BetsySundrop
🧙♀️ 🧹
Nooo...y'all....c'mon now.
Mafia Resident Evil Mafia - Game Thread [Endgame- Mafia Wins]
- Thread starter N e s s
- Start date
- Status
Nooo...y'all....c'mon now.
Vote Count 1.1
Geoni [2]: BetsySundrop, b100ming
BetsySundrop [1]: voltairenism
Not Voting [6]: @Ghost2008 @Antonio @Miss Misty @shellbell @Geoni @pottercrossing
Currently with [2] votes, Geoni is set to be eliminated.
Day 1 will end on October 11th at 8:00 PM CDT. You have exactly 24 hours to select someone to eliminate.
BetsySundrop
🧙♀️ 🧹
Welp. I'm not voting b100ming unless there is a miraculous counterclaim. Want to yeet an actual maf. Right now my obvious town is b100ming, my likely town is miss misty. My leaning town is shellbell.
That leaves: ghost- null, volt- not sure yet, antonio- leaning sus, pottercrossing- mia, geoni- not sure yet.
That leaves: ghost- null, volt- not sure yet, antonio- leaning sus, pottercrossing- mia, geoni- not sure yet.
don't get on b100ming so much guys, i feel like this claim is actually really good for us. we gained a lot of information and we have 1 less suspect.
mafia already knew what column they're in and it doesn't even give them that much more information
mafia already knew what column they're in and it doesn't even give them that much more information
BetsySundrop
🧙♀️ 🧹
True. And it is why I've got b100ming on obvious town now (barring counterclaims lol), so 1 less chance of voting for town- so that is helpful.
The sniffles were because b100ming may be the likely nk now, also losing a town pr.
(Also, in the rules it mentioned not putting out specific phrasing from role pm, and I was worried about the posts going further, a potential modkill. No experience with that, but was worried because I have no idea what would be too much. Although, I guess it doesn't matter after role claim? I just don't know enough...
)
Geoni
You're doing great!
B100 - town until someone CCs that which is just not happening
Shellbell, Betsy, and Antonio are in that range of null that feels relatively "They're here reacting to what is going on in a way that feels like they are figuring things out/just getting a feel in general" it's nothing that really goes super far for me but it's literally all I have so far.
Ghost is just there. I am curious to see how he begins to act later on in the day. I think he's lost regardless of what alignment he is right now because he didn't exactly have a lot of time to experience being a wolf last go around. We have an unCC'd claim who knows him better than all of us speaking of which I think you mentioned you feel your brother is acting a bit off @b100ming
Volt I think could probably just be in that grouping with the other three but it took me longer to remember they were here is all. Pretty null but lemme reread. Was Koopa your replacement in your last game Volt or was he Sheep's?
Miss Misty seems kinda off and that's not OMGUS from me, it's more that I have found her reaction to naming two mafia to come from a more questionable place because it felt very 'look at me I am earnestly looking for wolves and here are some nice and shallow reasons for me to drop these names' if anything. And her entry to the game felt tonally off in a way that's hard to explain.
Potter guy just ain't here yet.
1) He/him
2) To play and help Ness fill his requirement and get the whole D1 Geoni distrust miselimination experience out of the way lol
3) Just shared some.
4) Vanilla Town
5) Vanilla Town
6) I still like his OG one the best. The pic of Ness the character, but this one is nice though I don't know what it is from?
Fwiw I also like Betsy's off the cuff reaction to the b100 claim situation.
This is silly, but honestly it's not at all, but I 100% buy b100's claim not just because it would have been so silly to do as a wolf but because she finally has leverage to not be a day 1 yeet yet again lol
What's giving you your townreads on Misty and shellbell? Shellbell feels alright so far but I would like to see if you notice the same behavior I do. As for Misty, I have given my own reasons why I am already pinged but I am curious in what you like so far.
I was correct in that Volt did rand wolf last time before subbing out and I played with them all game last time they were town so I have some very recent meta at least.
Antonio I know what to wait for if he's town but I will just say I am still waiting for it. It's still early to be fair. I think it's not all pointless discussion at this point now, @Antonio what do you think about some of the reasons that have been handed out for people's townreads and sus reads?
Shellbell, Betsy, and Antonio are in that range of null that feels relatively "They're here reacting to what is going on in a way that feels like they are figuring things out/just getting a feel in general" it's nothing that really goes super far for me but it's literally all I have so far.
Ghost is just there. I am curious to see how he begins to act later on in the day. I think he's lost regardless of what alignment he is right now because he didn't exactly have a lot of time to experience being a wolf last go around. We have an unCC'd claim who knows him better than all of us speaking of which I think you mentioned you feel your brother is acting a bit off @b100ming
Volt I think could probably just be in that grouping with the other three but it took me longer to remember they were here is all. Pretty null but lemme reread. Was Koopa your replacement in your last game Volt or was he Sheep's?
Miss Misty seems kinda off and that's not OMGUS from me, it's more that I have found her reaction to naming two mafia to come from a more questionable place because it felt very 'look at me I am earnestly looking for wolves and here are some nice and shallow reasons for me to drop these names' if anything. And her entry to the game felt tonally off in a way that's hard to explain.
Potter guy just ain't here yet.
Post automatically merged:
1) He/him
2) To play and help Ness fill his requirement and get the whole D1 Geoni distrust miselimination experience out of the way lol
3) Just shared some.
4) Vanilla Town
5) Vanilla Town
6) I still like his OG one the best. The pic of Ness the character, but this one is nice though I don't know what it is from?
Post automatically merged:
Fwiw I also like Betsy's off the cuff reaction to the b100 claim situation.
This is silly, but honestly it's not at all, but I 100% buy b100's claim not just because it would have been so silly to do as a wolf but because she finally has leverage to not be a day 1 yeet yet again lol
Post automatically merged:
What's giving you your townreads on Misty and shellbell? Shellbell feels alright so far but I would like to see if you notice the same behavior I do. As for Misty, I have given my own reasons why I am already pinged but I am curious in what you like so far.
I was correct in that Volt did rand wolf last time before subbing out and I played with them all game last time they were town so I have some very recent meta at least.
Antonio I know what to wait for if he's town but I will just say I am still waiting for it. It's still early to be fair. I think it's not all pointless discussion at this point now, @Antonio what do you think about some of the reasons that have been handed out for people's townreads and sus reads?
Last edited:
BetsySundrop
🧙♀️ 🧹
Last couple thoughts before I turn in for the night.
Koopa was volts replacement a couple games back.
I am not good at finding wolves, but I have misty town lean because of the ( frustrated? ) reaction to the roleclaim. I felt that...
Something that struck me as odd, could be nothin, i dunno. Volt was briefly active, then volt was under light sus, then antonio posted (felt like the result was that it closed the door on volt sus, accidental or not), and volt not real active afterward. I don't know why, but that sequence (could be purely coincidental!) is striking me as strange.
Very last thing- seriously geoni? I took all that time to type out ##VOTE: Geoni (even used capitals), and no reaction? Nothin'? Not even a little gratitude? Well, guess I'll take that back, fold it up, and put it in my pocket for later ....just in case I need it again.
Back tomorrow.
Expanded on this in another post. The more the role was discussed, the more potential for negative consequences (regarding the rule about not including role pm phrasing/poss modkill). Might be paranoia, I have no exp with it, but better safe than sorry.
Koopa was volts replacement a couple games back.
I am not good at finding wolves, but I have misty town lean because of the ( frustrated? ) reaction to the roleclaim. I felt that...
Something that struck me as odd, could be nothin, i dunno. Volt was briefly active, then volt was under light sus, then antonio posted (felt like the result was that it closed the door on volt sus, accidental or not), and volt not real active afterward. I don't know why, but that sequence (could be purely coincidental!) is striking me as strange.
Very last thing- seriously geoni? I took all that time to type out ##VOTE: Geoni (even used capitals), and no reaction? Nothin'? Not even a little gratitude? Well, guess I'll take that back, fold it up, and put it in my pocket for later ....just in case I need it again.
Back tomorrow.
Post automatically merged:
Expanded on this in another post. The more the role was discussed, the more potential for negative consequences (regarding the rule about not including role pm phrasing/poss modkill). Might be paranoia, I have no exp with it, but better safe than sorry.
Geoni
You're doing great!
Very rude of you for voting me!!!!!
Eh the reaction could still be performative at the end of the day, but given you are reacting to it with a lot of panic, I can see why you liked that but personally it felt very 'shame on you look at what you just did' rather than you for example not wanting b100 to practically break a rule and risk a modkill. Of course that's not to discredit her explanation for b100 as to why it was bad, because that stuff is true, but it's the disposition behind it for me, not hard to act frustrated when you just team suspected the inexperienced PR right before they claimed.
Personally I didn't care it happened the moment I saw it because b100 has had a history of being misyeeted and it reduces the PoE slightly for us. So we might as well roll with the information since you know the wolf team is PoEing from this too. One thing I liked about Shellbell's reaction for example is that they were basically like 'okay that's one less person to worry about' and moved on.
Will look at that Volt and Antonio stuff in a bit myself but at first glance that tinfoil looks pretty noodley.
Geoni
You're doing great!
I looked at it. It's definitely a noodle that's not going to stick yet. I don't think interaction analysis is as accurate day 1 as it is later in the game where there's a more developed context but I definitely want to see more people interacting with each other.
the lack of voices is making this really hard...
like, i just dont know about pottercrossing and ghost.
i feel the same as betsy regarding misty cause i felt the same way when i saw b100ming's claim, so i'm town lean for misty
b100ming is obv town
betsy i think is also town lean. for the constant finger pointing and hunger to out mafia
antonio is null
volt i'm null slight mafia lean. i had a feeling before but also because they were here trying to stir things up and then became one of the silent ones. something doesn't sit right with me there
geoni i don't wanna sus my midnight bestie but i'm gonna sus my midnight bestie. tbh i'm quit conflicted, a lot was said, and it seems like helpful town but it could also be mafia trying a little hard to hide, as most of it is heavy on meta :/
i'm also conflicted on misty now that i've read what geoni has to say. i'm so confused
@Geoni i don't think you're going to answer me yet but i'm very curious of what you're waiting for regarding antonio
like, i just dont know about pottercrossing and ghost.
i feel the same as betsy regarding misty cause i felt the same way when i saw b100ming's claim, so i'm town lean for misty
b100ming is obv town
betsy i think is also town lean. for the constant finger pointing and hunger to out mafia
antonio is null
volt i'm null slight mafia lean. i had a feeling before but also because they were here trying to stir things up and then became one of the silent ones. something doesn't sit right with me there
geoni i don't wanna sus my midnight bestie but i'm gonna sus my midnight bestie. tbh i'm quit conflicted, a lot was said, and it seems like helpful town but it could also be mafia trying a little hard to hide, as most of it is heavy on meta :/
i'm also conflicted on misty now that i've read what geoni has to say. i'm so confused
@Geoni i don't think you're going to answer me yet but i'm very curious of what you're waiting for regarding antonio
what does tinfoil looking noodley mean? is it good or bad?
Geoni
You're doing great!
Volt is this why you are voting Betsy?
Also why would you just want to sheep that? Especially considering he's only played that game and Ghost and I only had a few hours of maf chat interaction in that game at all and most of it was me very lightly coaching him.
Post automatically merged:
Tinfoily and noodly are good things. Tinfoil means you are coming up with conspiracy level theories and idk if noodle is a widespread term but noodley for me is when someone throws spaghetti at the wall to see if it sticks and is cooked. In this case noodles = the things a player will try in order to make something out of info on the table: votes, wagons, reaction tests, theories, etc.
You say there's something you feel I am hiding, then what information do you feel lacking from me right now, that should be more out in the open at this point in the game? The Antonio thing?
It's the way he tries to solves games when he's town and the intensity behind whatever his chosen approach is. I won't say what specific way just that it's how I have observed his mindset operate in the past.
Post automatically merged:
Also when there's not a ton being said or people taking shots at one another you end up relying on meta and whatnot. :|
Last edited:
i mean it could be you, being mafia, hiding behind a lot of text to appear more town. not necessarily lacking in informativeness, it just seemed like a lot from the get go.
while that reason for relying on meta is valid, it didn't seem very helpful to me cause i feel like it distracts from the current situation but also that's not fair, i don't know any of you >.<
Geoni
You're doing great!
A lot of text is NAI for me. I always end up walling. People should consider my posts only look like walls because not enough people are posting meaty posts!
I'll try not to be overly meta heavy, shouldn't be too hard, because I don't think meta is ever reason enough alone to townread or suspect anyone.
I'm not liking how it feels this day's ending is going to really sneak up on us.
I'll try not to be overly meta heavy, shouldn't be too hard, because I don't think meta is ever reason enough alone to townread or suspect anyone.
I'm not liking how it feels this day's ending is going to really sneak up on us.
nod. doesn't make me not not sus you though
there's not even anything worthy to really talk about rn ._. is this normal? hopefully people will chime in more tomorrow.
i was waiting to see antonio's question to b100ming on why she claimed. the sudden claim then immediate off to bed is a little....
but i can see it being as simple as not wanting to be voted off day 1 if she's got a history of it lmao.
yes!
there's not even anything worthy to really talk about rn ._. is this normal? hopefully people will chime in more tomorrow.
i was waiting to see antonio's question to b100ming on why she claimed. the sudden claim then immediate off to bed is a little....
but i can see it being as simple as not wanting to be voted off day 1 if she's got a history of it lmao.
Post automatically merged:
!
yes!
b100ming
Training to become a pro Isabelle in smash
- Joined
- Jul 18, 2021
- Posts
- 1,160
- Bells
- 942
- Snowflakes
- 0
- Chocolate Coins
- 0
- Switch
- 4349-5195-1023
- Island
- Pyrrhia
I claimed because of not wanting to lie about my role, and say I’m vanilla town because it may come back to bite me in the future, and someone could accuse me of being mafia, and also I didn’t want to be yeeted d1.
Also I’m going to take a nap on the bus so I will return in about an hour and a half. Yes, I take naps on the bus. It’s because I wake up at 5:00am so my dad can drive me to the bus stop.
Post automatically merged:
Also I’m going to take a nap on the bus so I will return in about an hour and a half. Yes, I take naps on the bus. It’s because I wake up at 5:00am so my dad can drive me to the bus stop.
Last edited:
BetsySundrop
🧙♀️ 🧹
As much as I was cringing at the early role reveal, it does help with a confirmed town, and with the friendly neighbor role of confirming yourself town to 1 person/night...well, you've just friendly town "hi neighbor"-ed everyone.
Post automatically merged:
Also, regarding remaining pr, neighbor reveal may be a huge advantage. If a tracker catches a night action, no concern anymore of it being a town night action. So it makes tracker more powerful. Advantages for other poss town pr as well. So, could be genius actually.
Post automatically merged:
I thought it meant like, take off the tinfoil hat...
Post automatically merged:
Unfortunately for d1 (at least in the couple games I've played), it is very normal. It's why I try to stir things up. I'm really bad at interpreting responses though, I do tend to overthink everything.
It's usually better d2. You can see who voted/how, and the yeeted will flip town or maf. Then the nk. Then can go back and reread knowing the alignments/nk. I'm still bad at figuring it out from that point, but trying to improve....
Last edited:
b100ming
Training to become a pro Isabelle in smash
- Joined
- Jul 18, 2021
- Posts
- 1,160
- Bells
- 942
- Snowflakes
- 0
- Chocolate Coins
- 0
- Switch
- 4349-5195-1023
- Island
- Pyrrhia
I’m sussing geoni. Especially after the game I hosted where he was mafia. Also sussing ghost cuz he’s a sneaky boy and I don’t trust him. @Ghost2008 come back and explain yourself!
- Status
