Spooky Showdown

[KittenNoir]

gonna root for muffy til the very end, we need more black collectibles give my goth girl a chance!!!

OMG agree we need a cute little gothic queen I LOVE muffy !!!!

 

[moonbyu]

i need a muffy collectible PLEASEEEEE

 

[Coach]

Team Pietro

Petri and Raddle are cool too

 

[nightglow]

I'm hoping for Pietro to win due to the theme of this event plus I know there are a few out there who love him. (I don't)
He would look pretty neat nestled in this year's collectibles. I mean, you can't go wrong with cotton candy, popcorn, and the lollipop with Pietro. And New Horizons has dialog of villagers seeing ghosts and clowns outside at night.

 

[BetsySundrop]

What about Gruff? Nobody likes Gruff?

I like Gruff, Muffy, Stitches, or Rodeo... but I think out of those, only muffy and stitches have a chance to make it to the finals, lol.

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

What about Gruff? Nobody likes Gruff?

I like Gruff, Muffy, Stitches, or Rodeo... but I think out of those, only muffy and stitches have a chance to make it to the finals, lol.

Gruff has a special place in my heart, he was one of my first 10 original villagers in the first AC game I ever played!

But I voted for Cube because I think he would make a better collectible.. something about those spooky eyes

 

[Rainbowhorn]

Putting my money on Muffy

 

[Firesquids]

I'd be happy with Muffy, Stitches, and Pietro in that order.
I made some quick mock-ups to test out their colors and honestly (imo) Muffy and Stitches lend themselves best to the color scheme of the rest of the collectibles from this event.

Spoiler

 

[Flicky]

Two of my villagers are here, and neither of them are going to win even their first round by the looks of it. Alas.

I'm gonna cheer on Mathilda, but something tells me it'll be between Pietro, Muffy and/or Stitches, in which case, go Stitches!

 

[Croconaw]

Unpopular opinion: I want Cherry.

 

[Sharksheep]

I am so sad that Kiki isn't on this list. We have 3 canine animal crossing collectibles: Lucky, Lobo, and Isabelle
And the only cat on here is a Stinky

Kiki is like the most Halloween villager imo.

 

[Darkesque_]

I want a Pietro collectible so bad

 

[-Mars-]

R.I.P I knew I should have entered the slideshow tents sooner, too late to vote now
I wanted Spike and Cherry they are some of my favorite villagers of all time and Cherry lives on my island right now.

 

[LaBelleFleur]

Apologies for the delay - Round 2 is up for voting now!

 

[Aerith]

so sad my boy Knox didn't make it, I was too late

I guess I'll throw all in for goth icon Muffy.

 

[amemome]

things are panning out how i expected! wonder if there will be any upsets...

 

[Nougat]

Rooting for Stitches!

 

[Snek]

I have a feeling Pietro is going to win. It feels right considering this is a carnival

 

[LaBelleFleur]

Round 3 is up for voting!

 

[Snek]

Something deep down tells me it's going to be a Stitches x Muffy battle at the very end.

You have a very perfect intuition...scary almost.