Mafia Resident Evil Mafia - Game Thread [Endgame- Mafia Wins]

[BetsySundrop]

Well crap. I have thought myself into a never ending darn circle.

 

[Antonio]

and it seems like ghost isn't reading much of posts and information and it feels like he's trying to get by because he already knows who's town. (like, there's literally a whole page of filler fuelled by ghost ._.)

Exactly this, plus as I said he's just stating his thoughts and not actually exactly explaining why. It's like being productive without being productive.

Post automatically merged: Oct 11, 2021

Well crap. I have thought myself into a never ending darn circle.

can you elaborate on this circle?

 

[Damniel]

was misty the only player people were considering eliminating? its a rather boring EoD even if we have an AFK and a last minute sub-in

 

[Antonio]

was misty the only player people were considering eliminating? its a rather boring EoD even if we have an AFK and a last minute sub-in

Seems like the only votes atm is no vote and misty.

 

[BetsySundrop]

i haven't read so i dont know the reasoning behind the votes beyond geoni being sus and blooming agreeing. but also im not misty so i can't expiation her actions. i also dont have much free time tonight so im going to catch up tomorrow

Couple things on this.
1- you mean IF you're here tomorrow, as you've got the most votes as of now.
2- coming in like this strikes me as a bit of a town lean. If maf, you would have had a teammate and an easy way to catch up, so likely would have come in with "all caught up, I sus x"...
3- #2 could be by design, =sus
4- a town lean- if maf with inactive teammate, no way to catch up, would you really just give up with 2 votes on you?

 

[Damniel]

@Ghost2008 are you even trying to do anything the other players urged you to do? (iso, explain your reasoning, etc) if you're only posting because your sister is poking you, that's so suspicious!

Exactly this, plus as I said he's just stating his thoughts and not actually exactly explaining why. It's like being productive without being productive.

i see you guys are discussing and questioning ghost. do you not sus read them? from your votes for no-elim, i would think you guys didn't have any firm susses yet

 

[BetsySundrop]

was misty the only player people were considering eliminating? its a rather boring EoD even if we have an AFK and a last minute sub-in

I was considering volt/antonio earlier for sus reasons. Both have posted more townish since, but not 100% convinced.

I did consider ghost at one point because even tho I dont really think he's maf, he is not a helpful town.

If going by ghosts one and only sus, then geoni to be considered. I cannot tell town geoni from maf geoni, so have no idea on that.

I did not have misty on my vote list. Might make me dumb, as geoni made some good points, and I don't have the best track record with my sus.

 

[Geoni]

I will try and keep up here at work this last hour but as it stands I am keeping my vote on the Misty slot in spite of Dan subbing in last minute. My reason for suspecting her didn't have anything to do with her activity level anyways.

if b100 needs any more reasoning to be town i appreciate the fight back against a LHF elim
also antonio u seem different this game. i never played a game with u where u were mafia. maybe it's the avi and sig or maybe it's time to tinfoil you

Post automatically merged: Oct 11, 2021

@Geoni do u think antonio could be in their wolfrange

I'm going to look more for Antonio's townrange than wolfrange, he's not really out of either yet. Why he wants to no elim here is beyond me even if I have seen him do that before. Not really there yet I. Confidence yeeting him day 1 though I didn't like his RQS there was a cautionlessness about it that I have seen him do as town, not sure I wanna call it AI.

There's been too little discussion on roles and mechanics and not enough interaction about each other's reads.

 

[b100ming]

If maf, you would have had a teammate and an easy way to catch up, so likely would have come in with "all caught up, I sus x"...

That is, if his partner were even online, as most people aren’t online.

 

[Antonio]

i see you guys are discussing and questioning ghost. do you not sus read them? from your votes for no-elim, i would think you guys didn't have any firm susses yet

He's my most sus read atm but his behavior could also fall under the inexperienced town category, which is putting doubt into me actually voting him.

 

[Damniel]

Couple things on this.
1- you mean IF you're here tomorrow, as you've got the most votes as of now.
2- coming in like this strikes me as a bit of a town lean. If maf, you would have had a teammate and an easy way to catch up, so likely would have come in with "all caught up, I sus x"...
3- #2 could be by design, =sus
4- a town lean- if maf with inactive teammate, no way to catch up, would you really just give up with 2 votes on you?

well, its two votes on me with 4 people not voting yet. i can't really engage with geoni and blooming when im not misty and with the limited time i have what can i do? i just hope people will give me the time to clear any doubts on my slot

 

[BetsySundrop]

That is, if his partner were even online, as most people aren’t online.

Yep. Which is why #4. If you rep in as maf, have total inactive partner, would you just think pfft and go with being voted off...I dunno...I hate when I don't have a strong sus to vote for.

Post automatically merged: Oct 11, 2021

Yep. Which is why #4. If you rep in as maf, have total inactive partner, would you just think pfft and go with being voted off...I dunno...I hate when I don't have a strong sus to vote for.

As in, a single strong sus. Not a lot of little susses.

 

[Damniel]

He's my most sus read atm but his behavior could also fall under the inexperienced town category, which is putting doubt into me actually voting him.

from 0-100% how confident are you that he's mafia?

Post automatically merged: Oct 11, 2021

I will try and keep up here at work this last hour but as it stands I am keeping my vote on the Misty slot in spite of Dan subbing in last minute. My reason for suspecting her didn't have anything to do with her activity level anyways.

can't do much about that now can i

 

[Antonio]

from 0-100% how confident are you that he's mafia?

48%

 

[Geoni]

I was hoping to hear from shellbell. I'm still kind of on the fence with some things. I plan on posting reads/my legacy though. Should be no later than 8pm eastern (leaves an hour for discussion? Unless i have my time zones screwy).

Post automatically merged: Oct 11, 2021

Welcome to le game! I'll be off for a bit, back in an hour. Interested to hear your perspective on everything so far.

What are you otf about?

 

[BetsySundrop]

y'all are saying he's different from when he was mafia but he just seems weird to me. wasn't he eliminated early? how's he different?

Yes, he was eliminated d1. He accidentally outed himself and was inactive/ had weird posts. The difference is not a lot, but it's there (barely). He could still be maf. But I think town or maf he would still have few/odd posts.

And he has been given plenty of advice/time to come in with something. So yes, it's frustrating.

Post automatically merged: Oct 11, 2021

What are you otf about?

Otf about
- who to vote
- have my susses cleared themselves or no?
- is (what i see as) unhelpful town ok to keep around just because they may be town, or better to elim to have more chance success d2 even if town
- am I wrong about everything
- none of my susses appear to be consistent with possible maf teams
- are my townreads actually the opposite (wouldn't be the first time)
....etc.

 

[b100ming]

Um can someone explain otf?

 

[Antonio]

Um can someone explain otf?

on the fence

 

[Damniel]

has volt been active this game? i imagine potter isn't coming anytime soon

 

[BetsySundrop]

can you elaborate on this circle?

Yup. It's WIFOM that has me overthinking and complicating everything. I like to at least feel sure (ish) if I vote someone, or at least have good reasons.

Thinking of voting the inactive potter as last resort if I cant make up my mind. At least its a known mia that likely wont improve....