i can see sensai saying that like an hour ago i really hadn't done that much

sensai not trying is more town ai then scum ai imo

i mentioned wanting to sub out first in thread. this is a logical fallacy

 

[Feferily]

I'm just going to say I am against not culling anybody in today's vote. It's towns only try every cycle and like Shawo mentioned it will lose us information we could have gotten. Vital information. Regardless of if we incorrectly elimate somebody. I think the most recent wagons should be condensed and we should be looking more critically on the two or so that can be realistically voted out by majority. Voting for somebody in the earlier messes can give some input as to the idenities of the others but at the same time.. there's been such drama over it. So.. I'm still confused.

 

[Ace Marvel]

if sensai is the elim and he flips town i will be looking at daniel tomorrow

Daniel can go 50/50 just like you, but I don't think you are w/w

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I'm just going to say I am against not culling anybody in today's vote. It's towns only try every cycle and like Shawo mentioned it will lose us information we could have gotten. Vital information. Regardless of if we incorrectly elimate somebody. I think the most recent wagons should be condensed and we should be looking more critically on the two or so that can be realistically voted out by majority. Voting for somebody in the earlier messes can give some input as to the idenities of the others but at the same time.. there's been such drama over it. So.. I'm still confused.

that's great, baby steps

Spoiler: everyone but feferily

what's the over/under on scumbuddy coaching them

 

[Aerious]

i was 99% sure i was going to sub out bc of toads. spoke to radical6 about it and all. "that's just toads" is a **** excuse, toads and i should both be under fire for you if that's your reasoning

 

[shawo]

I currently dislike both the punchy/sensai wagon.

I'm not sure if both of them are town, but I feel like they're both mafia lead. If... that makes sense?

I'd much prefer a lynch outside, but voting patterns make sense.

The toads vote has both leaf and heyden in it, and toads is already someone I'm ?? on.


but....

I wouldn't be surprised if 1/2 sensai and punchy have mafia.