Mafia Sunleth Waterscape Mafia (Game Over/Mafia Win)

[Geoni]

That's anti-town.

I was actually pointfully(?) arguing to see if a nub mafia member picks up on the argument and tries to use it as a serious reason to suspect either of us. Like 8floor did in Portal. But you ruined it Nick. Like you ruin everything.

 

[Superpenguin]

I was actually pointfully(?) arguing to see if a nub mafia member picks up on the argument and tries to use it as a serious reason to suspect either of us. Like 8floor did in Portal. But you ruined it Nick. Like you ruin everything.

I didn't ruin our victory in Portal, so watch your mouth boi. I'll come over there and slap you! >:|

 

[Ashtot]

Yeah but Tom only posted a simple list and then was all like "herpderp It's only been an hour since game started so it's not like this is important hurdurrr," which basically discredits the information he was trying to give in his list. :|

That's exaggerated. He didn't discredit it. All me mean is that there is a possibility that they haven't been online.

 

[Superpenguin]

That nifty little watch list you people like so much. Why do you insist on being a pain lately Nick? That inner red color got you all hot and bothered?

Yeah, lots of dinosaur creatures have red insides. It's kinda common, actually.

 

[Geoni]

I'll come over there and slap you! >:|

Don't talk to Dad that way.

 

[Mewmewmewm]

Not really the same thing.

Mew I don't know why exactly this happens but every game you're like a page behind us in your thoughts or something.

Honestly, I'm a slow typer ヽ(；▽；)ノ and sometimes i miss pages i'm sorry. I swear i cant keep up.
Am i the only one who hates "reaction testing?" Isn't This the same thing dad did as glados in portal?

 

[Superpenguin]

That's exaggerated. He didn't discredit it. All me mean is that there is a possibility that they haven't been online.

Yeah, but you have to take in the fact that this is Tom so you have to exaggerate the things that he says to compare him to others, yah know?

 

[Ashtot]

Yeah, but you have to take in the fact that this is Tom so you have to exaggerate the things that he says to compare him to others, yah know?

That doesn't even make any sense.

 

[Superpenguin]

Honestly, I'm a slow typer ヽ(；▽；)ノ and sometimes i miss pages i'm sorry. I swear i cant keep up.
Am i the only one who hates "reaction testing?" Isn't This the same thing dad did as glados in portal?

Yeah, but since you specifically don't know how to really reaction test (hence why you probably hate it) he was able to tell you all false results of those reaction tests.

 

[Mewmewmewm]

OMG sp quality posts.
10/10.
Best game.
BEST game.
*brings back up portal mafia where SP went on for 3 pages in a pointless arguement with Aerious*

 

[Superpenguin]

That doesn't even make any sense.

Uhm yeah it does. Tom obviously isn't going to discredit something as greatly as a nubby player usually would, so his discredits are different from say Mew's.

 

[Ashtot]

I swear i cant keep up.

This doesn't really make any sense. It isn't hard to read a couple pages, and if you truly can't be bothered to put the time into it, then just don't play, it's as simple as that.

 

[Superpenguin]

OMG sp quality posts.
10/10.
Best game.
BEST game.
*brings back up portal mafia where SP went on for 3 pages in a pointless arguement with Aerious*

It wasn't a pointless argument. She is annoying and deserved to be argued with. >:| If you want to talk about pointless posts how about you talk about:

Kermit spam when I was town
Claiming to be a fool when I was town
Claiming to be a Sleeper Inventor Toxic Goo when I was town

 

[Geoni]

Am i the only one who hates "reaction testing?" Isn't This the same thing dad did as glados in portal?

Lol you weren't paying attention to how I was playing in Portal, were you? Probably why you helped town lose in the end. In portal, my strategy was to kill off all of the players who would catch onto mafia the quickest and leave the less attentive around to mislynch each other like crazy, and it worked. I don't think I even reaction tested anyone in Portal.

 

[Ashtot]

Uhm yeah it does. Tom obviously isn't going to discredit something as greatly as a nubby player usually would, so his discredits are different from say Mew's.

Yeah, didn't understand what you said sorry.

 

[Superpenguin]

Yeah, didn't understand what you said sorry.

It's okay. I could see that you were confused, so I decided to help you instead of accusing you of scum which is what Dad would do.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Uhm yeah it does. Tom obviously isn't going to discredit something as greatly as a nubby player usually would, so his discredits are different from say Mew's.

I don't really think so, but that's for you guys to decide. Honestly I've never really seen the point to those kinds of lists minus the few times its somehow managed to catch scum.

 

[Minties]

So home from work now and all caught up! Since it's day one, I don't have a TON of thoughts currently, just highlighted little snippets I noticed.

I'm Tom's twin but Tom doesn't know that he is my twin. Well, now he does as does everyone else. Twin works as normal. Any action that goes on me targets Tom and vice versa.

Don't twins usually know each other's identity? I've never heard of twins that didn't. Are you sleeper inventor toxic gooing us again? Not cool Nicko.

---

Tsundere and Ryan are clear.

Still wondering why you would even say this. So now claiming green automatically makes you not mafia? I don't think we can say that anyone at all is clear on day one ever (unless there was an innocent child).

---

This is my second game.

Perhaps you should have done a newbie mafia then.

---

OMG sp quality posts.
10/10.
Best game.
BEST game.
*brings back up portal mafia where SP went on for 3 pages in a pointless arguement with Aerious*

I can see that you're contributing quality posts as well. /sarcasm I don't buy your whole "can't keep up with the thread" crap. If I can work a full time job and read all the pages, so can you. In xcom, you didn't accuse anyone really or post anything that wasn't just recaps or complaining about catching up, but now you have a voice? Jumping straight on Ryan really raised all kinds of red flags* for me about you.


*used this term just for superpenguin.

 

[Geoni]

Still wondering why you would even say this. So now claiming green automatically makes you not mafia? I don't think we can say that anyone at all is clear on day one ever (unless there was an innocent child).

I simply said that as something coming from my own perspective. I was waiting for others to talk about what the townie was, and Tsundere confirmed it. They were the first to reveal the creature that I was given in my PM: miniflan (which look like cute little tomato blobs btw). For that reason alone Tsundere is 100% clear unless they were breaking the no PM rule. Ryan on the other hand isn't 100% clear but I honestly don't think he was lying about it either, due to his behavior in this game matching partners. I'll consider the possibility that he might not be town this time around, but I think it's unlikely in comparison to other people. The clarity regarding these two is something to remember when it comes to voting, so that's why I would say it.

And at the twin thing, Minties, they don't always know each other's identities. They didn't in Frozen when there was good elsa and evil elsa. At least I don't think they did? They just knew the other one existed from what I remember. I won't disregard the idea that SP could be throwing a curve ball of a role claim at us, he's done it a number of times before.

 

[JellofishXD]

I had school but I'm back now!