i love the pups! there isn't a single dog villager that i don't like
winnie and fang are awesome as well
i've never seen tucker in game before so i don't have an opinion on him
rod's a goof and i had him in wild world, i enjoyed him
vic and rhonda are ok i have very little exposure to them
flo is the only one on your list that i would say i DON'T like
I have:
Portia
Goldie
Shep
Cherry (all 4 dogs moved in on their own!)
Ricky
Wendy
Mira
Mathilda
Alfonso
^^^
You're so lucky to have Freya! I want a pink wolf c: I think you have a pretty good list of villagers.
I have
Marcel: He's a cute little lazy dog, but I'm trying to get him to move because he's screwing up my path.
Diana: I LOVE her design
Carmen: Very cute but I want her out
Felicity: Very cute but I also want her gone. Too many peppy animals in my village
Zell: I also love Zell. I think he's super adorable since I'm deer biased c:
Wendy: She's very cute
Diva: She's so ugly I want her to leave pretty badly. I haven't talked to her since she moved in c:
I had Cherry but I decided to kick her out.
Cinnamint, you have such lovely villagers! Zell especially!
I have:
Willow
Lucy
Hamphrey
Kabuki
Carmen
Egbert
Rodney
Katt
Chester (moving)
and Shari.
I've had Mac as well, but he moved away!
Carmen: It's okay
Melba: It's okay I guess
Tammy: Cool
Zell: It's not my type but ok
Wolfgang: Now i'm jealous
Diana: I'm more jealous!
Kevin: Still jealous! Kevin is awesome!
Poncho: Ok.
Groucho: Duh.
I have Egbert, Rowan, Peanut, Apollo, Rhonda, Canberra, Lionel (yes I TT'd for Canberra)
LOVE: Bangle
LIKE: Stinky, Astrid
The rest are ok
Adding Vesta to the list since shes also moving in, in a few days
Apple
Mitzi
Stinky
Willow
Rolf
Lopez (Moves in Tomorrow)
Vesta (Moves in after Lopez)
LOVE: Mitzi, Rolf, Apple
Like: Stinky, Lopez, Vesta
Meh: Willow
My Villagers
Drift
Cyrano
Fauna (MY FAV)
Deli
Bunnie (My 2nd fav)