Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!
- Thread starter Dolby
- Start date
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
And I understand with your personal issue, faced a similar thing with my great aunt during the BoI game. Feel free to log off for a bit if you need to.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also what's Ate again? Forgot what that means
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also what's Ate again? Forgot what that means
**** forgot shiida idk not really enough posts, but i'm glad they posted their reads b/c I agree with some of them
- - - Post Merge - - -
o lol i didnt refresh page. thought id post merge ooops.
@sarasakat & daniel, thank you. yea i'll prob log off for a bit today. but i will be back for sure. i definitely don't think sarasakat is scum, but i do understand why you both reacted the way you did. i guess i'm really null on both
- - - Post Merge - - -
o lol i didnt refresh page. thought id post merge ooops.
@sarasakat & daniel, thank you. yea i'll prob log off for a bit today. but i will be back for sure. i definitely don't think sarasakat is scum, but i do understand why you both reacted the way you did. i guess i'm really null on both
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
lmao rekt
But yeah I was trying to compare flavour ****. I can see how it's perceived as suspicious, but I was trying to make sure Ronald Reagan was a possible claim. It seemed like a completely off the wall role to associate with it but eh oh well.
You know, I gotta check back and look to see how many 'experienced' players there are in this game. I'm surprised by the lack of well known scumhunters being in the thick of it.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Appeal to emotion
Anyway yeah, we have a little over 12 hours left I think to decide on a lynch and we've barely gotten anywhere due to the past events... No lynch isn't an option so if we really can't deicde, maybe Honey since they did bring up QuickTopics a lot unless she's mason or something.
I thought honey was modkilled? don't we have to vote for someone alive?
Oh? I thought Dolby said he was replacing the 2...
Also, Dolby, if you wanna add these in at some point today I thought I'd help/make it easier idk.
Aronthaer
SarasaKat
Cory
Call me Daniel
Tardis2016
Alexi
Heyden
taesaek
Panda1376
toadsworthy
N e s s
Crys
m3ow_
inkling
Cadbberry
ClamEatsCurry
Kevinnn
shiida
Qwerty111
mother of all llamas
xine
- - - Post Merge - - -
@Aronthaer - you really don't think tardis is just confused?
@heyden - yeah i think there might be a replacement, but lynching the replacement based on their predecessor isn't the best idea..
Aronthaer
SarasaKat
Cory
Call me Daniel
Tardis2016
Alexi
Heyden
taesaek
Panda1376
toadsworthy
N e s s
Crys
m3ow_
inkling
Cadbberry
ClamEatsCurry
Kevinnn
shiida
Qwerty111
mother of all llamas
xine
- - - Post Merge - - -
@Aronthaer - you really don't think tardis is just confused?
@heyden - yeah i think there might be a replacement, but lynching the replacement based on their predecessor isn't the best idea..
nooooo. fail. ah well.
They aren't being replaced until the end of Day 1 so the replacement wouldn't be affected.
- - - Post Merge - - -
- - - Post Merge - - -
Okay like, then who's our lynch gonna be then
- - - Post Merge - - -
I made the same mistake haha
- - - Post Merge - - -
Okay like, then who's our lynch gonna be then
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
These are my current strong reads. The scale goes from
Very town
Slight town
Neutral/Null
Slight suspicions
Heavy scum read
Difference between Neutral and Null is that Neutral is split between Town and Mafia. Null is lack of evidence for either.
9. Toadsworthy - When I was coaching him, I told him when he was suspicious of someone, to make a case. And well, he did. And he showed he was willing to put in the effort to take initiative into a dying thread and start something new, which is generating discussion and protown. My only gripes with him is that he's tunneling and he hasn't really made any reads apparent besides his scumread of me iirc. Before I get asked, tunneling is ducking your head in and charging at someone full speed ahead going out of your way to find anything that points them towards being mafia, regardless of the evidence being sound or not. And while that concerns me, I think him being on the initiative is something that marks a town player, and he has been inactive so it's harder for him to give other reads.
10. ClamEatsCurry - As one of two people in here who have meta experience on Curry (Cad, Curry, and I have played Town of Salem before), this fits his town play. He doesn't seem like he's afraid to throw up whatever thoughts he has, where iirc he would try to be a little more guarded of his opinions as scum. I would appreciate you posting more, though.
11. Ness - Gonna look back in a sec. You've been very unremarkable. Which in your case, is concerning. I get IRL can be in the way sometimes, but you're the kind who has a very hands-in-deep meta regardless, picking fights wherever you can.
Considering he's known to be active as both town and mafia though, I don't think you can call him mafia for being AFK. It is interesting to note, however, so we should look back at a lot of his earlier posts.
12. Cadbberry - She seems tunneled on Tardis because of OMGUS ("you're suspicious of me, so Imma be suspicious of you"). Her replies also came off as... oddly defensive for not being a major topic at all. I'd like to hear your opinion on other issues, Cad. What do you think about the suspicion against me? What about the whole Doc fiasco?
13. M3ow_ - From what little you've posted, something's bothered me about your tone. I'll look back on evidence and specify what I mean in a little.
16. Cory - Someone said earlier that town!Cory is usually less reserved and willing to pick fights. I can see it as a general trend, but he was adamant about the sacrificial blade and whoever didn't out that they had the daggar was scum. And he has scumhunted a little, which is promising, but I generally have a "Lynch all Hypocrits" policy, and Cory pretty clearly broke that when talking about Curry and Toads being the only two scumhunters when he wasn't scumhunting himself. And he hasn't really scumhunted much, to be fair.
Also for future reference, but maybe his townread of me came about to pocket me. Iirc he said people needed to be more townie to go into his town circle, I townread him for saying that, and then he put me in the circle immediately after for meta reasons. One post can't be enough to change someone's mind from null regarding their meta to town, right?
18. Aronthaer - Claimed Doc, and he seems like ever since the drama blew over, he's been trying to some extent to scumhunt. I don't think a new scum player would think to do that.
Imma start reading up on the others, but Meow, Ness, and Tardis are my priorities.
Very town
Slight town
Neutral/Null
Slight suspicions
Heavy scum read
Difference between Neutral and Null is that Neutral is split between Town and Mafia. Null is lack of evidence for either.
9. Toadsworthy - When I was coaching him, I told him when he was suspicious of someone, to make a case. And well, he did. And he showed he was willing to put in the effort to take initiative into a dying thread and start something new, which is generating discussion and protown. My only gripes with him is that he's tunneling and he hasn't really made any reads apparent besides his scumread of me iirc. Before I get asked, tunneling is ducking your head in and charging at someone full speed ahead going out of your way to find anything that points them towards being mafia, regardless of the evidence being sound or not. And while that concerns me, I think him being on the initiative is something that marks a town player, and he has been inactive so it's harder for him to give other reads.
10. ClamEatsCurry - As one of two people in here who have meta experience on Curry (Cad, Curry, and I have played Town of Salem before), this fits his town play. He doesn't seem like he's afraid to throw up whatever thoughts he has, where iirc he would try to be a little more guarded of his opinions as scum. I would appreciate you posting more, though.
11. Ness - Gonna look back in a sec. You've been very unremarkable. Which in your case, is concerning. I get IRL can be in the way sometimes, but you're the kind who has a very hands-in-deep meta regardless, picking fights wherever you can.
Considering he's known to be active as both town and mafia though, I don't think you can call him mafia for being AFK. It is interesting to note, however, so we should look back at a lot of his earlier posts.
12. Cadbberry - She seems tunneled on Tardis because of OMGUS ("you're suspicious of me, so Imma be suspicious of you"). Her replies also came off as... oddly defensive for not being a major topic at all. I'd like to hear your opinion on other issues, Cad. What do you think about the suspicion against me? What about the whole Doc fiasco?
13. M3ow_ - From what little you've posted, something's bothered me about your tone. I'll look back on evidence and specify what I mean in a little.
16. Cory - Someone said earlier that town!Cory is usually less reserved and willing to pick fights. I can see it as a general trend, but he was adamant about the sacrificial blade and whoever didn't out that they had the daggar was scum. And he has scumhunted a little, which is promising, but I generally have a "Lynch all Hypocrits" policy, and Cory pretty clearly broke that when talking about Curry and Toads being the only two scumhunters when he wasn't scumhunting himself. And he hasn't really scumhunted much, to be fair.
Also for future reference, but maybe his townread of me came about to pocket me. Iirc he said people needed to be more townie to go into his town circle, I townread him for saying that, and then he put me in the circle immediately after for meta reasons. One post can't be enough to change someone's mind from null regarding their meta to town, right?
18. Aronthaer - Claimed Doc, and he seems like ever since the drama blew over, he's been trying to some extent to scumhunt. I don't think a new scum player would think to do that.
Imma start reading up on the others, but Meow, Ness, and Tardis are my priorities.
Also I think I'll stay on today. this game is definitely helping and distracting me so lets goooo.
I'm expecting Crys to actually deliver something "[good]" crys DO NOT LET ME DOWN.
Then theres ness who said he would post today.
One, or both of those two things are sure to deliver us in some direction.
- - - Post Merge - - -
oh i missed sarasakat's reads. reading rn
I'm expecting Crys to actually deliver something "[good]" crys DO NOT LET ME DOWN.
Then theres ness who said he would post today.
One, or both of those two things are sure to deliver us in some direction.
- - - Post Merge - - -
oh i missed sarasakat's reads. reading rn
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
Yeah I will try to make more posts later.... I should be home by 8ish est and have plenty of time to catch up, post, and vote... Woulda been more active but tryna hang out with friends I haven't seen in years
?!?! heyden, did you post your reads or like, the colors .. anything?
do you at least have one person you read as town, and one thats scum?
- - - Post Merge - - -
also I pretty much agree with @SarasaKat. cadbberry did seem very defensive against tardis, but then there's also aron who's like LYNCH TARDIS MAKE MAFIA GRATE. ... that doesn't help either.
I guess if I had two strong reads for both:
m3ow_ / ness
Panda / Cory
do you at least have one person you read as town, and one thats scum?
- - - Post Merge - - -
also I pretty much agree with @SarasaKat. cadbberry did seem very defensive against tardis, but then there's also aron who's like LYNCH TARDIS MAKE MAFIA GRATE. ... that doesn't help either.
I guess if I had two strong reads for both:
m3ow_ / ness
Panda / Cory
aron's done that for 2 people, which is kinda annoying since he just keeps posting that every time a person gets accused by multiple people.
Oh yea right ummmm
Cadbberry/Daniel
Panda/Shiida
yeah yeah I'll elaborate tomorrow and my reasonings. Don't take into account for these reads yet thought since I'll be missing out on most if not the rest of the day. God bless there's night talk this time round.
Cadbberry/Daniel
Panda/Shiida
yeah yeah I'll elaborate tomorrow and my reasonings. Don't take into account for these reads yet thought since I'll be missing out on most if not the rest of the day. God bless there's night talk this time round.
Alright I'm gonna actually attempt at some reading so here goes (warning the last time I played properly (eg without dying first day) was like 2014/15 so have mercy)
Alexi
Acted virtually the same in newbie so I think town
Tardis2016
either generally confused, or "has a qt".
Panda1376
active but they seem to just rub me off the wrong way. idk tho.
Sarasakat
active + scumhunting so I think town
Crys
Kinda waiting on their post, but they seem pretty chill.
Toadsworthy
A tiny (tiny) bit more reserved than last time. but may just not have anything to go on or is busy. i think town though.
Ness
Doesn't seem sus to me? Yeah he disappeered rather suspiciously after being called out
M3ow_
Making some valid points, but idk they rub me off the wrong way I might just hate confident people gdi
Inkling
Still quiet as heck, even after newbie, where they were not maf (blue role I think?) so I think town for now.
Cory
not putting much effort into this, but i suppose they're not suspicious.
Taesaek
Seems consistent with newbie mafia, so i think town.
Aronthaer
I really don't think they're sus, but roleclaiming was a pretty stupid move. So I'm assuming mafia will just take care of them. They do seem town though.
Qwerty111
it me
Mother of all llamas
was quite quiet in newbie, bit like inkling, and was town, so for now I think they are pretty consistent.
help pls cannot scumhunt for anything, I'm kinda just using past games and obvious stuff. i suck.
Alexi
Acted virtually the same in newbie so I think town
Tardis2016
either generally confused, or "has a qt".
Panda1376
active but they seem to just rub me off the wrong way. idk tho.
Sarasakat
active + scumhunting so I think town
Crys
Kinda waiting on their post, but they seem pretty chill.
Toadsworthy
A tiny (tiny) bit more reserved than last time. but may just not have anything to go on or is busy. i think town though.
Ness
Doesn't seem sus to me? Yeah he disappeered rather suspiciously after being called out
M3ow_
Making some valid points, but idk they rub me off the wrong way I might just hate confident people gdi
Inkling
Still quiet as heck, even after newbie, where they were not maf (blue role I think?) so I think town for now.
Cory
not putting much effort into this, but i suppose they're not suspicious.
Taesaek
Seems consistent with newbie mafia, so i think town.
Aronthaer
I really don't think they're sus, but roleclaiming was a pretty stupid move. So I'm assuming mafia will just take care of them. They do seem town though.
Qwerty111
it me
Mother of all llamas
was quite quiet in newbie, bit like inkling, and was town, so for now I think they are pretty consistent.
help pls cannot scumhunt for anything, I'm kinda just using past games and obvious stuff. i suck.
