Oh yes, we need the rude villagers back! At least make the cranky and snooty villagers rude again. To
be honest, I don't like how friendly and kind the villagers are in New Leaf, it feels like for me sometimes
that they are BFFs with you after you just talk with them once. Back then, it took some time till you
start to become friends with them. I really prefer how they acted back in the older games and also
hope that they improve the personalities.
Totally agreeing with you! I love NL, but that is one of my main complaints about the game. Everyone is just so nice to a point that the personalities feel a bit watered down, and that + the fact that everyone seems to like my player character right from the start makes it a little... well... boring to talk to some of them.
Though I think the whole friendship building aspect was never too fleshed out in Animal Crossing to begin with...
I'd love for them to work on that aspect and make building up a friendship with a villager more of a little quest or challenge.
It doesn't have to be / shouldn't be a super
huge, frustrating struggle or anything, but I at least want the snooty and grumpy ones to be a bit suspicious/dismissive of me as a newbie for a little while. Then it'd be all the more rewarding once they warm up to you!
At the very least they need to give them more interesting dialogue. I remember the Gamecube AC villagers could be really mean sometimes - but in a funny way. In any case, having everyone want to be your best bud for life right off the bat can get boring. I'm sure they could find a way to make it more interesting without making it unenjoyable for younger players or players who just want to relax and have everyone be nice. ^^
And as weird as it sounds, I actually... like disliking some of my villagers. I had this peppy hippo in my GC town and she said the sassiest/meanest stuff to me sometimes. I had this weird love-hate-friendship with her, and while she definitely wasn't my favourite villager and I would often joke about wanting her to move out, she's also the first one that comes to mind when I think about the villagers I had on the GC. I'm actually kind of sad that she has not made it into the newer games.