Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!
- Thread starter Dolby
- Start date
Aronthaer
Back from Hiatus (3/18/22)
I believe him. he sounds sincere.
Kirbystarship
Senior Member
Welcome back Ness! Where have you been?
do you not read...
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
Hi everyone... Tried reading up, but to no avail, I can't focus! I should be home before end of d1 tomorrow then and hopefully caught up to make a vote
Kirbystarship
Senior Member
I'm saying you might be mafia but you don't want to post because you don't want people hammering you. The last game I play I was scared because I was a mafia and I didn't post that much.
Yeah, but to lean towards mafia for those reasons doesn't really suffice imo. Plus you're basing your own experiences and applying it to three others, who may act completely different to how you would. Only speaking for myself.
Kirbystarship
Senior Member
I Read fast every now and then because I'm worried/ or scared because I'm under pressure or how the game is going.
Clam, others, and I are not all scum because we are new. Nor are most inactive people new members. Your logic seems a bit flawed in the deciding process. Newbies, like my self, may be more scare to post because we would hate to make large mistakes, though I hope everyone is able to come out of their shell soon, it doesn't make us scum. But this is a personal thought of scared to post so maybe it only applies to me, but some members just aren't as adapted to the mafia scene as you are.
I just finished that project but for Jrs. we only have to do 20 hours. It is a laboring project and very time consuming. You do what you need to finish.
Exactly, I have a feeling Tardis is calling anyone scum to get people off his back, I have a feeling I know where my vote is going.
I also agree with Kevinnn, no one is you, dont think that they all think like you, it is like driving, you may know what others are going to do but you have no control or knowledge of that. Just because you do not know us will not make us mafia automatically.
I also do not mean to target everything you say Tardis, if that is how it comes off, I just don't agree with many of your opinions and statements in this game.
This flag, it shall hang in the lynched hall of justice
Well take some time to read so you don't make the mistakes that are getting you closer to getting lynched. Take your time to read the posts and reply to them carefully.
oh?
damn. sucks I'm gonna be gone most of tmrw (today technically). Will try to be on before day ends, I'm hoping.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also hi ness. guess we'll hear from you tmrw then.
okay, first of all, ive only played like 1/12th of a mafia game, so this could all be wrong or really bad but thats ok i guess.
heyden
he seems like town to me so far. i was reading through all his posts and his reactions all seem genuine, dont have anything to use against him as of now
call me daniel
ive got nothing on daniel. could be anything.
alexi
i think her reactions to the aron incident were genuine, so ill base what i think of her off of that (for now). town, maybe an important role
tardis2016
tardis seems kinda innocent, it always feels like theyre getting jumped on (and for good reasons of course) but i dont really wanna say anything here yet. i read their posts and i have no idea what to make of anything. seems like a sloppy playstyle
panda1376
town id say, posts seem genuinely helpful
sarasakat
i don't know
xine
ive only read their big post. i dont have enough to say anything about xine.
crys
unsure, maybe scum cuz shes quieter in this game than the other but then again idk if irl stuff is going on or
toadsworthy
as others have said, he just really wants to help so hes posting anything he can.
clameatscurry
unsure!!
ness
unsure, and i dont wanna hop on the ness bandwagon just yet, so i wont say anything here yet. i will say this though, i saw someone say one of ness' posts was awkward, but from what ive seen is he tends to be an awkward poster outside of mafia. not defending him though, just something to keep in mind.
cadbberry
not definite town, but hasnt done anything to come off as scummy yet
m3ow_
i actually think m3ow is kinda scummy. the thing about "anyone lynching aron will be in my crosshairs" was like..trying too hard to be passionate about helping town.
inkling
scum, even if theyre not, its kinda annoying how all of their posts are based off of personal dislike of people, especially from that last mafia game.
kevinnn
hasnt done anything that shouts town, but also hasnt done anything scummy
cory
tbh i was doctor in the last mafia game, and i was gonna save cory from the lynching train, but i couldnt bc i was banned. however in this game im not rly believing in him so much. i think hes possibly scum. then again i dont have much evidence. so this is hard.
taesaek
don't know
aronthaer
as i said before, seemed like a bad coverup to a silly mistake, i only called him mafia to so hed be more inclined to respond to me. im not sure how party mafia works exactly so i wanted to find out the rules to see if ppl rly did claim that early. so town for now.
qwerty111
kinda innocent. not sure
mother of all llamas
idk but i think panda said they were being kinda quiet and thats true.
i feel like im saying everyone is town. i just cant find any evidence against people so i really cant go around screaming maf yet, i guess. pls be patient w me ty
nothing ive said here is certain, as i stated in the beginning im new and i legit dont know what to do but i feel obligated to contribute something so here we are
hoping someone responds to me and points out my mistakes so i can learn, but now im just gonna wait for some more posts.
ps - honey.dew is izzy reincarnated. all of izzys alts mention me, its a recurring pattern. anyway LOL
heyden
he seems like town to me so far. i was reading through all his posts and his reactions all seem genuine, dont have anything to use against him as of now
call me daniel
ive got nothing on daniel. could be anything.
alexi
i think her reactions to the aron incident were genuine, so ill base what i think of her off of that (for now). town, maybe an important role
tardis2016
tardis seems kinda innocent, it always feels like theyre getting jumped on (and for good reasons of course) but i dont really wanna say anything here yet. i read their posts and i have no idea what to make of anything. seems like a sloppy playstyle
panda1376
town id say, posts seem genuinely helpful
sarasakat
i don't know
xine
ive only read their big post. i dont have enough to say anything about xine.
crys
unsure, maybe scum cuz shes quieter in this game than the other but then again idk if irl stuff is going on or
toadsworthy
as others have said, he just really wants to help so hes posting anything he can.
clameatscurry
unsure!!
ness
unsure, and i dont wanna hop on the ness bandwagon just yet, so i wont say anything here yet. i will say this though, i saw someone say one of ness' posts was awkward, but from what ive seen is he tends to be an awkward poster outside of mafia. not defending him though, just something to keep in mind.
cadbberry
not definite town, but hasnt done anything to come off as scummy yet
m3ow_
i actually think m3ow is kinda scummy. the thing about "anyone lynching aron will be in my crosshairs" was like..trying too hard to be passionate about helping town.
inkling
scum, even if theyre not, its kinda annoying how all of their posts are based off of personal dislike of people, especially from that last mafia game.
kevinnn
hasnt done anything that shouts town, but also hasnt done anything scummy
cory
tbh i was doctor in the last mafia game, and i was gonna save cory from the lynching train, but i couldnt bc i was banned. however in this game im not rly believing in him so much. i think hes possibly scum. then again i dont have much evidence. so this is hard.
taesaek
don't know
aronthaer
as i said before, seemed like a bad coverup to a silly mistake, i only called him mafia to so hed be more inclined to respond to me. im not sure how party mafia works exactly so i wanted to find out the rules to see if ppl rly did claim that early. so town for now.
qwerty111
kinda innocent. not sure
mother of all llamas
idk but i think panda said they were being kinda quiet and thats true.
i feel like im saying everyone is town. i just cant find any evidence against people so i really cant go around screaming maf yet, i guess. pls be patient w me ty
nothing ive said here is certain, as i stated in the beginning im new and i legit dont know what to do but i feel obligated to contribute something so here we are
hoping someone responds to me and points out my mistakes so i can learn, but now im just gonna wait for some more posts.
ps - honey.dew is izzy reincarnated. all of izzys alts mention me, its a recurring pattern. anyway LOL
mother of all llamas
llamas <3
Read back and constructed some reads as I went along, sorry if I'm a little off track, I skimmed through quite a lot so I might have missed things... Sorry if they're repeats too
Heyden- He reacted very angry/upset towards Aronthaer claiming doctor which makes me believe he's possibly town.
Call me Daniel- Mostly questioning other people and such trying to find reactions.
Alexi- Assisting in town activity trying to lead in the right direction, reactions seemed pretty real too.
Tardis2016- Has been acting very off in this game from my point of view, I can't really tell if he's confused or what. I'm not really getting any suspicions on him and he seems pretty lost.
Panda1376- Step up from usual gameplay and meta seems pretty accurate, possible town.
Sarasakat- Very pro-town behaviour, trying to lead town in the right direction.
Xine- Very in-depth and confident with their posts, I have a gut feeling she's town.
Crys- Weirdly playing, their gameplay in the last game made it obvious they were fool, looks like they're trying harder this time round so could be scum, but not enough to justify anything.
Toadsworthy- Unsure, not seeing much from him.
ClamEatsCurry- Seen lurking the read, says quite a few people, neutral on them.
Ness- I'm torn between Ness, his behavior is different but his disappearance is what struck me weird. Although he had a pretty good reason, I don't know what the chances are of getting scum over and over are though...
Cadbberry- Has been lurking a LOT also, claims to getting the hang of mafia and posting every once in a while, a little wary of her...
M3ow_- Her suspicion on Ness was pretty unexplained, although she's usually quiet on day 1 despite what party she's in.
Inkling- Has been pretty quiet unlike Tarot, but I think they're staying quiet due to what happened last time and so many arguements were caused...
Kevinnn- Hasn't posted much (I shouldn't be talking though), so I can't get a proper read on them.
Cory- He's usually one to try and lead town, and I can definitely see it in this game
Taesaek- Said they were travelling so I'm not sure yet.
Aronthaer- Don't know what to say, claimed Doctor so he's most likely town unless he's lying, but I don't think scum would risk that much just as day 1 started, although that was a very silly mistake.
Shondell- Banned and awaiting replacement.
Qwerty111- In the newbie game she was pretty chill even though she was the day 1 lynch, same behavior in this game so not sure yet.
Shiida- Has made pretty decent posts so far and agreeable reads, her RQS was very similar to the one in Tarot so yeah, probably town.
Honey.dew- Banned and awaiting replacement
Heyden- He reacted very angry/upset towards Aronthaer claiming doctor which makes me believe he's possibly town.
Call me Daniel- Mostly questioning other people and such trying to find reactions.
Alexi- Assisting in town activity trying to lead in the right direction, reactions seemed pretty real too.
Tardis2016- Has been acting very off in this game from my point of view, I can't really tell if he's confused or what. I'm not really getting any suspicions on him and he seems pretty lost.
Panda1376- Step up from usual gameplay and meta seems pretty accurate, possible town.
Sarasakat- Very pro-town behaviour, trying to lead town in the right direction.
Xine- Very in-depth and confident with their posts, I have a gut feeling she's town.
Crys- Weirdly playing, their gameplay in the last game made it obvious they were fool, looks like they're trying harder this time round so could be scum, but not enough to justify anything.
Toadsworthy- Unsure, not seeing much from him.
ClamEatsCurry- Seen lurking the read, says quite a few people, neutral on them.
Ness- I'm torn between Ness, his behavior is different but his disappearance is what struck me weird. Although he had a pretty good reason, I don't know what the chances are of getting scum over and over are though...
Cadbberry- Has been lurking a LOT also, claims to getting the hang of mafia and posting every once in a while, a little wary of her...
M3ow_- Her suspicion on Ness was pretty unexplained, although she's usually quiet on day 1 despite what party she's in.
Inkling- Has been pretty quiet unlike Tarot, but I think they're staying quiet due to what happened last time and so many arguements were caused...
Kevinnn- Hasn't posted much (I shouldn't be talking though), so I can't get a proper read on them.
Cory- He's usually one to try and lead town, and I can definitely see it in this game
Taesaek- Said they were travelling so I'm not sure yet.
Aronthaer- Don't know what to say, claimed Doctor so he's most likely town unless he's lying, but I don't think scum would risk that much just as day 1 started, although that was a very silly mistake.
Shondell- Banned and awaiting replacement.
Qwerty111- In the newbie game she was pretty chill even though she was the day 1 lynch, same behavior in this game so not sure yet.
Shiida- Has made pretty decent posts so far and agreeable reads, her RQS was very similar to the one in Tarot so yeah, probably town.
Honey.dew- Banned and awaiting replacement
Welll. Slept in and looks like I'll be here today instead. Feel like a piece of **** for not making it to my uncle's funeral and istg if any of you come at me for AtE or any personal attacks I will go right back at you. Apparently AtE = scum but apparently NOT after the way Aron reacted to claiming doctor SO I'm just throwing that out there, I'm not in a good place right now.
all I wana say right now is, shiida, you have a really good point with m3ow. I'm not saying m3ow is scum but I didn't like how she basically told us all to get off Aron and that he made a mistake bla bla. I already had said my opinions towards him weere 60% town, 20% scum, 20% doctor, but then she said that it was like I had to be 100% believed he was town or i was scum.
I hope that makes sense. It's just something real quick I thought I'd say. I'll get everyones reads together later when I have a better, more clear mindset.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Actually nah I'll do it now.
heyden
reactions towards aron's claim seemed genuine. town to me.
call me daniel
also was there to react to aron's claim.. seemed kinda off with the "whats your role." instead of reacting to the fact our doctor just outted themselves. but, seems pretty town to me regardless.
tardis2016
as always, tardis just seems confused and i dont really think thats a good reason to be lynching him to be honest. idk what he is reallly.
panda1376
town. panda's been really helpful so far. i didnt really agree with her x cory back and forth but i guess both made sense.
sarasakat
also was there to react to aron's claim... actually kinda seems waay off and kinda scummy especially with asking about anyone's roles if they had one similar to Ronald Reagan... Idk if you meant to make it sound like that, but it did. thats been the one thing that seems off to me for her.
xine
xine always has good reasons but y'know, I didn't agree with the inkling case because theres lots of others who have yet to post a lot too, so that didn't make sense to me but the rest did.
crys
i'm awaiting this "[good]" post from crys. should be interesting.
toadsworthy
your read on sarasakat, while some points weren't as strong as they could've been, made sense. pretty town to me i think.
clameatscurry
not really enough posts to say, but the one they made about aron bringing attention to himself was smart and obv made sense. idk im null for them.
ness
unsure, but i think i'll be more sure when he posts more today.
cadbberry
her RQS seemed really off but it's her first game so, i'm really just thinking town. null, if anything.
m3ow_
said my opinion before.
inkling
as always a little defensive, but i think this time it was pretty justified.
kevinnn
null. hasnt posted enough.
cory
town. if anyone reads town in this entire list to me, it's cory.
taesaek
reactions to the DR claim seemed genuine and i agreed to them. pretty town to me.
aronthaer
i really dont know.
qwerty111
null. not enough posts.
mother of all llamas
null. not enough posts. but im glad they pposted their reads on everyone just recently.
all I wana say right now is, shiida, you have a really good point with m3ow. I'm not saying m3ow is scum but I didn't like how she basically told us all to get off Aron and that he made a mistake bla bla. I already had said my opinions towards him weere 60% town, 20% scum, 20% doctor, but then she said that it was like I had to be 100% believed he was town or i was scum.
I hope that makes sense. It's just something real quick I thought I'd say. I'll get everyones reads together later when I have a better, more clear mindset.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Actually nah I'll do it now.
heyden
reactions towards aron's claim seemed genuine. town to me.
call me daniel
also was there to react to aron's claim.. seemed kinda off with the "whats your role." instead of reacting to the fact our doctor just outted themselves. but, seems pretty town to me regardless.
tardis2016
as always, tardis just seems confused and i dont really think thats a good reason to be lynching him to be honest. idk what he is reallly.
panda1376
town. panda's been really helpful so far. i didnt really agree with her x cory back and forth but i guess both made sense.
sarasakat
also was there to react to aron's claim... actually kinda seems waay off and kinda scummy especially with asking about anyone's roles if they had one similar to Ronald Reagan... Idk if you meant to make it sound like that, but it did. thats been the one thing that seems off to me for her.
xine
xine always has good reasons but y'know, I didn't agree with the inkling case because theres lots of others who have yet to post a lot too, so that didn't make sense to me but the rest did.
crys
i'm awaiting this "[good]" post from crys. should be interesting.
toadsworthy
your read on sarasakat, while some points weren't as strong as they could've been, made sense. pretty town to me i think.
clameatscurry
not really enough posts to say, but the one they made about aron bringing attention to himself was smart and obv made sense. idk im null for them.
ness
unsure, but i think i'll be more sure when he posts more today.
cadbberry
her RQS seemed really off but it's her first game so, i'm really just thinking town. null, if anything.
m3ow_
said my opinion before.
inkling
as always a little defensive, but i think this time it was pretty justified.
kevinnn
null. hasnt posted enough.
cory
town. if anyone reads town in this entire list to me, it's cory.
taesaek
reactions to the DR claim seemed genuine and i agreed to them. pretty town to me.
aronthaer
i really dont know.
qwerty111
null. not enough posts.
mother of all llamas
null. not enough posts. but im glad they pposted their reads on everyone just recently.
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
MoTL, have you made any strides to improving your playstyle? And if so, what are they?
I'd actually like to talk about this at depth post game, but I don't think AtE is an inherent scumtell. AtE is very situational and it, like anything else, depends on the motivation for using AtE. Pride? Being hurt IRL? Intimidation tactics by scum? All possible.
Gonna read back and develop some reads.
- - - Post Merge - - -
And sorry for your loss Alexi. Feel free to take a break from thread if things get too intense
I'd actually like to talk about this at depth post game, but I don't think AtE is an inherent scumtell. AtE is very situational and it, like anything else, depends on the motivation for using AtE. Pride? Being hurt IRL? Intimidation tactics by scum? All possible.
Gonna read back and develop some reads.
- - - Post Merge - - -
And sorry for your loss Alexi. Feel free to take a break from thread if things get too intense
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
I have to go out for a few hours, but when I get back I'll make a nice long post of my reads y'all seem to like from me, with all them juicy quotes and stuff. Should be back in the afternoon. Seems like everyone is posting their reads, yet don't really say who they want to lynch today.
@Alexi's post. I said Aron made a dumb move claiming, and then I asked for their rolename. I dunno how else I'm supposed to react when it seemed Cory was flaming him for claiming, didn't find it nessary to say much else. More on what I think of them will come tonight with the post. But you're read on me is a bit inaccurate.
@Alexi's post. I said Aron made a dumb move claiming, and then I asked for their rolename. I dunno how else I'm supposed to react when it seemed Cory was flaming him for claiming, didn't find it nessary to say much else. More on what I think of them will come tonight with the post. But you're read on me is a bit inaccurate.
