Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

[Aronthaer]

what

Cory, you need to chill.

Honestly, you're all being d***s and it's kinda ruining the game for me. I know that's how the game goes but seriously, I just went through something really stressful and I just don't want to put up with this crap. That's why I cracked so easily is because honestly the game's no longer fun.

I really do want to play TBT mafia at some point in the future though, this sort of thing I'm normally really good at and enjoy immensely. I'm jut having some difficulties right now.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Which doesn't make sense to me, considering

A: it's not true
B: It means little to nothing, scum can "scumhunt" on town and try to get them to crack

but whatever. I was hoping he had another reason, anything, but I guess not.

Lemme try to explain it a little better.

Scumhunting (at least the brand I use) is taking people's statements, and getting clarification on points that don't make sense. If someone displays motivations of a townie person in their replies, they're likely town. And on the flip side, if their answers give away scummy motivations, they're probably town.

- - - Post Merge - - -

They're probably scum*

 

[Aronthaer]

Lemme try to explain it a little better.

Scumhunting (at least the brand I use) is taking people's statements, and getting clarification on points that don't make sense. If someone displays motivations of a townie person in their replies, they're likely town. And on the flip side, if their answers give away scummy motivations, they're probably town.

- - - Post Merge - - -

They're probably scum*

Yes. this. I agree. however, couldn't a scum "scumhunt" on townies who aren't explaining their motives clearly and try to get them lynched? Idk how y'all do mafia round here (obviously) but when I'm mafia that's my preferred way to take attention off of me.

 

[PandaDarling]

oh man i just caught up on the thread and my head hurts with all this Doctor claim bs... I'm gonna go back put my reads together.

@Cory stop being mean for no reason. Thanks.

 

[Qwerty111]

Lemme try to explain it a little better.

Scumhunting (at least the brand I use)

Scumhunting™

 

[Arstotzkan]

Yes. this. I agree. however, couldn't a scum "scumhunt" on townies who aren't explaining their motives clearly and try to get them lynched? Idk how y'all do mafia round here (obviously) but when I'm mafia that's my preferred way to take attention off of me.

Well of course, but for your example, not explaining clearly doesn't mean itms a scum tell. Itms a derp/potential scum tell. So I'd press said person with that argument and ask why they aren't assuming derp tell if a derp tell is reasonable.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Scumhunting™

Kek

Thoughts so far on the game? They don't have to be super well thought out - anything is good ^^"

 

[Aronthaer]

Thoughts so far on the game? They don't have to be super well thought out - anything is good ^^"

Cory's a ****, I F***ed up, everything else has been pretty good. I have no idea an scum, I'm waiting for someone to say something incriminating.

- - - Post Merge - - -

on*

 

[Arstotzkan]

Cory's a ****, I F***ed up, everything else has been pretty good. I have no idea an scum, I'm waiting for someone to say something incriminating.

- - - Post Merge - - -

on*

So you don't think my post about the role names was suspicious enough to warrent you pushing me? Why not?

- - - Post Merge - - -

And sorry about Cory. He's usually not that pissy.

 

[Aronthaer]

So you don't think my post about the role names was suspicious enough to warrent you pushing me? Why not?

And sorry about Cory. He's usually not that pissy.

Nah. it was an honest question and while it WAS suspicious, by itself it doesn't amount to much.

And I love how you're apologizing for Cory like he's your pet or something lmao

 

[Arstotzkan]

Haha well I mean I like Cory! But I think hems been rotten in thread today, and I felt bad for you since you're getting you ass blasted and this is your first game on here.

If you had to call one person scum, who would you say?

- - - Post Merge - - -

he's*

 

[Aronthaer]

If you had to call one person scum, who would you say?

Hmmm... Probably Cory, but I don't necessarily think he's scum, I think he's just being a jerk. I'm gonna be on a lot today scum hunting and trying to find at least one scum before the Mafia makes Swiss Cheese of me on day 2 (since I can't protect myself two days in a row lmao)

- - - Post Merge - - -

I really want to be helpful in this game despite my slipups so I'm going to try to find at least 1 scum. that's my goal.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Sounds like a great goal to me! Hopefully you can live beyond D2 though lol

Gonna go take a nap but I plan on looking through the thread to see if I can dig up anything. My current FOS I wanna focus on is Tardis - he's had low thread presence and kinda just jumped on the Aron wagon.

 

[tae]

Sounds like a great goal to me! Hopefully you can live beyond D2 though lol

Gonna go take a nap but I plan on looking through the thread to see if I can dig up anything. My current FOS I wanna focus on is Tardis - he's had low thread presence and kinda just jumped on the Aron wagon.

sounds like a good plan, honestly. enjoy your nap sarasa

 

[glow]

wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong
most games have role blocker
why are you assuming there isn't one

it's pretty likely that there is but I was just trying to help him, in case there is not one.

btw can you guys like not with the ad hominem? it makes me feel like i'm in kindergarten rn lol

@Aron i'm talking to you here as well as others, i know you're new here but you shouldn't call someone a dick just for putting pressure on you. don't take anything here personally, it's a game b chill homie

pro tip: play this game with no emotions attached, in fact just live life with no emotions attached. feelings are gross. :^)

 

[Kirbystarship]

Hmmm... Probably Cory, but I don't necessarily think he's scum, I think he's just being a jerk. I'm gonna be on a lot today scum hunting and trying to find at least one scum before the Mafia makes Swiss Cheese of me on day 2 (since I can't protect myself two days in a row lmao)

- - - Post Merge - - -

I really want to be helpful in this game despite my slipups so I'm going to try to find at least 1 scum. that's my goal.

Or mafia roleblocks you I don't know. If you are a doctor what is your character role?

 

[Damniel]

Okay so we have this fight between Aron and cory. Both are being pretty emotional(Cory pressing a bit too hard and Aron taking it too hard) and it's honestly just a distraction. I'm not a fan of Cory's constant,"I'm one of the few people who are scumhunting" ego when you've haven't stated any reason for any of your reads besides "I think they are because of meta and gut feelings". Pointing out suspicious posts and behavior is scumhunting, not by tunneling someone and start a emotional fight. Both of you need to tone it down with the posting because I wasted my time reading your bickering.

 

[glow]

@Dolby can you pleeeeez put post links on the OP?

 

[PandaDarling]

This Aron bandwagon is gross.

i strongly agree with this.

Aron is mostly leaning town to me because of stuff like this...

Am I allowed to claim to be a certain role? I know that a lot of games allow this but I'd like to be sure before I do so.

Am I allowed to PM you with a question about my role?

if Aron was mafia he would have his scum buddies to help explain any questions he may have about claiming and or his role so this seem very unlikely to say as mafia, also there is always a chance he could be third party, given he has been posting stuff like this...

I play this game pretty recklessly, it's true. but I slipped up in the beginning and there's really no hope of redeeming myself, so I'm pretty much toying with you at this point.

My only hope is to continue toying with all of your minds.

@Aron if you really are town then please don't mess with our minds, its hard enough to read though all this crap and find mafia we don't need fellow town members trying to confuse us. If you want to be helpful then please just explain yourself calmly and as Sarasakat said the sincerity of your post should come through so we can get a proper read on you and your true intentions. also if i were you i would heavily weigh the options that M3ow said to you about your role (if you truly are our Doctor) and not hint to it in the thread any long, i think thats how you would still be most helpful to us now that you've seemed to made a bit of a mess of things.

and yeah I can also see I am being a little nitpicky for saying my first few points....

but isnt it also nitpicking to call out alexi 10 minutes into the game for her insincere tone?
or curry for just lurking around for a little bit?

so I don't know what we are getting at about the importance of nitpicking, as long as you don't act on it right away

@Toad im not gonna quote your long post cause of trying to save space but i read it and i had to read it a couple times, it seemed kinda forced and far fetched like you were really having to reach to pull some of those points out of thin air. Then you had to go "ya im nitpicking" seems too wishy washy. i appreciate it if you are genuinely trying to help cause your new, but at the same time your read on Sarasakat just seems like you are trying to seem pro-town and have a different opinion than everyone else to me.

omg and then Cory what do i even say ?

I was excited for this game. Then I realized how inept some of these people are

wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong
most games have role blocker
why are you assuming there isn't one

im not going to pull all of you pointless quotes but it seems to me that you are kinda hanging around not being and even refusing at time to help, and then you just do this bully tactic thing that always makes me think you are trying to be intimidating towards town so that we don't want to call you out on your bs. scum or not you are being helpful and your mean and it makes people not want to play to the best of their abilities (at least thats the way it makes me feel)

Guys guys hear me out I have a great idea. Let's lynch the doctor 1 hour before deadline while they are asleep.

No Cory we only do that to ou cause you're a certain kinda special to us. ha

 

[glow]

Still pretty iffy about Ness, considering he was posting a decent amount up to when I sussed him, then he backed off and slinked into the shadows

 

[Kirbystarship]

Sounds like a great goal to me! Hopefully you can live beyond D2 though lol

Gonna go take a nap but I plan on looking through the thread to see if I can dig up anything. My current FOS I wanna focus on is Tardis - he's had low thread presence and kinda just jumped on the Aron wagon.

I didn't join the bandwagon if you look I explained why I was voting for them.