Mafia TBT Mafia II: Mafia Strike Back [Game Over/Mafia Win]

[MyLifeIsCake]

Aw, sucks we lost two paramedics and a dectective I assume the vigilante took a risk and hit a mafia member, cudos to them

Anyways, I don't know about Hikari yet. Half of me wants to think they are suspicious, but the other half of says they are just trying to defend a weak argument.

 

[Hikari]

Okay, SP, I'll go ahead and start my defences.

Riley: I agreed with you because I really do find it suspious that Trundle has been trying to get me out through out this whole game. Also, if I recall, you also agree with everyone, partlically last game. With your reasoning, should we suspect you as Mafia as well?

Kayla: I wouldn't be surprised if Mafia framed me. Especially if Trundle or tsudere was a detective and the mafia knew it. Also, I wouldn't jump to conclusions just because some told me I was a Mafia Goon. This 'detective' could be trying to decieve you, and get another townie out of the game, and making another lynch useless.

Trundle: I still don't know why you keep on targeting me, and with only one piece of 'evidence'. Can you tell me any other evidence you have against me other than, "bad evidence." and "lurking."

 

[Midoriya]

Okay, SP, I'll go ahead and start my defences.

Riley: I agreed with you because I really do find it suspious that Trundle has been trying to get me out through out this whole game. Also, if I recall, you also agree with everyone, partlically last game. With your reasoning, should we suspect you as Mafia as well?

Kayla: I wouldn't be surprised if Mafia framed me. Especially if Trundle or tsudere was a detective and the mafia knew it. Also, I wouldn't jump to conclusions just because some told me I was a Mafia Goon. This 'detective' could be trying to decieve you, and get another townie out of the game, and making another lynch useless.

Trundle: I still don't know why you keep on targeting me, and with only one piece of 'evidence'. Can you tell me any other evidence you have against me other than, "bad evidence." and "lurking."

I haven't been agreeing with everyone, if you've noticed. If I do agree with someone I give a clear reason as to why I did backed up by evidence. Also, remember when ITYW was going to be lynched, I didn't agree with them. It was my mistake to change the tide against someone I didn't know was a townie, but it could have at least saved an important role that ITYW might be occupying. I've been watching how you agree with me over and over again, and it seems too fake to be real. If this is your attempt to cast the suspicion on someone else, then you just rejected the advice SP told you to. He said to post a defense, not cast the suspicion on someone else. And you did the opposite when posting your defense to me. I have no doubt that you're mafia now.

 

[Hikari]

I haven't been agreeing with everyone, if you've noticed. If I do agree with someone I give a clear reason as to why I did backed up by evidence. Also, remember when ITYW was going to be lynched, I didn't agree with them. It was my mistake to change the tide against someone I didn't know was a townie, but it could have at least saved an important role that ITYW might be occupying. I've been watching how you agree with me over and over again, and it seems too fake to be real. If this is your attempt to cast the suspicion on someone else, then you just rejected the advice SP told you to. He said to post a defense, not cast the suspicion on someone else. And you did the opposite when posting your defense to me. I have no doubt that you're mafia now.

I wasn't really trying to shift attention to you, put I was just pointing out that you were agreeing with a lot of people too. Also, I personally think that you made some really good points in your last couple of post, so that's why I was agreeing with you.

 

[iLoveYou]

Kayla: I wouldn't be surprised if Mafia framed me. Especially if Trundle or tsudere was a detective and the mafia knew it. Also, I wouldn't jump to conclusions just because some told me I was a Mafia Goon. This 'detective' could be trying to decieve you, and get another townie out of the game, and making another lynch useless.

We have been suspecting you for a long while though, this is definitely not the first time we have brought up your name for the Town to see. This has been going on and on based on your posts and your voting habits. I do believe the detective who inspected you for obvious reasons that I can not post here (otherwise I will most likely be modkilled as I already received my warning).

I honestly feel like we can not pass up this opportunity. :l Especially since our Vigilante (who has been PM'ing me and keeping in contact with me) correctly hit a Mafia member last night, we have a chance right now to change their KP for the upcoming night.

 

[EpicGamer12]

For some reason I feel like Trundle is trying too hard. In the beginning of the game I remember Trundle voted for himself in the town election at first, and people thought it made him look like mafia, but then waved off the fact. He changed it to Gallows to try and get suspicion off of him, but I still saw what happened. Now, later in the game, he's been trying really hard at accusing Hikari of mafia. I think Trundle has tried too hard to go in one direction that people don't always want to go. For that reason, I think Trundle is suspicious. I would like to hear a defense from Trundle though before I vote.

Hahaha... Trying too hard? I've already stated my defense for this more than once, but if you'd like to hear it again, sure.
I was pressed for time that night, and because I didn't trust any of the running, I decided to NOT join a bandwagon and vote for myself. When I woke up I switched to Gallows because I felt like he would be a good choice. Maybe I should hear YOUR defense for bandwagon'ing the whole flipping time. Obviously, I knew earlier that I wasn't going to get a bunch of votes. I placed my vote there as a placeholder in case I didn't have time to get back on before the day ended.
I've been trying really hard at Hikari because I honestly believe Hikari is mafia.

 

[BlueLeaf]

Back from school. I hope the two paramedics aren't the only ones, or else every shot given will be successful, unless the sheriff incarcerates.

Trundle: Do not try too hard to suspect anyone. FoxWolf mentioned this, and last game, he was killed for that.

I don't have any suspicions on anyone right now. We have tons of time, so I'll keep my eyes peeled for suspicion.

 

[Midoriya]

That was just a test. Again you agree with me with not enough reason. I can understand once, but you're too attached and it's starting to seem suspicious. And after reading the above that Iloveyou quoted, I'm voting Hikari.

I think you skipped this part, Trundle. I was never suspicious of you at all. I was just trying to see if Hikari would bandwagon with me a 2nd/3rd time. If you don't believe me, I've had no suspicion against you the whole time before my post. There's no reason I would now.

I was analyzing posts last night and saw some things out of the ordinary. I wanted to confirm my suspicion against Hikari to see how they would respond. I forgot to mention this Trundle, so sorry if I confused you.

 

[cannedcommunism]

Well, Hikari's starting to point fingers. I'll keep a close eye on him, but I'm definitely not jumping to conclusions.

 

[Beary]

Well
Um
I'm sad.
Honestly, it surprised me that lynn was the detective. I understand she tried to keep it secret, but didn't do a very good job defensively.
3 blue roles.
3. And important ones too! I really hope we win...
Because I don't want to lose my first game :O
VillageDweller...WHY
WHY WHYWHY
Now everyone will think that I'm mafia because he voted for me...wow. These mafia are smart to set me up like that.
BUT I WAS NOT FOOLED.
Thunder...he was slightly inactive. I'm honestly not surprised...
And Creeper? 5 Mafia left. Prepare to lose >

 

[Hikari]

Guess I'm gonna have to wait for Trundle to get back online, for him to respond to what I said. Anyways, thank you to everyone who hasn't gone and bandwangoned me yet. Seeing as how the last two bandwagons went, we should try and find really good evidence before we start voting.

 

[radical6]

VD U CANT LEAVE ME I LOVE U!!!
and bye lynn !! (sucks u got a 3 game ban)
and bye thunder u piece of trash luv u u will be missed (not rly)

although i voted for hikari yesterday i wont vote for him right away but ill keep my eye on him? and there are a few others ill watch too.

also whoever the vig is good job man!
i do hope we have another medic or we're screwed

 

[Superpenguin]

Guess I'm gonna have to wait for Trundle to get back online, for him to respond to what I said. Anyways, thank you to everyone who hasn't gone and bandwangoned me yet. Seeing as how the last two bandwagons went, we should try and find really good evidence before we start voting.

Well, let's see...you are really the only suspect so far. Sure a case can be made on Riley for his recent bandwagoning or we could look at Lauren, a random player lynn was targeting(who was a detective, hmm?), but those two both lack a crucial piece of evidence that you have against you...

There are several of us who are going to be making a move against another person who was inspected. The results came up as "Mafia Goon" and they need to be lynched today. We can not afford another delay. Evidence is currently being accumulated by several players.

I know this is a tease, but please be understanding.

My suspicion as of now is Hikari.




Also after he publicly attacked Horus and Horus posted his defence, the thread began exploding on Beary509 + iTookYourWaffles. He immediately fell silent. I viewed this as the act of Hikari trying to point a finger and get someone in the spotlight & then simply falling silent, because he could have seen that the town was already doing the work by being at each other's throats.

Also his vote shifted along with the town as I mentioned in my quote. He voted for iTookYourWaffles when she was the popular vote and then he voted for 3DSFan134 when he was the popular vote.

Maybe Kayla's true suspicion isn't you, but yeah it seems most likely it is.

And after last night's kill of Hugz and Kayla announcing that the vig who killed Hugz was in continuous contact with her, I'd say that they had A LOT of trust in each other...and the fact that a mafia member was the victim of the kill instead of a town member shows that Kayla probably didn't attempt steering them in the wrong direction.

So, as of now I'll trust Kayla's instincts, but I won't rush into the voting process too early, as I ended up changing my vote yesterday when I did. :/

 

[BlueLeaf]

Question for Kayla and/or Justin:
Did any detective PM you with information? The days/nights early in the game have few information, so we need as much as we need.
The two lynches were based off of non-contributors, and I feel we should step away from that route.

 

[iLoveYou]

I need the town to think about how this will affect the Mafia's killing power.

If we remove another Mafia player from the game this will knock down their killing power from 3 to 2. We can not afford to pass this opportunity. Especially after the results of last night. :l

Please note that I was closely working with our Vigilante who shot down TheCreeperHugz (died & confirmed as Mafia). We have good reason to believe in our suspicions when we do make them. It is really hard to reveal certain pieces of information without putting other players at risk right now (Bodyguard, Vigilante, Detective). Especially now that our Vigilante is a regular townie. I need strong players like that to help guide the Town on the right path.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Question for Kayla and/or Justin:
Did any detective PM you with information? The days/nights early in the game have few information, so we need as much as we need.
The two lynches were based off of non-contributors, and I feel we should step away from that route.

I personally received no PMs from Detectives, until today after the night deathly post was posted. So unfortunately I was not able to work with Lynn105 as she did not reveal herself to me.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Hikari, a lot of people are suspicious of you at this point, not just me. Maybe just look around at EVERYONE ELSE'S POSTS and you'll see why you're so suspected.

 

[Hikari]

Hikari, a lot of people are suspicious of you at this point, not just me. Maybe just look around at EVERYONE ELSE'S POSTS and you'll see why you're so suspected.

I already heard their reasons, but I wanted to know why you suspected me other than your two reasons I already know. ("lurking" and "bad evidence.")

 

[EpicGamer12]

I already heard their reasons, but I wanted to know why you suspected me other than your two reasons I already know. ("lurking" and "bad evidence.")

My main suspicions were based off of you're random framing of Horus. Next, I called you out on your terrible evidence, and you lurked for the next while until Jubs supported my point on Waffles and anything anyone thought of you blew over. You then jumped on the next bandwagon available and tried to blend in past then. That was all I had, and now people have other accusations on you based on other points. I'm not in any way the grand scheme master of framing you and I don't know about everyone else's points. That was why I originally suspected and now people have picked up on the fact that you are indeed quite suspicious.

 

[Hikari]

My main suspicions were based off of you're random framing of Horus. Next, I called you out on your terrible evidence, and you lurked for the next while until Jubs supported my point on Waffles and anything anyone thought of you blew over. You then jumped on the next bandwagon available and tried to blend in past then. That was all I had, and now people have other accusations on you based on other points. I'm not in any way the grand scheme master of framing you and I don't know about everyone else's points. That was why I originally suspected and now people have picked up on the fact that you are indeed quite suspicious.

Okay, thanks for explaining why you were suspsious of me in the first place.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And sorry that I was "lurking", I left the thread open in a tab for most of the day, during the past few days, and like Horus, I didn't really have anything to say.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Okay, thanks for explaining why you were suspsious of me in the first place.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And sorry that I was "lurking", I left the thread open in a tab for most of the day, during the past few days, and like Horus, I didn't really have anything to say.

Just another question. Why are you invisibly posting? Something to hide?