Serious question: Dom or Sherb? Why?

[eggie_]

sherb, because doms chin wrinkles freak my out they’re icky get them away from me

 

[HopeForHyrule]

Dom is cute, especially for a jock...but Sherb is my BOI.

 

[Wookaru]

I'm not really into the goat/sheep designs. However Sherb is the exception here. Just enough charm to set himself apart form the crowd. Plus I really like blue.

 

[Zane]

Out of these two Dom for sure. Neither are among my favorites but when I saw Dom on a mystery island I adopted him. When I saw Sherb I left him there. Lol. Jocks > Lazies (Especially in NH), and sheep > goats. Plus Dom’s face is hilarious. Sherb has a gorgeous color scheme - I reeeally like blue villagers - but it’s kinda wasted on him.

 

[saucySheep]

alright... i know i already replied SHerb... but here's WHY:

Much easier on the eyes. loving the simplistic design and i love that he REALLY fits the lazy personality - when he talks about bugs, it isn't weird and unsettling. it's just natural. that's sherb for ya.
Dom, on the other hand, is absolutely PRECIOUS - but.... ehh... Blue > white : P

 

[Sander]

That's a tough one. I like both which is remarkable since I mostly only like 'natural' looking villagers - so neither of them are on my island.

I'd probably pick Dom because of him breaking the mold for jock villagers and the pretty limited options of fitting jocks on my Island. Sherb's really cute too, and his house interior is one of the best in the game imo, but I don't want 3 lazies and Erik & Beau are here to stay.

 

[pawpatrolbab]

Dom bc he is our rainbow loving MLM icon

 

[a sprout]

Dom! I had Sherb at some point, and something about his mouth bothered me a little? he's still adorable and i do appreciate him, but Dom has a special charm of trying to be incredibly tough and muscular...and...fluffy. Dom's facial expressions are hilarious too.

 

[ekcomyth]

dom cos he's fluffy and cuter than sherb IMO. sherb looks like any other villager but that doesnt mean i dont love him

 

[Che5hire Cat]

I'm gonna say Dom, I have Sherb currently on my island and while he's a cutie, I just don't get along with him that much. Dom on the other hand became kinda a favorite of mine, then again I like the sheep villagers in general, so therefore he gets automatically a plus point.

 

[BambieTheMayor]

I've never been a fan of goats. However, Sherb is definitely an exception. I love the huge eyes and... of course he has to be my favorite shade of blue! The lazies are also my favorite male personality, so thay's definitely a bonus. Although I paid him no mind at first (he wasn't even originally in my roster for dreamies), he eventually became one of my favorites. 250 tickets later, he's all mine!

Dom... sorry, buddy, but I just don't like the sheep villagers, and unfortunately you, unlike Sherb, are no exception. I don't mind the jocks in the slightest. I loved Axel in NH and Roald was definitely in the running when I was considering what dreamies to have on my island, but Dom's design just... heavily creeps me out.

 

[Bulbadragon]

Sherb. I just like his design and personality better, plus I love the goats (I already have Pashmina). I love lazy villagers and always have. Where his design is pastel, I find it much easier on the eyes personally. I'd love to have Sherb and would take him if offered, because I would have multiple lazy villagers. However, I'd pass on Dom because jock villagers are okay to have one of and I wouldn't choose him over my favorite, Tank. Dom isn't ugly to me, but he's just okay, nothing special. Sherb is just too cute

 

[Heartcore]

Sherb 1000000%. I've had both and I did not like Dom at all. Sherb has quickly become my favorite villager of all time, even more so than Diana or Lobo. He's just so sweet and his design definitely fits the lazy vibe. Dom just was not for me, I prefer other jocks like Bam, Genji, Rudy, or Pierce. But overall other than Muffy, I don't really like the sheep villagers.

 

[TheSillyPuppy]

Personally, I prefer Sherb. I'm not the biggest fan of jock villagers to begin with, and to me, Dom isn't the cutest jock villager out there. Generally, I don't like the goat villagers either, -- I find their faces to be way too flat -- but Sherb looks like a baby, which I think embodies the lazy villager persona. I also prefer villager designs with more focused colour schemes.

 

[Angerfish]

I initially liked Sherb more for his cohesive design. He is undoubtedly cute! He would fit perfectly in anyone's pastel or kidcore village. However, I do prefer Dom's very chaotic vibe. Him being a cry baby jock is great and makes him look like a complete wannabe. I love him!

 

[Fraggle]

I really don’t get on with the Jock personality but even if I did I’m Team Sherb! He lives on my island and is innocent and adorable