Mafia Mystic Messenger Mafia [Endgame]

[toadsworthy]

If vig is going to shoot kirby, detective please choose someone else to inspect... Kit, Me, Mog, f11, byngo
also good morning everyone, so power roles would be doctor, cop, watcher, vig, and bus driver. Does that seem like too much?

- - - Post Merge - - -

are we certain there even is a vigilante?

- - - Post Merge - - -

hi friends I'm back will post thoughts in a bit

can someone help me out and tell me when night ends

7pm EST. Or 8 and a half hours from now

- - - Post Merge - - -

I work tonight, so I will not be around for EoD

- - - Post Merge - - -

EoN*

 

[KermitTea]

Ok here are my thoughts.

Hopefully maf KP will be just 1 tonight. I think I read that this game was # mafia / 2 rounded up? So if there is 1 kill, and no doc save, then we can confirm there are 3 total mafia and 2 surviving ones.

That being said @Oliver I highly suggest you protect one of the confirmed blues.

Ok, as to who could be remaining scum. Feasibly I only see mog, kit, f11, and kirby at this point. Ruled out Toads for the time being. I haven't looked back at Dad's posts yet so this is subject to change but yea.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Forgot to mention that list of confirmed blues includes yourself. Don't be afraid to use the protect on yourself. If anything, put the names into RNG and pick one

 

[oliversacnl]

Forgot to mention that list of confirmed blues includes yourself. Don't be afraid to use the protect on yourself. If anything, put the names into RNG and pick one

I think I've said this like 5 times already, but I am going to protect Zendel. Not only is he my boy, but his ability is probably the most important tbh, except for maybe Evan, but Evan can protect himself, I think.

Thus, I shall protect Zendel with my last dying breath.

 

[KermitTea]

I think I've said this like 5 times already, but I am going to protect Zendel. Not only is he my boy, but his ability is probably the most important tbh, except for maybe Evan, but Evan can protect himself, I think.

Thus, I shall protect Zendel with my last dying breath.

Please rethink what you are doing.

If I say I am going to protect X, then mafia are most likely not going to attempt a kill on X.

I did this last game when I was doc. I said I was going to protect kit, but ended up protecting myself. That way, it's a psychological double protect.

What you are doing is noble, but it's not optimal play.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, I usually don't say that in public. But since it's your first game, and I'm fairly certain you're not trying to do something other than what you're saying, so...

Since that's all out, you have a choice to take my advice or keep doing what you are doing.

 

[Byngo]

hmm dad seemed sensitive whenever toad was brought up. rn im thinking there's scum between toad/kirby, cuz if kirbys scum i see no motivation for toad to push his partner when there's 3 other names on the table

which speaking of the other 3 (mog/kit/f11) still gotta look through dads **** and each users posts individually. i will say of the 3 that my sus on mog has been waning for a while

 

[moonford]

hmm dad seemed sensitive whenever toad was brought up. rn im thinking there's scum between toad/kirby, cuz if kirbys scum i see no motivation for toad to push his partner when there's 3 other names on the table

which speaking of the other 3 (mog/kit/f11) still gotta look through dads **** and each users posts individually. i will say of the 3 that my sus on mog has been waning for a while

You're probably mafia tbh.

 

[Byngo]

are we certain there even is a vigilante?

no. does the possibility scare you?

- - - Post Merge - - -

You're probably mafia tbh.

tbh

 

[oliversacnl]

If I say I am going to protect X, then mafia are most likely not going to attempt a kill on X.

I thought of that too, don't get me wrong, but it's just not worth the risk of having him killed. This isn't really so much a matter of being noble; it's more of a matter of utilitarianism. His role is more important than mine, and with him, we're more likely to win.

It's really not that big of a deal for me. I'll just play the next game.

Besides, I've already promised Zendel. And, like I said, he's my boy.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Thank you for the advice, though, KermitTea. I might do something like that once I'm a more experienced player and can actually pull that off.

 

[KermitTea]

I thought of that too, don't get me wrong, but it's just not worth the risk of having him killed. This isn't really so much a matter of being noble; it's more of a matter of utilitarianism. His role is more important than mine, and with him, we're more likely to win.

It's really not that big of a deal for me. I'll just play the next game.

Besides, I've already promised Zendel. And, like I said, he's my boy.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Thank you for the advice, though, KermitTea. I might do something like that once I'm a more experienced player and can actually pull that off.

Disagree; your role is equally if not more important than his.

If you successfully protect someone you give Town an extra day of majority. That's one more day to discuss and scumhunt.

Let that sink in.

 

[moonford]

Using my night action on Heyden, feel like they may go for him because he's kinda carrying town right now.

 

[KermitTea]

^ That's assuming Mafia only have 1KP now.

But still, the Doc is important.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Using my night action on Heyden, feel like they may go for him because he's kinda carrying town right now.

okay lowkey you posted that a tad too early if anything maf could change their actions now

also rip post merge

 

[moonford]

If they have one night kill and go for me or Heyden it's over for them.

I'm being protected and I'm watching Heyden, it'd be a waste.

 

[KermitTea]

also @zendel sorry if I'm making it sound like oliver shouldn't protect you, you deserve protecting fosho but it's just trying to get a successful doc protect so town numbers don't drop

- - - Post Merge - - -

anddd rip post merge again LOL

 

[Byngo]

If they have one night kill and go for me or Heyden it's over for them.

I'm being protected and I'm watching Heyden, it'd be a waste.

u do realize by narrating plans in public, maf can simply proceed accordingly

 

[moonford]

u do realize by narrating plans in public, maf can simply proceed accordingly

Oh crap.

- - - Post Merge - - -

also @zendel sorry if I'm making it sound like oliver shouldn't protect you, you deserve protecting fosho but it's just trying to get a successful doc protect so town numbers don't drop

- - - Post Merge - - -

anddd rip post merge again LOL

It's fine.

 

[oliversacnl]

Yeah... the only reason I'm telling the truth rn is so the actual townsfolk can act accordingly tbh

I know it means the mafia see it too, but... still

 

[KermitTea]

yeah especially since oliver seems set on protecting you, you don't need to tell us what youre doing until night phase is over since you're bound to survive unless mafia 1) have 2KP and 2) decide to stack both of it onto you

- - - Post Merge - - -

sigh maybe this game is rip

 

[moonford]

yeah especially since oliver seems set on protecting you, you don't need to tell us what youre doing until night phase is over since you're bound to survive unless mafia 1) have 2KP and 2) decide to stack both of it onto you

Don't think 2 kp is likely if we assume there is 3 mafia (2 now) and if they have 2 kp and use both on me then they have wasted the chance to get two kills and instead only get one.


Kirby is obviously scum, we lynch him, there will be one scum left, they surrender, we win, the end.

 

[KermitTea]

exactly which is why you dont really need to tell us what youre doing

 

[moonford]

exactly which is why you dont really need to tell us what youre doing

Oh well.

Not going to be posting on here until night ends.