Mafia June 2020 Mafia Game Thread [DAY 2 ENDS AT 6/20 5PM PST]

[Heyden]

I think Aerious is town, when she said ‘when do we roleclaim this game should be easy’ that just sent strong townvibes.

As for Sensai, I do believe he’s town, but not to a great extent. There’s some people who are so insistent on him being scum or town, idk how you guys are that sure but it feels off. I wouldn’t vote him today but I’m not opposed to his lynch.

Punchy’s recent activity is weird the more I think about it, might vote him if it’s down to him and Sensai.

 

[epona]

being honest this is my first time playing a game as town in 6 years LOL i don't like not knowing things

 

[N e s s]

no!

they led the toads argument on and on and on until he wanted to sub out

toads did keep feeding the fire but that's toads

i can see sensai saying that like an hour ago i really hadn't done that much

sensai not trying is more town ai then scum ai imo

It's not my job to synthesize a defense for Aerious, she can do that for herself.

But you're literally coming in here an hour before day is about to end trying to lead an elimination with your only point of reference being you think it's "weird." I'm not going along with that, you're just ASKING for division right now punchy. Just you wait an hour from now where someone starts screaming about some completely irrelevant wagon like Ace y'all blitz them for some reason.

We're not lynching Aerious today. Cut it out.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I currently dislike both the punchy/sensai wagon.

I'm not sure if both of them are town, but I feel like they're both mafia lead. If... that makes sense?

I'd much prefer a lynch outside, but voting patterns make sense.

The toads vote has both leaf and heyden in it, and toads is already someone I'm ?? on.


but....

I wouldn't be surprised if 1/2 sensai and punchy have mafia.

i really don't like this take

 

[Heyden]

However I’m sticking to Toads for now, if that’s gonna gain any traction.
People started mentioning ‘oh there’s a BW on Toads now’ but there really isn’t.

 

[radical6]

i guess the reason i dont fully buy this is more of a game mechanic question. if i were to say "whatever im gonna replace out" in thread but then never follow through with DMing the host, would the host take this request seriously?

I cannot answer this.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I think Aerious is town, when she said ‘when do we roleclaim this game should be easy’ that just sent strong townvibes.

As for Sensai, I do believe he’s town, but not to a great extent. There’s some people who are so insistent on him being scum or town, idk how you guys are that sure but it feels off. I wouldn’t vote him today but I’m not opposed to his lynch.

Punchy’s recent activity is weird the more I think about it, might vote him if it’s down to him and Sensai.

gonna have to use a better argument then "weird"

 

[shawo]

i really don't like this take

I mean, you don't have to like it but it's how I feel.

I haven't read anything before page 58, so I read voting patterns and what people are saying about it.

 

[g u a v a]

my vote is locked honeys, @ me if you have compelling evidence to change my vote.

 

[Heyden]

gonna have to use a better argument then "weird"

Strange

 

[shawo]

Putting it into perspective,

if I have three townreads in heyden/leaf/fefer, and I know myself is town.

That puts 13 other people with 4 mafia, two people are being bw'd right now.

Do I think those two people are mafia or do I think they're town?

If I pick a random group of 3-4-5 people voting one of you, how many mafia are in that pile?

That's what makes voting patterns weird.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

It's not my job to synthesize a defense for Aerious, she can do that for herself.

But you're literally coming in here an hour before day is about to end trying to lead an elimination with your only point of reference being you think it's "weird." I'm not going along with that, you're just ASKING for division right now punchy. Just you wait an hour from now where someone starts screaming about some completely irrelevant wagon like Ace y'all blitz them for some reason.

We're not lynching Aerious today. Cut it out.

it's not because they're "weird"

aerious lead toads on and on in a pointless argument that clogged the thread and pushed progress to a halt

i will never let ace cfd happen

 

[Damniel]

Lynching town gains us nothing, but we lose the chance of lynching the ninja. Our only goal is lynch a ninja that we don't even know exists or not.

honestly surprised you didn't try supporting this with numbers. i thought you opposed the pure information lynch culture

I currently dislike both the punchy/sensai wagon.

I'm not sure if both of them are town, but I feel like they're both mafia lead. If... that makes sense?

I'd much prefer a lynch outside, but voting patterns make sense.

The toads vote has both leaf and heyden in it, and toads is already someone I'm ?? on.


but....

I wouldn't be surprised if 1/2 sensai and punchy have mafia.

what's your thoughts on ness since i think your vote is still on him

being honest this is my first time playing a game as town in 6 years LOL i don't like not knowing things

you said you really wanted to be town before this game started so i mean you asked for it

 

[PunchyTheCat]

i'm increasingly becoming less and less confident in sensai town

 

[epona]

i'm increasingly becoming less and less confident in sensai town

oh my f****ing god

 

[Damniel]

my vote is locked honeys, @ me if you have compelling evidence to change my vote.

what did you think about the quote i posted that showed that sensai's only two reads post flip and don't make sense as a progression?

 

[Aerious]

it's not because they're "weird"

aerious lead toads on and on in a pointless argument that clogged the thread and pushed progress to a halt

i will never let ace cfd happen

don't dodge my point. i wanted to leave and spoke to kallie about me leaving if toad didn't. why toads not under fire bc it's "just toads." the desperation is astounding

i'm increasingly becoming less and less confident in sensai town

lol

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Strange

that's not my argument ness just wants to stop my wagon

 

[shawo]

same as before, I don't think I've seen ness post.

He's not in the lynch so I'll deal with it later.

Also I like mechanically supported lynches. Even if NLing gains us an extra day, the extra day doesn't do anything.

 

[Damniel]

same as before, I don't think I've seen ness post.

He's not in the lynch so I'll deal with it later.

Also I like mechanically supported lynches. Even if NLing gains us an extra day, the extra day doesn't do anything.

aren't you the one that put extraordinary value in extra MLs last night