Mafia Reindeer Mafia! - WE'RE DONE GUYS - YETI WIN
- Thread starter Kit
- Start date
yeah he did but he didnt say he was Rudolph lol
You did make a good point that we shouldn't let him reach majority though, currently he's one vote away. Let's actually use the extra time to talk about suspicions (unlike the extra 24 hours of the Tom lynch). Unless you all think it'll just be a big waste of time
After Ashtot, Jacob is my top scum read
Jacob's posts that matter
Support for Call me Daniel. Supporting Ashtot in saying that people are jumping on him.
So, Tom isn't scum either, just like CMD. I'm scummy because I have good reads and called Tom out. Did you even read my post explaining the most likely reasons why Trojan and Ender were killed instead of other people?
Having good reads means I'm 100% scum, yet, it doesn't fall under suspicious activity. You can't really back up your suspicions.
Jacob seems genuinely scummy to me guys. They considered CMD to be town and didn't vote for Tom until it was evident that he was going to be lynched no matter what. Hypocritical on the idea of suspicious activity. Considered Starry scum for pushing that they were scum and stating the potential irony.
And there's this as well
Gonna do an iso on Jellofish and maybe StarryWolf also.
To Starry, dinger, and sarnone. Please speak up, we have very little content from any of you
Jacob's posts that matter
Seems reasonable enough. Talking about the day one, Blu Rose fake wagon.
I find this a bit suspicious. Talking about StarryWolf saying that they aren't wolf. I kind of find the difference between his response to Ness's "case" against Blu and Starry pushing that their town interesting
More of the same
Voted for Starry with about 30 hours left in the day, literally four hours after saying that "it's still early"
Support for Call me Daniel. Supporting Ashtot in saying that people are jumping on him.
So, Tom isn't scum either, just like CMD. I'm scummy because I have good reads and called Tom out. Did you even read my post explaining the most likely reasons why Trojan and Ender were killed instead of other people?
Having good reads means I'm 100% scum, yet, it doesn't fall under suspicious activity. You can't really back up your suspicions.
Jacob seems genuinely scummy to me guys. They considered CMD to be town and didn't vote for Tom until it was evident that he was going to be lynched no matter what. Hypocritical on the idea of suspicious activity. Considered Starry scum for pushing that they were scum and stating the potential irony.
And there's this as well
Gonna do an iso on Jellofish and maybe StarryWolf also.
To Starry, dinger, and sarnone. Please speak up, we have very little content from any of you
Those were fine reads Dolby, but I am not scum
I can't really prove it per se because I don't think I am allowed to show you the PM
The fact that you believe so strongly that I am scum makes me just a little more suspicious of you, as you are an experienced player.
I assume people who are good at mafia don't usually try to make Town members seem like scum, unless you are mafia yourself.
- - - Post Merge - - -
*continuation*
unless you genuinely read my posts and interperated them the wrong way (which skillful experienced members shouldn't be doing?)
I can't really prove it per se because I don't think I am allowed to show you the PM
The fact that you believe so strongly that I am scum makes me just a little more suspicious of you, as you are an experienced player.
I assume people who are good at mafia don't usually try to make Town members seem like scum, unless you are mafia yourself.
- - - Post Merge - - -
*continuation*
unless you genuinely read my posts and interperated them the wrong way (which skillful experienced members shouldn't be doing?)
I do have a few questions for you to answer
1)Who are your wolf reads and how strongly do you feel about them?
2)Who are your town reads?
3)What do you think of your friends, dinger and Sarnone?
1)Who are your wolf reads and how strongly do you feel about them?
Stonger reads are you and Ashtot, I am more confident in Ashtot than you (but I have never played a real game with either of you before so I am not sure of your usual playing habits)
2)Who are your town reads?
Just Dinger and Jello now
Everyone else I have 0 reads on, their posts keep changing my mind
3)What do you think of your friends, dinger and Sarnone?
I know Sarnone reads because he lurks a lot, but I am not sure why he doesn't post
Dinger started to read and reply more the past couple days I think
Overall they could post way more, but I think their playing styles are just quiet (i guess its working cuz no one knows either of their roles)
Maybe they have been sending actions if they had them. if they had an important role and didn't participate, wouldn't Kit or Trundle just mod kill/replace them?
Stonger reads are you and Ashtot, I am more confident in Ashtot than you (but I have never played a real game with either of you before so I am not sure of your usual playing habits)
2)Who are your town reads?
Just Dinger and Jello now
Everyone else I have 0 reads on, their posts keep changing my mind
3)What do you think of your friends, dinger and Sarnone?
I know Sarnone reads because he lurks a lot, but I am not sure why he doesn't post
Dinger started to read and reply more the past couple days I think
Overall they could post way more, but I think their playing styles are just quiet (i guess its working cuz no one knows either of their roles)
Maybe they have been sending actions if they had them. if they had an important role and didn't participate, wouldn't Kit or Trundle just mod kill/replace them?
You know, you're not confirmed as Town though. We can't go out on a limb and take your insistance that you're townie.
Dolby has potential for being Wolf, But Ashtot's flip would say otherwise about him. Logically with your posts(atleast after Ashtot flips) it will point to you or StarryWolf being mafia.
I personally believe Jacob to be Town at the moment.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I also just realized: If Ashtot was an Unlynchable, then Dolby would have backed off of him by now. If Ashtot couldn't be lynched today and Dolby was wolf, then logically Dolby would burn in flames the next day.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Hold on folks, did you see that? Jacob just Town slipped!
The entire list of Blue Roles were leaked out during Day 2 by Blu Rose, and him saying he doesn't trust any confirmed people somewhat makes Jacob town.
Why do you think that jello is town?
- - - Post Merge - - -
Ok, so Jacob's confirmed town now since if he was mafia, he would've known who the confirmed people were since Tom (mafia) saw the list