A new player centric game has never really worked here. We gave coaches who either helped to much or didn't help enough, followed by players who were too meek or worried to post cases leading to massive inactive games where a few players stood out, but only because of contribution or because their coach helped them a lot.
That said we could try another one comprised of mostly new players, basic roles, and maybe some mediocre players like Cory Oath2order join in. That said mafia on TBT is in need of an overhaul or something.
How does everyone feel about "super-micro" games?
Literally 4 Town vs. 1 Mafia and see how that goes?
That means a Day 2 Lynch-or-Lose as a worse-case scenario, yes, I get that.
While it doesn't bring players in, it improves the current ones--addressed below.
More simplicity, like in the first three games, should be played at least a few times as a Nub Mafia. I also feel like TBT Mafia nowadays has become somewhat ability-centered in that there are...
1.) maybe three people who are actually attempting to look for scum in each game and every townie rides on their backs
and then the reason I refer to it as being "ability-centered:"
2.) Most people who have an ability seem to be relying heavily on this ability to do their scumhunting for them, instead of playing the game the way it was made to be played as and actively getting involved. I know I'm guilty of this myself. I know many others are.
Now, a lot of the original Mafia community has dispersed, and that is saddening:
Lauren - Townie - gone
Justin Townie (Killed Night 3) - hasn't played
Gandalf - Townie - hasn't played/gone
lynn105 Suicide Bomber (Lynched Day 5) - get your ass over here son ily
kurolli Townie (Modkilled Day 2) - idek
FireNinja1 Mafia Underling (Lynched Day 7) - gone
iLoveYou Vigilante (Modkilled Night 1) - gone
MyLifeIsCake - Townie - gone
Mary Mafia Underling (Lynched Day 2) - gone
Thunder Townie (Killed Night 2) - hasn't played
tsundere Townie (Killed Night 1) - justice
Hikari Detective (Killed Night 6) - gone
oath2order Townie (Killed Night 5) - still does
FoxWolf64 Townie (Lynched Day 3) - gone
TheCreeperHugz - Doctor - gone
BellBringerGreen Veteran (Killed Night 3) - hasn't played
River Mafia Underling (Lynched Day 4) - gone
Prof Gallows - Mafia Rolebocker - hasn't played
VillageDweller Vigilante (Killed Night 1) - hasn't played
Kuma Townie (Modkilled Day 4) - gone
DeviousCrossing Townie (Modkilled Day 4) - gone
ACE Doctor (Lynched Day 1) - riley now, gone anyways
3DSfan134 Townie (Lynched Day 6) - gone
AndyB - Townie - gone
pallycake Townie (Modkilled Day 6) - gone
SuperPenguin Vigilante (Killed Night 5) - in and out
LaurinaMN Miller (Killed Night 1) - haven't seen her for a while, likely gone
BlueLeaf Townie (Modkilled Day 5) - haven't seen
Farobi - hasn't played
Horus Miller (Killed Night 4) - hasn't played
Dolby Townie (Lynched Day 1) - hey dolby still drive the bus?
Trundle Bodyguard
bluegoat14 Mafia Roleblocker - she's a friend, can't remember but her real name is beth
Tom Townie (Killed Night 3) - heya
Kippla Townie (Killed Night 1) - haven't seen in a while
Blu Rose - scrub alert
BowserFanGurl1999 - hasn't played
Tina - semi-active mafia-wise
Kerryelizabeth - hasn't played
Pikasweet - hasn't played
SlaughterShy - hasn't played
Klinkguin - hasn't played
Chris. - gone
KarlaKGB - hasn't played
lynnie ffs u stole my line i even had it typed when u said that
Basically, what I believe we need to do is make Mafia more fun and spread the word instead of being the social recluses we are about it. Mafia was like a bunch of people that gathered for a cult meeting when I first joined, but now like 6 of those people still play and we're not being too open about spreading it to others.
I can host a Nub Mafia if we get enough interest.
How does everyone feel about "super-micro" games?
Literally 4 Town vs. 1 Mafia and see how that goes?
That means a Day 2 Lynch-or-Lose as a worse-case scenario, yes, I get that.
While it doesn't bring players in, it improves the current ones--addressed below.
More simplicity, like in the first three games, should be played at least a few times as a Nub Mafia. I also feel like TBT Mafia nowadays has become somewhat ability-centered in that there are...
1.) maybe three people who are actually attempting to look for scum in each game and every townie rides on their backs
and then the reason I refer to it as being "ability-centered:"
2.) Most people who have an ability seem to be relying heavily on this ability to do their scumhunting for them, instead of playing the game the way it was made to be played as and actively getting involved. I know I'm guilty of this myself. I know many others are.
Now, a lot of the original Mafia community has dispersed, and that is saddening:
Lauren - Townie - gone
Justin Townie (Killed Night 3) - hasn't played
Gandalf - Townie - hasn't played/gone
lynn105 Suicide Bomber (Lynched Day 5) - get your ass over here son ily
kurolli Townie (Modkilled Day 2) - idek
FireNinja1 Mafia Underling (Lynched Day 7) - gone
iLoveYou Vigilante (Modkilled Night 1) - gone
MyLifeIsCake - Townie - gone
Mary Mafia Underling (Lynched Day 2) - gone
Thunder Townie (Killed Night 2) - hasn't played
tsundere Townie (Killed Night 1) - justice
Hikari Detective (Killed Night 6) - gone
oath2order Townie (Killed Night 5) - still does
FoxWolf64 Townie (Lynched Day 3) - gone
TheCreeperHugz - Doctor - gone
BellBringerGreen Veteran (Killed Night 3) - hasn't played
River Mafia Underling (Lynched Day 4) - gone
Prof Gallows - Mafia Rolebocker - hasn't played
VillageDweller Vigilante (Killed Night 1) - hasn't played
Kuma Townie (Modkilled Day 4) - gone
DeviousCrossing Townie (Modkilled Day 4) - gone
ACE Doctor (Lynched Day 1) - riley now, gone anyways
3DSfan134 Townie (Lynched Day 6) - gone
AndyB - Townie - gone
pallycake Townie (Modkilled Day 6) - gone
SuperPenguin Vigilante (Killed Night 5) - in and out
LaurinaMN Miller (Killed Night 1) - haven't seen her for a while, likely gone
BlueLeaf Townie (Modkilled Day 5) - haven't seen
Farobi - hasn't played
Horus Miller (Killed Night 4) - hasn't played
Dolby Townie (Lynched Day 1) - hey dolby still drive the bus?
Trundle Bodyguard
bluegoat14 Mafia Roleblocker - she's a friend, can't remember but her real name is beth
Tom Townie (Killed Night 3) - heya
Kippla Townie (Killed Night 1) - haven't seen in a while
Blu Rose - scrub alert
BowserFanGurl1999 - hasn't played
Tina - semi-active mafia-wise
Kerryelizabeth - hasn't played
Pikasweet - hasn't played
SlaughterShy - hasn't played
Klinkguin - hasn't played
Chris. - gone
KarlaKGB - hasn't played
lynnie ffs u stole my line i even had it typed when u said that
Basically, what I believe we need to do is make Mafia more fun and spread the word instead of being the social recluses we are about it. Mafia was like a bunch of people that gathered for a cult meeting when I first joined, but now like 6 of those people still play and we're not being too open about spreading it to others.
I can host a Nub Mafia if we get enough interest.
Yes this is what i've been trying to do. In my Smash game i invited a ton of new people to play, but in the end some of them were "innactive". However players like Monkeyd99 and Lucanosa did pretty good though.
Yes this is what i've been trying to do. In my Smash game i invited a ton of new people to play, but in the end some of them were "innactive". However players like Monkeyd99 and Lucanosa did pretty good though.