So going through some of these I noticed I didn't have enough information to make a case for/neutral/against them so I left out anyone I didn't feel like I had enough knowledge of to give an accurate opinion on. As a heads up, I did not do these in order so some of them may be referencing earlier/later members that I did before or after,
Heyden - Really rubs me the wrong with way with his exit, their last few posts before he left were making sure no lynch would never be an option (to be fair it's a bad idea), but he made sure to leave making sure we didn't lynch him when no one was really sus of him or throwing his name out there. His past few posts really throw me on a sus trail. Not to mention for the first part of the game he put himself on invisible so we couldn't see that he was viewing the thread (see
http://www.belltreeforums.com/showth...=1#post6434321 ). This post doesn't necessarily say scum, but going invisible is sus to me. Could be town, but I'm very wary of them.
Call Me Daniel - Seems pretty town to me. I don't really have any evidence or thoughts against him, he has the same problem as me where I don't like to just rehash what people have said (according to
http://www.belltreeforums.com/showth...t=#post6434753 ).
Alexi - M3ow_ had some really good cases against Alexi and she does seem to be a bit wishy-washy on how she deals with Aron specifically. I hate to just go "yeah they said it best" since I hate rehashing, but since it's one of the most prominent topics atm I may as well, I agree with M3ow_ and Kat's reads on her.
Tardis2016 - He's said some scummy things to me, the main part about him that bugs me is he wrote
http://www.belltreeforums.com/showth...t=#post6432955 and then accused inactives of being scum. I think he has scum posts on his hands, but I'm not claiming him to be scum just yet and like Aron may have just gotten himself in a bad spot.
Panda1376 - My opinion generally stays the same as what I said last night.
SarasaKat - Kat's probably the person who will best read me, lol. Anyways, she's been a helpful member to both Aron and been scumhunting pretty actively so I'm inclined to say town.
Crys - Will probably have a valid opinion once their big post comes, figured I'd mention them since their hype.
Toadsworthy - Disappeared for a bit (but he let us know ahead of time), but when he was posting he struck me as a town member.
Ness - For a long time I was on the bandwagon of the whole "Ness disappeared, he's scum," and I still haven't let him off the hook necessarily. However, his newest posts seemed genuine and I'm willing to hear him out when he gives us more to read.
Cadbberry - Knowing Cad for a while, I know she can get emotions tied up in her logic, but I'll be looking at the posts objectively and not as my friend. She got really defensive against Tardis even mentioning mine, Cad and Kevin's names when we weren't under much pressure so that rubs me the wrong way.
M3ow_ - I think they are town, they had some great points against Alexi so I'm inclined to trust them. Looking back, all of their posts have been very rational and with valid reasoning to help town so I'm inclined to go with a town read on them.
Kevinnn - Not many posts so it's hard to say, but like me for a while he was like "hey I'm catching up" as his posts, and like Cad, the moment our names were mentioned he got really defensive. I'm on board with Kat that I wanna hear more from him because he seems off to me.
Cory - I stick to what I said in my past post, I don't know Cory all that well and definitely don't know his meta so I don't know if he acts like this when he's town or not, but I think he came out swinging way too fast to be scum D1.
Aronthaer - There are so many red flags here, so many. I agree with the people who say he's town and just did a really bad **** up when he cracked under pressure, so while he's said some very scummy things and I've questioned him for some things he's said, I don't think he's too scummy yet. My opinion may change as the game goes on, but I'm on a town read for him right now.
So halfway through this I found out about the search feature and I'd been doing this the long way the first half...****. Anyway, there's my thoughts of people I have an opinion on right now.
