Rank the Personalities

Here are my current villager personality rankings:

1. Cranky
2. Uchi
3. Smug
4. Snooty
5. Lazy
6. Normal
7. Jock
8. Peppy
 
Current ranking at the moment:
1. Cranky!!!
2. Lazy
3. Normal
4. Smug
5. Snooty
6. Uchi
7. Peppy
8. Jock
 
1. Snooty - There always seems to be a snooty in my town that I get really attached to. I love getting to know them and having them warm up to me, and their sass in the older games like WW is great. Even though I hate how they're not as snooty or rude in NL as they used to be, they still have some funny dialogue.
2. Lazy - They're so friendly and relaxed, and I always enjoy talking to them.
3. Jock - I like how energetic and friendly they are. Even though I don't care about all the muscle and sports talk, there always seems to be one of these that I end up loving in my towns, too.
4. Peppy - This was a really tough choice between peppy and normal. I love the energy of the peppy villagers, but in NL they took the whole pop-star thing way too far to the point where they all seemed completely deluded that they were a famous celebrity, which got aggravating fast. But they have a lot of good and memorable dialogue, so that's why they're here.
5. Normal - I like how nice they are, and normal is definitely the personality I'm most like, but they tend to seem pretty bland. They have their heartwarming moments, but I would not want to have more than one of them in a town.
6. Uchi - They're okay. I think part of the reason they're so low is because I haven't had many of them in comparison to the other personalities. They just don't really stick out to me.
7. Cranky - This was my least favourite personality type for a while because almost all of them are so darn ugly and I just wasn't a fan of the personality, but I do like how they warm up to you and have some sweet dialogue and letters. That being said, a lot of my least favourite villagers are cranky, more than any other type.
8. Smug - The only smug I really like is Marshal, although I've also started to take a liking to a few others a bit recently. But for the most part, smugs come across as conceited as the snooties, maybe even more so, without any of the redeeming sassiness, entertaining dialogue, or deep relationship building. I just find them obnoxious. (But not Marshal, I'll always love him.)
 
Last edited:
1- uchi, i love all these gals. big sis energy
2- normal, theyre all so sweet & cute
3- cranky, theyre funny & act like a dad to my character
4- lazy, love these silly boyes
5- smug, funny & flirty- what's not to love?
6- peppy, excitable and usually cute
7- snooty, can be cool, were better in the older games but now they lack sass
8- jock, cool guys but just not my fav
 
This is kind of hard. I know which personality is my favorite and my least favorite, but the others in the middle are harder to define. I'm going to try anyway.

1. Cranky - They have always been my favorite. I wish they were still as cranky as the old days, but I still love them.
2. Smug - This was a toss up between Lazy and Smug, but I've really enjoyed the Smug villagers in my town.
3. Lazy - Just barely beaten out by Smug.
4. Uchi - They seem to have the most personality out of the New Leaf villagers, but the individuals have been hit or miss for me.
5. Peppy - I've had a couple of Peppy villagers that I've really loved, but overall they're too energetic for me.
6. Normal - They are really sweet and cute, but having more than one in a town, their dialog can get bland really fast.
7. Snooty - I love, love, love Mint, but I don't think I want more than one Snooty villager in a town. Now that they aren't as sarcastic, their dialog gets too repetitive.
8. Jock - I still really like Jocks, but in addition to being too energetic sometimes, their dialog also gets repetitive for me.
 
This is my ranking:

1. Cranky
2. Uchi
3. Lazy
4. Smug
5. Peppy
6. Normal
7. Snooty
8. Jock

I do like Cranky villagers the most because of their behavior and the way they act. Although it's a shame that their personality got watered down so much in New Leaf, I liked it way more back then in the previous games when they were so rude to you. Uchi villagers are quite funny, same goes for lazy villagers. Smug, Peppy and Normal are overall okay. The snooty villagers became kinda annoying to me over time, however
just like with the cranky villagers, I hate it that their personality got watered down too in NL. Jock is to be honest my least favorite personality. While I do like some of the villagers which have that personality, I don't like their dialogue that much and over all jock is kinda boring.
 
Last edited:
In terms of looks:
1. Normal
2. Lazy
3. Peppy
4.Snooty
5.Cranky
6.Jock
7.Uchi
8.Smug (exception: Marshal)

In terms of Dialogue:
1.Cranky
2.Snooty
3.Jock
4.Smug
5.Lazy
6.Uchi
7.Peppy
8.Normal
 
Tough question since I enjoy so many of them!

#1 Cranky
#2 Smug (Honestly these first two are interchangeable. Both are absolutely fantastic and full of incredible villagers.)
#3 Snooty
#4 Jock
#5 Lazy (Not my favorite, but my town seems to attract them bahaha).
#6 Peppy
#7 Normal
#8 Uchi (not a fan of almost any of the villagers in this one)
 
1) Snooty: It was a tough decision between Snooty and Smug for the #1 spot, but Snooty just has so many great designs and it's my favorite female personality type in the game. Ankha, Freya, Monique, Olivia, Pecan, Tiffany, and so many more great villagers.

2) Smug: Very close second. I really love their mature demeanor and they have some of my favorite designs among them as well, with the likes of Beardo, Hans, Eugene, Jacques, Julian, Pietro, and again many more.

3) Jock: Cranky and Jock are pretty even, they're both strong personalities with a bunch of designs I like. This placement is pretty arbitrary, they could easily trade spots for the most part, but what cinches the third place spot for Jock is having both Ribbot and Sprocket. Boone, Bud, Cobb, Drift, Mott, and Sterling are quite good as well.

4) Cranky: See the description for the Jocks, only reason it's ranked fourth is because of my love for the robots. Boris, Camofrog, Hopper, Knox, Lobo, Octavian, Rasher? Really great.

5) Peppy: Peppy seems like a solid #5 spot despite the other personalities being more fluid in their placements. Good personality, a number of designs I really like despite there also being a great many I'm totally disinterested in. Agent S, Anabelle, Bella, Cheri, Flora, Piper, Ruby, Sprinkle, Tammi, and Victoria are all good, but I'm very much not interested in any of the rest of them.

6) Uchi: Uchi and Lazy are interchangeable a bit. I like the Uchi personality more than the Lazy personality, but there are fewer Uchi villagers that are among my favorites than Lazy villagers. Uchi ranks higher because I find the personality more tolerable. Agnes, Cherry, Deirdre, Diva, Pashmina, Phoebe, and a few others are good.

7) Lazy: I have a bunch of favorites who are Lazies, but I'm not really a fan of the childlike behavior of the personality itself. Particularly fond of Boomer, Drago, Lucky, Marcel, Raddle, Stitches, and Tucker.

8) Normal: That name really captures the essence of these villagers. Just normal. I have favorites among them too of course, but they're the most forgettable in terms of personality. Gotta love Annalisa, Coco, Maple, Melba, Midge, Pekoe, and Savannah though.
 
1: Normal (I love a lot of normal villager and I love how genuinely sweet they are!)
2: Snooty (I like how they're just so wicked... but with time they become so adorable! (for the most part...))
3: Peppy (Love how energetic the peppy personnality villagers are! they're so cute and actually funny to me!)
4: Cranky (I always adored cranky villagers, they're so sweet and kind souls under this big coat of "meanness")
5: Lazy (They're just funny to me because I actually relate to them a bit too much I guess.)
6: Uchi (They're very nice but I don't really like the way they talk. But I love how kind they are though!)
7: Smug (They're okay to me but just not my favorite!)
8: Jock (I HATE jocks. There's waaaaay too many jock villagers I hate, heck, I don't even know if there's one I like, or at least do not despise. I hate them in real life, so no thanks)
 
# 1 Lazy
#2 Cranky kindred spirits
#3 Uchi
#5 Normal
#6 Peppy
#7 Smug
#8 Snooty

I dunno, I just don't like the snooty villagers. I'm a crybaby and they go for the throat. D:
 
going off new leaf dialogue only it'd be...

1. Smug/Peppy
2. Snooty
3. Uchi
4. Normal
5. Lazy
6. Jock
7. Cranky

if you asked me a year ago i would say my favorite is absolutely uncontested-ly smug, i might've even put snooty ABOVE peppy, but lately peppy's really grown on me! they're so goofy.
i would like cranky more if they were actually cranky... i want villagers with more attitude again!!!
 
as an overall (based on looks/dialogue/etc) ranking:

1. Snooty
2. Normal
3. Peppy
4. Uchi
5. Lazy
6. Cranky
7. Jock
 
I'd put Cranky and Uchi at the top.

Lazy and Peppy at the very bottom (Peppies give me a bleedin' migraine).

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'd put Cranky and Uchi at the top.

Lazy and Peppy at the very bottom (Peppies give me a bleedin' migraine).
 
Uchi- Love their friendliness and energy, as well as their PWPs
Cranky- Great PWPs
Snooty- Fav Villager is Snooty (Willow)
Lazy
Smug
Peppy
Jock/Normal- Just aren't a huge fan of thwm
 
-peppy (so fun)
-uchi (cool)
-smug (cool)
-snooty/lazy (some likeness)
-normal ( a bit boring)
-cranky (meh)
-jock (the worst but I do like kody and he is a jock)
 
Back
Top