Mafia TBT Mafia: Attack on Titan - [Game Over/Town Wins]
- Thread starter Minties
- Start date
Kirbystarship
Senior Member
Or they could be trolling the game.
Kirbystarship
Senior Member
I'm still decideing.
Curry
Kunai wit chain!
I don't believe Tardis's claim. Vig seems like a fairly easy safe claim for the mafia to claim as a PR since most blues have duplicates and I doubt all of the duplicates are in play. It's a power role but not an unbelievable one like JoAT. Trundle was ballsy af for claiming JoAT and I don't believe he would risk it as mafia. Vig is much more believable, especially when there were two listed. I'll look at tae's more when it's not 2 AM, but I don't really believe Tardis's.
Tardis began this game like he did Bus Driver as scum. Maybe I shouldn't use a micro as evidence but it's where I saw Tardis as scum and I thought he started this game just like that one. I began to town lean him, but since the suspicions on him, Tardis hasn't defended himself adequately at all. The only thing that really tells him not being scum is his Vig claim and even that isn't confirmed yet. So far his defenses have been terrible or even avoiding the questions. Such as these examples:
Like, everyone else who has been sus'd has defended themselves more than Tardis has and a lack of a good defense is really what turns up my suspicions on people. Even someone like Cad who has been a large sus target has defended themselves more than Tardis has. Like I said, Tardis's biggest defense of himself has been his claim.
And then to answer his sus of me (which Alexi also pointed this quote out):
Tardis really just hasn't made any adequate defense and I'm not convinced of his Vig claim since all possible roles can be seen, it makes sense to pick a believable safe claim as mafia when double Vigs doesn't seem entirely likely. Since not all roles have to be in play, if there isn't a mafia doctor I don't see there being double Vig and a JoAT. If Day 3 comes and he shot someone and claims it and it's believable, I'll eat my words but for now I think Tardis is very sus.
Sorry this took so long, I got distracted a lot.
Tardis began this game like he did Bus Driver as scum. Maybe I shouldn't use a micro as evidence but it's where I saw Tardis as scum and I thought he started this game just like that one. I began to town lean him, but since the suspicions on him, Tardis hasn't defended himself adequately at all. The only thing that really tells him not being scum is his Vig claim and even that isn't confirmed yet. So far his defenses have been terrible or even avoiding the questions. Such as these examples:
Tardis2016 said:
Miharu said:
Such a wonderful defense.Tardis2016 said:
BangoTheElf said:
This doesn't even make any sense...Trundle never even called Heyden for sure scum in this post.Tardis2016 said:
Like, everyone else who has been sus'd has defended themselves more than Tardis has and a lack of a good defense is really what turns up my suspicions on people. Even someone like Cad who has been a large sus target has defended themselves more than Tardis has. Like I said, Tardis's biggest defense of himself has been his claim.
And then to answer his sus of me (which Alexi also pointed this quote out):
If I was going to sheep and try and get away with it, why the hell would I point out the fact that I'm sheeping? I would want to attract as little attention as possible, not point out the fact that I'm intentionally sheeping. You're also saying you don't like how I'm trying to help not get the JoAT killed? Because just sitting back and risking Trundle getting lynched is so much better.Tardis2016 said:
Tardis really just hasn't made any adequate defense and I'm not convinced of his Vig claim since all possible roles can be seen, it makes sense to pick a believable safe claim as mafia when double Vigs doesn't seem entirely likely. Since not all roles have to be in play, if there isn't a mafia doctor I don't see there being double Vig and a JoAT. If Day 3 comes and he shot someone and claims it and it's believable, I'll eat my words but for now I think Tardis is very sus.
Sorry this took so long, I got distracted a lot.
Cory
Senior Member
- Joined
- Jan 7, 2014
- Posts
- 6,442
- Bells
- 271
- Snowflakes
- 0
- Chocolate Coins
- 0
- Santa Tokens
- 0
- Switch
- 4803-6658-3883
Two days in a row everyone voted? That must be a new record.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Tae vig yourself to keep the prophecy going
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oath is either blue or scum becuase he doesn't get townie
- - - Post Merge - - -
Tae vig yourself to keep the prophecy going
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oath is either blue or scum becuase he doesn't get townie
