Moe or Bob?

[Nostalgicdreamerqueen]

Choosing my villagers like my dreamies has been a very hard decision. Right now, I have Marina, Sherb, Ricky, Biff, Chaddar, Cleo, Gayle, Eugene, Deirdre and Fang on my island.

My dream island is: Marina, Sherb, Fang, Chaddar, Cleo (or Judy unsure- need some advice here too) Julian, Cookie, Tangy, Dom, and rather Moe or Bob (at least I think)

The limit is 10 and I don’t think having too many cats would be wise because I lile variety so maybe 2 cats is good. I struggle because at first I wanted Mitzi and Kiki then I wanted Raymond (three smugs wouldn’t give enough variety for me and I love Julian and have grown fond of Chaddar) but I really can’t decide between Moe and Bob

I had them both in Wild world though I had Bob first and liked him and his house a lot. Then I had Moe in new leaf and loved him also and became sad when he left. I love them both and cannot decide which do you think I should choose? and who would fit best with my dream villagers?

 

[Jhine7]

I would go with Bob. Don't really have a solid reason other than I think he's pretty cool! I agree, tough decision!

 

[k e r f u f f l e]

I'd vote in Moe's favor. He's so cute!

For your Cleo/Judy situation, I think Cleo has those 'old-school Animal Crossing' vibes.

 

[Mezzanine]

deleted

 

[Hobowire]

I would go with Bob because he's OG.

 

[Florence + The Machine]

Moe is the best cat so I'd vote for him. Bob is kinda ugly imo and I don't like his shady eyes. Bob also has a lame/bad house while Moe's is very cute and blue.

Judy also has creepy eyes so I'd vote for Cleo. Her house is a dermatologist's office, which is kinda cool.

 

[rubyrubert]

I don’t like either (Punchy ftw!), but I think I’d rather have Moe.

Also Judy is good. I think her eyes are creepy, but I actually kinda like that trait lol. Her fur is really pretty

 

[Etown20]

I prefer Bob, his default expression just amuses me - like he is always up to mischief. If you liked his house in Wild World, it's very similar in New Horizons and is probably one of the more distinct houses in the game.

 

[Chungus]

I would put all of your villagers together in an app like ACNH Life and compare how they look together. Try Moe among your lineup first and then switch with Bob, just to see which cat compliments the rest of your villagers better. Same goes for Cleo/Judy.

As far as my personal preference, I have nostalgia with Bob, but I had Moe more recently in New Horizons and enjoyed him. Both lazy cats have their merits.

 

[Alicia]

I'd go with Moe!
I love Moe, he's such a cutie.

 

[axo]

I'd pick Moe, for sure! He's adorable and unique, and super underrated.

 

[Bk1234]

I don’t like either of them, but if I had to pick, I would go with Moe. Moe has that goofy, I’m dumb, but cute look. Bob just looks stupid...

 

[lilyplaysacnh]

Choosing my villagers like my dreamies has been a very hard decision. Right now, I have Marina, Sherb, Ricky, Biff, Chaddar, Cleo, Gayle, Eugene, Deirdre and Fang on my island.

My dream island is: Marina, Sherb, Fang, Chaddar, Cleo (or Judy unsure- need some advice here too) Julian, Cookie, Tangy, Dom, and rather Moe or Bob (at least I think)

The limit is 10 and I don’t think having too many cats would be wise because I lile variety so maybe 2 cats is good. I struggle because at first I wanted Mitzi and Kiki then I wanted Raymond (three smugs wouldn’t give enough variety for me and I love Julian and have grown fond of Chaddar) but I really can’t decide between Moe and Bob

I had them both in Wild world though I had Bob first and liked him and his house a lot. Then I had Moe in new leaf and loved him also and became sad when he left. I love them both and cannot decide which do you think I should choose? and who would fit best with my dream villagers?

bob!! i’ve been looking for him and i love him smmmm

 

[dragonair]

I'd never put Bob in my town but he just exudes a vibe that I really love.

 

[lilyplaysacnh]

I'd never put Bob in my town but he just exudes a vibe that I really love.

yess same

 

[Aromatisse]

Bob! <3 He's so cute and weird, I love him. Plus he's purple.

 

[Dunquixote]

I’ve never had either of them but I can certainly see the appeal in both of them and I think they’re both cute. I personally would go for Moe because I this his design is interesting along with his eyes. These are just my opinions; since this is your island, what matters more is how you feel about them

 

[xTech]

Even though I really don't like either of them at all honestly, if I had to choose one, then I guess i'd go for Bob. His character design and outfit are kind of nice and not too over the top, whereas Moe looks like someone took his two front teeth out, and then stabbed them into his lip. I also think Bob's exterior is wayyy better than Moe's overly blue house, and I prefer his colourful playroom themed interior over Moe's blue playroom as well, since it just seems more playful. Moe's also doesn't have enough furniture for my liking, and his house just feels pretty empty for a playroom if i'm honest. Of course while the overall decision to this question for me is Bob, if it were my decision i'd rather yeet them both into the void than keep one of them.

 

[fluttershy300]

I would get Moe but it’s your choice.

 

[JunoHorizon]

Bob! I'm biased though, Moe is good too.