S Tier: Lucky's my favorite of the bunch due to his mummy design, but the others aren't too far behind. I love Drago's dragon design, even if his big pink lips look a bit goofy. I've loved Boomer's pilot design since the GameCube game. Stitches' cobbled together, multicolor look is really pleasant and the only reason he isn't higher is because of his house's interior design which, while fitting, isn't for me. I love Tucker's woolly mammoth design and Marcel's mime design. Finally, Raddle is the villager of our times.
A Tier: Solid group of good designs.
B Tier: Bob through to Spork are pretty good too, just not as good as the villagers in A Tier. Jeremiah through to Sherb are in B just because I like them better than those in C tier.
C Tier: Decent. Doc through to Wade are the ones that interest me most in this tier, and my interest in them continues to descend as the lines go on.
D Tier: Eh, they just don't do anything for me, really. Zucker could maybe be moved up to the bottom of C tier, but I just really don't like the takoyaki design as much as other people do.