I don't really have much confidence in anyone I have at null or below at this point in time. Also, just want to say to Zendel that I was legitimately annoyed by both Cleb in Smash and Ness now, and I would be regardless of my alignment in either game.
I am slightly suspicious of Daniel's survivor claim, but I am willing to let it slide for now, especially if we are able to determine that there are three maf and no other third parties, because that's the only setup in which adding another third party makes any sense in terms of game-balance.
I see few worlds in which Byngo, Bianca, or Kermit are mafia.
F11 actually easily could be scum, and many of her posts are extremely hypocritical, while also being non-contributive.
Biancasbotique Dolby Amazonevan19
Damniel - I don't even know lul Kirbystarship
mogyay - wya, probably town
Fireninja1 - smh N e s s
oliversacnl - newb but I think the chances of maf are low Kit
Byngo - idk im dumb but most likely not mafia
f11
Heyden - im afraid of heyden lowkey and whenever he townreads me day 1 he's mafia so I gotta think about this one, most likely not mafia. Dad
Toadsworthy - feels off idk Zendel KermitTea
uhh so yeah I wouldn't be surprised if there was a Ness/Dolby/Kit/Kirby scum team considering the interactions dolby has had with them and kirby's reads list. I can elaborate on all of these but please don't ask
I feel like I would be comfortable with the town reads, except that see posted this about half an hour before, in which she pretty much townlocks FN1. There was only one post between there(from Toads), so there wasn't new content to change her mind
As for Dan and Ness, I can honestly understand being sus of both of them, but I particularly don't like the shift in trying to form a sus on Dan for being "anti-Ness". There was a good deal of change between the time of the reads and EoD, but F11's reads remained fairly consistent from what I could get from her posts
As for Oliver, I've been null on him for the most part. Though i don't really like this post here, though it's pretty minor
Everybody, please literally never trust my judgment ever again. I can't ****ing believe N e s s was the jester. I should have seen it coming. ...I have a feeling I'm going to be saying that a lot during this game.
Now I feel bad since the whole "who's the jester" thing drew attention away from him. Damn. I seriously wish I hadn't done that.
OK, I think that FireNinja1 is definitely in the mafia now. I think he called himself the jester to act like he wanted to be lynched to pretend that he wasn't trying to avoid death. Sighs.
The first section, on one hand takes responsibility for the mislynch, but on the other hand tries to act townleadery. I can def see both town and maf writing this though
The thing that confuses me the most is Kirby/Mog, as I see both with the potential to be scum, yet not compatible with eachother. With the exception of the FN1 vote yesterday, I honestly don't see anything town-indictative. There was the confusion over mis-coloring her reads with inconsistencies. But many of her posts have little value as well. At the same time though, I don't really like Kirby piggybacking off Kermit's Mog suspicion, and he honestly feels a bit off.
First pool I'm heavily leaning towards Kit because if you go through her post filter everything is pure jibberish and nothing of content fmpov, and with the least posts in the game so far, I guess you could say she's somewhat coasting as well. I can't really tell if she's just bad town at this point especially with her claiming townie for no reason, like you've played at least 10 games by now I'm pretty sure you should know that claiming townie will only give town power roles away so idk what the hell you were thinking when you decided to claim.
I'm going to ignore Dad for now, I feel like I'm sort of stuck in a tunneling mentality myself when it comes to him, though I do feel like Evan's crack is town-indicative Townlock
Bianca
Byngo
Kermit
Townlean(In Order except Dan)
FN1
Zendel
Dan (Yeah, he's not town, but for now I'm inclined to believe his claim, because it also could make sense with Kat changing the scum condition)
Heyden
Evan
Toadsworthy
I've added my reads recently. Going to expand on my leans and alignments once there's a flip, but if I'm not around to do so I still suggest a Dolby lynch especially if it's a blue snipe situation because out of everyone here he's the one who has a gift for guessing blues right. Didn't like my short exchange with Kit recently tbh so eyes on them for a lynch as well. Keep your eyes on Kirby too, I'm still not convinced.
reads 2.0
I have some changes after my last reads. I know my last reads had a lot of nulls but I hope this one has less.
Bianca- townlean, tone still feels calm, and I like how she is trying to be helpful and sharing your thoughts.
Dolby- townlean, feel like you're playing like your usual when you're town. And I think you're town out of the Dolby VS Dad interactions.
Amazon- townlean, after Ness flip Jester I'm leaning you back at town, I felt like scum was in that Ness VS Amazon interactions. And seeing that ness flip jester, I think he knew you were town but he was doing this to try and get himself lynched.
Dan- TP, I think we have 2 TP's in this game looking at Kat's last game the cult one that game had 2 Tp's but it was somewhat larger.
Mog- scumlean, at the beginning I felt like she was coasting along until someone wanted her reads than she posted them, didn't really like how she posted them after she was called out. Her reads did feel normal to me except you changed some of the player names. I would like to know why people think her reads are weird.
FireNinja- townlock, after Ness flips I don't think we have 2 jesters. I understand why you claimed jester but didn't like so much talking about having 2 jesters.
Oliver- townlean, looking back at your posts I feel like you're playing newbie town still didn't like how you tried to derail the thread but maybe I'm just looking at it too much.
Kit- scumlean, I feel like you're coasting and posts are just fillers imo cause most of them talk about how you're trying to catch up and you're kinda sheeping as well.
Byngo- townlean, feels like you're playing like your town self in SU mafia.
F11- null, still can't read you except you seem to just pop in at a random time.
Heyden- townlean, you don't seem as pushy as last game I played with you, I think it was smash mafia. But might need to look at your other games you were mafia.
Dad- scumlean, I still think you're scum in that Dolby Vs Dad interactions and most of your posts only talk about people you scumlean. Thanks for making a reads list with all the players on it.
Toads and Zendel- null, one thing I saw about Zendel was he was very active on first half of day1 but less active after first half of day1. You're usually active so just taking a note of your Activity Zendel
Kermittea- townlean, in smash mafia I did see you make very long posts, I don't see this in this game or the last one. So I think you're town.
I'm very sure scum is in that list I scumlean.
Most scum to least scum in my scumleans.
Dad, Mog, and Kit. Mog and kit are equal in sus for me.
Also, just want to say to Zendel that I was legitimately annoyed by both Cleb in Smash and Ness now, and I would be regardless of my alignment in either game.
Probtown {Zendel (need to read filter on this but from what I've seen I'm pretty certain he's town), Heyden, mogyay, Dolby (based off of first third of his filter)}
Nulltown: {Byngo, Dad}
Null: {Toads, Kermit}
D2 Lynchblock: {f11, Kit, Kirby}
If your name is not on the list it means that I haven't read your filter yet and therefore haven't drawn anything conclusive about you.
- - - Post Merge - - -
mog should be in nulltown not probtown, just a minor correction
kirby you're clearly just re-doing your reads cause u got called out for having too many nulls, it seems so sus tbh, if u had nulls u had nulls, it seems like ur forcing an opinion now to look better. also nobody asked for reads from me, they called out low activty which ive explained (the game started at 1am my time and i had a full day of work the next day) so i disagree with the activity discussion anyway. also dolby already explained why he thought my reads were weird
