Mafia Luigi's Ma(fia)nsion | Luigi's Mansion Mafia | Ghosts Win

[xCleb]

Strange that prima and cleb started posting right after they were getting sused for inactivity...

- - - Post Merge - - -

Within minutes of each other

Excuse me? I made two posts before Prima made their first post, the first being much earlier than Prima's first post, so this is completely irrelevant.

Also, coming from the post you made before this one, why even bring this up when you literally just stated that voting based off inactivity isn't a good reason to lynch somebody? It already doesn't make any sense in the first place, but this makes it seem like you're looking for any reason to get anybody lynched, and it just doesn't matter who that person is.

Putting a vote on Uttumori for this; I want to see what's going through their head with this situation.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Here's some reads.

Likely Scum
Scum-Lean
Null
Town-Lean
Likely Town

Spoiler

Dolby - I've pretty much explained this in my past posts. I don't agree with the voting on Day 1, but I see the logic in it.

Uttumori - See above post.

toadsworthy - I'm really on the fence between putting them as null or scum-lean, but I think this is based heavily on Tensu's alignment, considering the bandwagon situation.

f11 - Like I said, the situation brought up with them earlier doesn't have much merit in my opinion, and shouldn't really be used to read f11. Other than that, there's really nothing to base anything on, at least not from what I've seen.

Nightmares - Tough to tell with all the joking around they do in their posts. They seem pretty carefree about the game, which makes me want to put them as a Town-Lean, but I know there's WIFOM involved in that, so I'll leave them as Null.

Heyden - They seem like they're good on catching things in the game, and isn't afraid to call people out for those things. If they're actually Town, they're almost certainly not a blue role.

Zendel - Pretty much confirmed Town, so no point in reading them.

Tensu - I still don't like Tensu's piggybacking off toadsworthy's comment about inactivity, and if Tensu flips scum, I think toads should get a closer look afterward.

Cleb - ****ing scum.

Primarina - Hasn't posted enough for me to get a read on them.

Corrie - Newer player, and hasn't posted enough for me to get a solid read on them. I'd like to see more from them more than anybody else.

Edit: Fixed broken spoiler tag.

 

[Corrie]

Excuse me? I made two posts before Prima made their first post, the first being much earlier than Prima's first post, so this is completely irrelevant.

Also, coming from the post you made before this one, why even bring this up when you literally just stated that voting based off inactivity isn't a good reason to lynch somebody? It already doesn't make any sense in the first place, but this makes it seem like you're looking for any reason to get anybody lynched, and it just doesn't matter who that person is.

Putting a vote on Uttumori for this; I want to see what's going through their head with this situation.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Here's some reads.

Likely Scum
Scum-Lean
Null
Town-Lean
Likely Town

Spoiler

Dolby - I've pretty much explained this in my past posts. I don't agree with the voting on Day 1, but I see the logic in it.

Uttumori - See above post.

toadsworthy - I'm really on the fence between putting them as null or scum-lean, but I think this is based heavily on Tensu's alignment, considering the bandwagon situation.

f11 - Like I said, the situation brought up with them earlier doesn't have much merit in my opinion, and shouldn't really be used to read f11. Other than that, there's really nothing to base anything on, at least not from what I've seen.

Nightmares - Tough to tell with all the joking around they do in their posts. They seem pretty carefree about the game, which makes me want to put them as a Town-Lean, but I know there's WIFOM involved in that, so I'll leave them as Null.

Heyden - They seem like they're good on catching things in the game, and isn't afraid to call people out for those things. If they're actually Town, they're almost certainly not a blue role.

Zendel - Pretty much confirmed Town, so no point in reading them.

Tensu - I still don't like Tensu's piggybacking off toadsworthy's comment about inactivity, and if Tensu flips scum, I think toads should get a closer look afterward.

Cleb - ****ing scum.

Primarina - Hasn't posted enough for me to get a read on them.

Corrie - Newer player, and hasn't posted enough for me to get a solid read on them. I'd like to see more from them more than anybody else.

Edit: Fixed broken spoiler tag.

But uh, what did Uttumori do? Unless I'm bad at reading people.

 

[Aquari]

Excuse me? I made two posts before Prima made their first post, the first being much earlier than Prima's first post, so this is completely irrelevant.

Yea I know, I'm just sayin you disappeared for a good while then suddenly popped back in once dolby and zendel were discussing your inactivity which i'm saying was pretty weird, no need to get so fired up about it lol

Also, coming from the post you made before this one, why even bring this up when you literally just stated that voting based off inactivity isn't a good reason to lynch somebody? It already doesn't make any sense in the first place, but this makes it seem like you're looking for any reason to get anybody lynched, and it just doesn't matter who that person is.

I never said i was going to vote or try to lynch you? so i have no idea where you got this from?

 

[Dolby]

I want to see Toads reads, as I feel like I could use those the most to come up with a judgement. f11 not posting their "reasons" makes me more confident in them being mafia than town. Honestly, I feel that the Uttumori thing isn't particularly scummy as it is noobish. Specifically, they're trying to make connections when there are none, though they still should be a lynch candidate.

I'm going to stress again that we are going to lynch today, and probably on all subsequent days, as that will keep us on track with LYLO. f11, Prim, Tensu, and Toads are all players who I would consider lynching today. F11 I've outlined with their inconsistency, but there is also their anti-town behavior. Prim is on here because of how they swooped in, then swooped out without saying anything of value. Toads isn't matching his normal contributions, but I think that Tensu piggybacking off of him is more sus. I can see anybody besides Zendal and Nightmares being mafia at this point. We should also be wary of not lynching the mafia given lynch immunity

 

[Corrie]

I want to see Toads reads, as I feel like I could use those the most to come up with a judgement. f11 not posting their "reasons" makes me more confident in them being mafia than town. Honestly, I feel that the Uttumori thing isn't particularly scummy as it is noobish. Specifically, they're trying to make connections when there are none, though they still should be a lynch candidate.

I'm going to stress again that we are going to lynch today, and probably on all subsequent days, as that will keep us on track with LYLO. f11, Prim, Tensu, and Toads are all players who I would consider lynching today. F11 I've outlined with their inconsistency, but there is also their anti-town behavior. Prim is on here because of how they swooped in, then swooped out without saying anything of value. Toads isn't matching his normal contributions, but I think that Tensu piggybacking off of him is more sus. I can see anybody besides Zendal and Nightmares being mafia at this point. We should also be wary of not lynching the mafia given lynch immunity

I agree with you with Nightmares being town for sure. They seem rather laid back and give off a chill vibe. They also haven't been suspecting anyone as of yet. Zendal is obviously town cause of being silenced.

F11 seems rather sketchy. They just seem to come in here and blame people without backing themselves up which could mean that they don't care who gets killed. That's just my view on it anyway.

I agree that we need to lynch someone, but I really want it to be for a good reason and not just a random lynch. We already lost mogyay who was a smart player; I don't wanna lose another good one.

 

[Heyden]

why did mog die, I would've expected zendel or someone else wtf

Anyway it's between dolby/tensu/mori/prima today, I'll explain when I get home

- - - Post Merge - - -

also everyone needs to vote or we'll have a vegetable garden

 

[f11]

Yeah, I love being sketchy, it's kinda my thing. Dolby is mafia. Idk if my mafia skills are rusting or whateva but this is the most fickle I've seen Dolby in a while. He seems to have no convictions nothing sure about. All of his posts are ifs and hypotheticals. Inb4, "town shouldn't be sure about anything" yes that is true, however when mad acts like town, I find easy to see when they are overdoing it, like Dolby . Ok so he tries to act like a town leader in the beginning of the game, but instead of reads and leans, I see pockets. A lean for someone saying we shouldn't edit, like dolbs, I honestly expect better things from you. And then a weird vote in me with a weirder explanation/excuse. I'm gonna be honest here, all it did was confuse me and probably the others of town. Also like your only reason for town leaning nightmares is tone, can explain why you think that pls, I am highly interesting in the bull**** excuse. Also I found Dolby saying no lunch was interesting, considering how earlier he was actively looking for 'counterwagons' thus Dolby can be seen somewhat contracting himself there. He gave me a town lean then null, like wtf make your mind. Also Dolby fears to get black mailed or killed, like chill ur scum biddies won't kill you. Anyways It's either I'm dumb af, Dolby needs to get his act together if town, or Dolby is mafia. My convictions tell me to take a crack at the third. TLDR; Dolby is as fickle as the wind

Am I the only who's not town reading zendel completely. Like yeah you have a chance to be town, but also could be a separate faction of ghosts.

Also I got my eyes out for lunch bandwagoners. So yeah hose are my thoughts, I'll probably have reads tomorrow *.

 

[Dolby]

Yeah, I love being sketchy, it's kinda my thing. Dolby is mafia. Idk if my mafia skills are rusting or whateva but this is the most fickle I've seen Dolby in a while. He seems to have no convictions nothing sure about. All of his posts are ifs and hypotheticals. Inb4, "town shouldn't be sure about anything" yes that is true, however when mad acts like town, I find easy to see when they are overdoing it, like Dolby . Ok so he tries to act like a town leader in the beginning of the game, but instead of reads and leans, I see pockets

I'm trying to lead town since nobody will step up to the plate, post, or actually read people (with the exception of Cleb) Well I don't see leans and reads from you either, and this is extremely contradictory to what you said at the beginning of the game

anyway dolby imma vote dolby so :^). Like i agree wityh whomstdve (hayden? i think) said dolby will just town read anyone who posts basically. too many reads/leans/ or whatever for a game that barely started.

Well gee, nice to know that you're arguing against your past self here. In addition, literally the only read I have wavered on is you. So your TLDR doesn't even make sense

Also like your only reason for town leaning nightmares is tone, can explain why you think that pls, I am highly interesting in the bull**** excuse.

Easy, as town, Nightmares posting style more relaxed, as mafia, Nightmares is more tense, terse, and to the point.

Also I found Dolby saying no lunch was interesting, considering how earlier he was actively looking for 'counterwagons' thus Dolby can be seen somewhat contracting himself there.

I was looking for scum buddies trying to safe you from the lynch. I got onto the idea of no lynch once Heyden demonstrated that it was better for town in that situation

Am I the only who's not town reading zendel completely. Like yeah you have a chance to be town, but also could be a separate faction of ghosts.

I'm having a hard time not calling you ******** right now...Zendal was blackmailed, and Bowie literally showed their role and alignment with the green color for their name. And he confirmed that all the ghosts, included our blackmailer, are on the same team in this post

The special roles all have a choice whether they want to unveil themselves to their mates or not. To my knowledge, they all know who each other are. I don't really see a reason why they'd choose not to, since they're on the same team and all, but that's really none of my business.

why did mog die, I would've expected zendel or someone else wtf

Anyway it's between dolby/tensu/mori/prima today, I'll explain when I get home

With the exception of me, this list is fine

Anyway, fun facts. Toads has been lurking the thread, I called him out and he still hasn't said anything. f11's reasons (with the exception of the counterwagon argument) have no merit, and pretty much nobody has made the reads I asked of them

 

[toadsworthy]

my phone is like eternally locked on here because as I said earlier.... I follow this throughout the day on mobile when I can. I have obligations tomorrow, but plan on voting and posting my thoughts so far after those and before I have to go to work. I'm sorry i can't post more, but I've been strapped to the max with how busy i am from clinical. Its an excuse, I know.... but I'm not gonna bs around it or beat around the bush, thats literally why i've been so distant

 

[Heyden]

Current reads on the players atm;

Uttumori
The line that sort of struck me the most was 'Ah dammit I missed day vote, I was gonna NL anyway, there's nothing to work with for now.' She wasn't even online before the idea of no lynch was even a thing before I brought it up, and she plays it off as if she was gonna vote no lynch anyway, either because she was ready to sheep the vote to blend in or she had that idea beforehand, which the latter definitely isn't true after assuming that 'activity would pick up soon'. And of course the jab towards Cleb and Prima, in which the last game although Uttumori was very inactive, a lot of the posts she actually made were suspicions onto townies already made by others, in this case I think Dolby and Zendel sussing Cleb and Prima. And her contradictions that Cleb pointed out but that was never my point so, Uttumori is definitely high up in my 'lynch list'.

Tensu
I've had a lowly suspicion on Tensu since the start, but didn't really have anything to pursue with it until now. Again, sheeped on the no lynch train but I can't really complain because I'm the one who led it so, but the fact that they said they weren't comfortable in voting someone put me off, because the whole point of the no lynch was to buy extra time. Also 'mislynching Prima' is better than 'mislynching Cleb' was weird too, like I get what you mean because Cleb has posted more content so far, but I don't know why you'd agree with that in any sense considering you weren't comfortable in voting anyone, right?? Also I'm pretty sure Tensu piggybacked on Dolby and maybe Mog, can't recall and don't know if that's within their play style, but definitely a good lynch for today imo.

Dolby
The thing with more-experienced/veteran members is that the people 'below' them are often too afraid to sus these said so people in fear of that they'll bite back harder. While I don't think Dolby is the -best- lynch candidate for today, I definitely think he's someone to keep an eye on. Early on with with pocketing of 3 people claiming that they're town just seemed a bit off, whether those people are actually town or not. Same goes for his taken on role of 'leader', for which he could easily manipulate but that's another story because I'm pretty sure Cleb is going for that same role too. And speaking of Cleb I'm not a big fan of the exchange between the two, the 'yes good points yes yes!', gives me a sense that maybe they both share a certain alignment?? I don't know, but yeah, while I don't think Dolby should be lynched, I don't think we should take into account about everything he says because I'm still heavily wary of him.

Primarina
With a grand total of 3 posts, I guess I'm sort of sus of them. Their first post ironically was calling for more activity when they missed almost 2 phases. Although I usually don't like basing people on inactivity, Prima's had many opportunities to converse and defend for their inactivity, and although they have sort of defended themselves a bit from Uttumori's point about Prima and Cleb's coincidental posting times, I don't see too much of a reflection from when Prima was scum in that other game for which she was apparently super defensive, but then again Prima was also pretty defensive as town and got bashed for that, so I'm still undecided.

As for everyone else I can't be bothered to do a full analysis so;
Zendel
F11
Nightmares
Corrie
Toads
Cleb

- - - Post Merge - - -

anyway I'm out for the rest of the night so won't be able to reply for a few hours

 

[Bowie]

I would just like to point out for quick clarification (before I head off to sleep) that every player is referred to in green until they are proven otherwise. They can choose to silence any player, whether they be on their side, the opposite side, or even themselves. Zendel being silenced does not necessarily confirm their role. I'm sure you guys already know this, but I just wanted to avoid any confusion while I'm gone. They can choose any player.

 

[Nightmares]

Just putting it out there, but mafia silencing themselves would be a really good tactic to confirm one of their own as town

 

[Tensu]

Regarding my "piggybacking" off of toad's post about inactivity, at that point the game was extremely inactive and I was simply attempting to start some conversation and make the game more active. There was really nothing else to say at that moment if you look back.

 

[Aquari]

Did prima fill in RQS? i think she just popped in here to defend herself then disappeared again, unless I somehow missed it
and yet IM the sus one, lol

 

[Nightmares]

I'm voting Cleb for now - jumping on Mori like that seemed a bit weird

 

[Aquari]

I'm voting Cleb for now - jumping on Mori like that seemed a bit weird

the way he wrote that post made it seem like i personally insulted him and his family name (even voting me just for my little theory), but whatever, he atleast made some good posts so hes off my radar for now

 

[Heyden]

Just putting it out there, but mafia silencing themselves would be a really good tactic to confirm one of their own as town

Interesting you bring that up. Do you really still think Zendel could be scum?? even so I'm pretty sure Zendel is town regardless

- - - Post Merge - - -

Regarding my "piggybacking" off of toad's post about inactivity, at that point the game was extremely inactive and I was simply attempting to start some conversation and make the game more active. There was really nothing else to say at that moment if you look back.

I get what you mean, but you can't really start conversation by repeating what everyone else is saying but okay, ANYWAY

- - - Post Merge - - -

Did prima fill in RQS? i think she just popped in here to defend herself then disappeared again, unless I somehow missed it
and yet IM the sus one, lol

Don't think she did, your constant pushing and deflecting attention onto her makes me believe that there's a scum between you two...

- - - Post Merge - - -

Did prima fill in RQS? i think she just popped in here to defend herself then disappeared again, unless I somehow missed it
and yet IM the sus one, lol

Don't think she did, your constant pushing and deflecting attention onto her makes me believe that there's a scum between you two...

- - - Post Merge - - -

sorry I'm so unco I have to make a rush decision because I sleep in saturdays lol

 

[Dolby]

Tbh, Heyden townreading f11 does make me paranoid that Mog's theory about no lynch being the counterwagon could be correct. I don't agree with Nightmares vote as well. I really just want a reads list from Toads at this point most of all

 

[toadsworthy]

Tbh, Heyden townreading f11 does make me paranoid that Mog's theory about no lynch being the counterwagon could be correct. I don't agree with Nightmares vote as well. I really just want a reads list from Toads at this point most of all

literally working on it now! I had to give a tour of our program and have lunch at 12, so its going to be my next post with thoughts on EVERYONE

 

[Heyden]

Tbh, Heyden townreading f11 does make me paranoid that Mog's theory about no lynch being the counterwagon could be correct. I don't agree with Nightmares vote as well. I really just want a reads list from Toads at this point most of all

Could you explain this? A bit lost on what you mean

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh, so you think I pushed the lynch away from f11 on purpose?