Mafia Murder Mystery Mafia-Mafia Win

[Chrystina]

daniel you suck for that suspense

**** im sorry guys. and sorry crys for not believing your claim. i suck

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Well okay

 

[toadsworthy]

Damn yo.... I mean Cory you wanna blame me for all that ok? Lots of people had opinions about the three I just chose one. And cmon with crys' history she could've been anything

 

[Cory]

Damn yo.... I mean Cory you wanna blame me for all that ok? Lots of people had opinions about the three I just chose one. And cmon with crys' history she could've been anything

I didn't blame you for everything.
Did you not see the Tarot pt.2 comment?

 

[Fleshy]

Toadsworthy you better explain yourself...

everyone who didn't remove their vote from crys better explain themselves tbh

 

[N e s s]

*lip smack*

no comment.

 

[toadsworthy]

I stand by that the mafia just kinda laid low with all that going on. I don't think chrys or panda is necessarily mafia yet

 

[Seroja]

but Tom was the one the "said" he PM'd everyone ? sooo.... ? i agree i was careless to take Tom's word for what had happened. lesson learned.

Ohh, but you were the one who posted it here (not Tom. I wasn't on Discord or wherever that took place so I didn't know) and you didn't mention that Tom was the one who said it at first. Not everyone is where the PMs take place so yes, I think we should all be more careful with how we share information.

 

[PandaDarling]

i just want to make is publicly known that Improper claimed to both Tom and I and then when i asked Tom about it he lied to me and even though he knew there was a chance of her being Doctor he didnt change his vote off of her.

i want to know why Kirby, Chrystina, Tom, Toad, and Karla took a chance of lynching out Doctor ?

 

[toadsworthy]

I mean with improper you can get damn near anything... And with everything going on, I believed her story the least. It wasn't the best move but I made due with what I had.

 

[toadsworthy]

i just want to make is publicly known that Improper claimed to both Tom and I and then when i asked Tom about it he lied to me and even though he knew there was a chance of her being Doctor he didnt change his vote off of her.

i want to know why Kirby, Chrystina, Tom, Toad, and Karla took a chance of lynching out Doctor ?

That's a strange story? Tom needs to explain

 

[mogyay]

i'm also inclined to believe mafia are lying low and laughing at us. whoever coasted through that lynch is looking shady. also why didn't dolby vote?

 

[N e s s]

I'll see to making a case/analysis later within tonight to later tomorrow.

 

[mogyay]

oh i see u dolby nice timing

 

[Cory]

i'm also inclined to believe mafia are lying low and laughing at us. whoever coasted through that lynch is looking shady. also why didn't dolby vote?

So Karla...

 

[mogyay]

So Karla...

karla and kirby

 

[Seroja]

karla and kirby

Kirby's vote is somewhat sus because he was in Crys' position in the last game. Why wouldn't he believe Crys' claim tbh... and Karla please explain yourself.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

As I've said before I'm not apologizing for lynching Improper. This is how I viewed the whole situation:

- Once Improper stopped joking around and started suggesting a policy lynch on Liam (despite obviously better lynches), red flags were set off in my mind. I swap my vote from Ness to Improper to apply more pressure and see where it leads.
- Improper messages me over Discord asking if I'm really third party, I reply yes. About an hour later I ask if they're a PR, I get an eggplant emoji as a response. Ask for clarification if they mean doc, they say big D. I disregard the claim then because to me it just means they're not playing semi-seriously enough.
- Improper kind of hints in the thread about some sort of investigative role, Panda messages me asking if I believe Improper's claim (the DM claim). Thinkin she meant the post in the thread, I say "what her softin cop?" "No the other claim" I am naturally confused, only to eventually remember oh yeah eggplant. I ask what she claimed to Panda and Panda is like yo wtf hold on a min. Go back, as Crys. Crys is like yeah I'm doc. Then they out.

So I ask you what good is an outed doc? In the Discord the response I get (post death mind you) is a Doc and a number. That's well and good I suppose, but I'm talkin like unknowns here. I ain't for sure Crys is the doc and given their highly chaotic playstyles, I'm not inclined to trust them. So I calculate the risk in my head.

Outed doc isn't good for two reasons:
1. They're gonna die N1, probably blocked if there's a roleblocker on maf
2. If they don't die N1, they'll probably be blocked enough times to cast doubt. So we circle back to D1 all over again, is Crys doc or not.

Secondly Crys outed what three hours before day end? Let's assume Crys was mafia and not the real doc. Real doc is in a dilemma, it's D1 and someone's claimed a role that's pretty much impossible given our setup. Do they out? Do they get someone to CC Crys for them? Is it enough to sway people?

Day 1 was nothing but a game of risk assessment for me. Yeah I'm third party and yeah, I win either way, but despite lynching the doc I am actively working in the best interests of town. I determined the risk of leaving Crys alive was a bigger threat to town than them being a bigger asset to it.

 

[Kirbystarship]

I didn't coast through the lynch. I shared my thoughts and didn't see Crys soft claim.

 

[PandaDarling]

As I've said before I'm not apologizing for lynching Improper. This is how I viewed the whole situation:

- Once Improper stopped joking around and started suggesting a policy lynch on Liam (despite obviously better lynches), red flags were set off in my mind. I swap my vote from Ness to Improper to apply more pressure and see where it leads.
- Improper messages me over Discord asking if I'm really third party, I reply yes. About an hour later I ask if they're a PR, I get an eggplant emoji as a response. Ask for clarification if they mean doc, they say big D. I disregard the claim then because to me it just means they're not playing semi-seriously enough.
- Improper kind of hints in the thread about some sort of investigative role, Panda messages me asking if I believe Improper's claim (the DM claim). Thinkin she meant the post in the thread, I say "what her softin cop?" "No the other claim" I am naturally confused, only to eventually remember oh yeah eggplant. I ask what she claimed to Panda and Panda is like yo wtf hold on a min. Go back, as Crys. Crys is like yeah I'm doc. Then they out.

So I ask you what good is an outed doc? In the Discord the response I get (post death mind you) is a Doc and a number. That's well and good I suppose, but I'm talkin like unknowns here. I ain't for sure Crys is the doc and given their highly chaotic playstyles, I'm not inclined to trust them. So I calculate the risk in my head.

Outed doc isn't good for two reasons:
1. They're gonna die N1, probably blocked if there's a roleblocker on maf
2. If they don't die N1, they'll probably be blocked enough times to cast doubt. So we circle back to D1 all over again, is Crys doc or not.

Secondly Crys outed what three hours before day end? Let's assume Crys was mafia and not the real doc. Real doc is in a dilemma, it's D1 and someone's claimed a role that's pretty much impossible given our setup. Do they out? Do they get someone to CC Crys for them? Is it enough to sway people?

Day 1 was nothing but a game of risk assessment for me. Yeah I'm third party and yeah, I win either way, but despite lynching the doc I am actively working in the best interests of town. I determined the risk of leaving Crys alive was a bigger threat to town than them being a bigger asset to it.

@Tom but Improper wouldnt have been an "outed doctor" if you would have taken you're vote off of her she wouldnt have outed herself out of desperation to survive....