Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!
- Thread starter Dolby
- Start date
well ive been sus of you, and the fact that cad keeps backing you up isn't helping. it seems a bit pushy and hurried. now you'd think this'd be too obvious a scum move, but maf is hoping to attribute this to cad's newness, thus clearing her, when in actuality she consulted her team for instructions.
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
Then if it should be objectively read as me being scummy, then what's the need to add in the subjective "to me in my opinion"? That makes it sound like there's reasonable room for interpreting it differently.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Well then why have you been sus of me?
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
Why is Qwerty posting in the critique thread and not participating in here ? they're as bad a Mother.
speaking of qwerty....
SarasaKat pointed out something about their wording hold up.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Completely forgot about this. That wording was waaayy off to me too.
I am not backing her all the way, I am just saying she is less of a target then Daniel and Cory. In my reads I even say I am a bit sus of her
I backed SarasaKat in my original mini read but after some points were made about the way she is pushing certain people and her constant change of stand points on players left me pretty sus of them. Even if their Scumhunting is helping town my suspicions of her are still in play.
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
Tbh I forgot about saying that myself, but god yeah.
That is a great point Alexi, Qwerty has been unusually silent and participating in other places, and that wording was very scummy
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
Pushing certain people? What do you mean by that?Cad said:
That was a wording mistake on my behalf, I am playing ToS and my mind is else where, I meant to say
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
So the only thing is my changing standpoints on Aron? Or do you think I've done it in areas besides him?
I would say that is a main standpoint that you have switched on so many times to make is confusing. Also some of what you have said could be portrayed as scummy though from ToS that is kind of how you roll so maybe you are not as scummy as I thought and I was just over thinking it
???What's wrong with it? What else could I say- "Mafia are obviously going to kill a doctor?". Oh. Actually. That could of worked.
Did you even read my post there? I'm struggling to scum hunt, so I was asking for help.
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
I switched opinions three times total
Initial: Townie
Doc claim: Scummy
Hearing his role name claim and hearing his remorse: Townie.
If that's only "a" main standpoint I've changed my mind on, who else have I changed my mind on?
What else have I said that could be portrayed as scummy?
- - - Post Merge - - -
Saying "Mafia has to deal with the doctor" puts the Doctor in a negative role, if that makes sense.
*goes on over to critique thread*
I think we've all agreed on this
My reads may change after night ends, depending what happens so like I said not gonna post them yet
but I do have a question for cadbberry - why'd you vote for me then unvote? was it my defense, were you just too quick to vote?
I know it's your first game but voting quickly like that seems odd to me since in my first game (BoI) I was very very hesitant to vote.
- - - Post Merge - - -
oh and Tardis too, since he did the same.
My reads may change after night ends, depending what happens so like I said not gonna post them yet
but I do have a question for cadbberry - why'd you vote for me then unvote? was it my defense, were you just too quick to vote?
I know it's your first game but voting quickly like that seems odd to me since in my first game (BoI) I was very very hesitant to vote.
- - - Post Merge - - -
oh and Tardis too, since he did the same.
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
sorry guys, im going to be leaving shortly, i was planning on having most of the day free and wanted to read back and make a post incase i die and if i get back in time i will still do that, but if not look at my posts upon my death and make sure to take them into consideration. stay safe everyone.
Certain little things that other players have pointed out etc etc, I really can not compile a list at the moment as we are now going out shopping since I finished my ToS game and so I am stuck on mobile, but it is just little tweaks and tiny things that seem scummy
Example
Arstotzkan
A scum mom
What did you think about my reply to Panda there? I didn't think the point was too valid tbh. I just didn't know what to reply to in a tone accusation (because what are you supposed to say to someone saying your tone is weird). I agree it's a big tell, but there isn't much you can reply to when it comes to a tone tell.
People made some accusations about you but as time went on I didn't think they were as big and important making me switch my vote to inkling
