Mafia TBT Mafia II: Mafia Strike Back [Game Over/Mafia Win]

[Midoriya]

Okay, it seems like the only thing I can do know is to tell you all my role. I didn't want to reveal it, since th Mafia will know, but I've relized it won't hurt me very much since I'm a Miller. And I guess I've lived up to my name, since, according to Kayla, a detective investigated me, and said I was a Mafia Goon. Anyways, I hope you will believe me, and vote for someone else, who's acutally mafia.

Come to think of it, doesn't it say that if a Miller is rolechecked they'll be seen as a mafia goon? This could be the case, but I don't think I'll change my vote yet since it could be a lie too.

Prof Gallows, I know you're sure about Iloveyou being mafia, but I would like to hear an argument to why you think she is. It'd be too hard to look back and find your original argument in the thread, but I would like you to post a new one (If possible).

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh never mind, just reread the first post. You just dug a deeper grave, Hikari.

 

[Hikari]

Sorry, I worded that wrong, Justin. I meant to say that I now know I'm a Miller since Kayla told everyone I was a Mafia Goon. Sorry for any confusion!

 

[Justin]

Also, sorry I haven't posted today, I'll be doing that a bit later. Although I'm not sure if there's a whole lot to say now after the events just now... I literally just popped in here now to read through and saw Hikari's post feeling it was worth calling out right away.

 

[Beary]

Jubs.
You are so intense.
On that note, I beleive Hikari, because he seems to be legitamatlly miller.
And it does make sense when you think about it. C:

 

[Hikari]

Jubs.
You are so intense.
On that note, I beleive Hikari, because he seems to be legitamatlly miller.
And it does make sense when you think about it. C:

Thank you Beary for believing me. (I hate it when I mis-word things!)

 

[oath2order]

Well, this just sealed my vote for you. You must be scum considering you're not told if you're Miller.

Nice try.

Btw, YOU WON'T BE TOLD IF YOU'RE A MILLER. Unless you're lying or you slipped up, can we actually believe you?

Signed, sealed, and delivered. The lynch is yours, Hikari, and oh my god I have no regrets voting for you now.

 

[BellGreen]

Thank you Beary for believing me. (I hate it when I mis-word things!)

It seems as though it was just a slip up in text.
It could have been a framer as well since it's another logical explanation for Mafia Goon.

 

[iLoveYou]

Spoiler: snip

Come to think of it, doesn't it say that if a Miller is rolechecked they'll be seen as a mafia goon? This could be the case, but I don't think I'll change my vote yet since it could be a lie too.

Prof Gallows, I know you're sure about Iloveyou being mafia, but I would like to hear an argument to why you think she is. It'd be too hard to look back and find your original argument in the thread, but I would like you to post a new one (If possible).

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh never mind, just reread the first post. You just dug a deeper grave, Hikari.

Prof Gallows is someone on my suspicion list right now. He has been the only one to step up and subtly defend Hikari. Last game you will all remember that Prof Gallows subtly tried defending FireNinja1 (they were both mafia last game), when FireNinja1 was under attack. Today reminded me somewhat of that. I understand if players choose not to go by previous games but that is there regardless.

Also his posts:

To be honest, if you were having a group of people holding a witch hunt on you, I think you'd be pointing fingers at them as well. =p

You're very quick to jump onto the accusation train as well, FoxWolf. As is everyone else.

How about you go back and look what happened with 3DSfan? You were all determined he was mafia, or if he wasn't, that it was a lynch worth doing. So we wasted a lynch on him, and now we have most of our important roles dead. With only one mafia member to go with them. Think everyone should take their flipping time to figure these things out before voting on someone.

Here we see Prof Gallows attempting to defend Hikari's move of pointing fingers right back at us. I understand that it is normal to want to defend yourself (as Hikari did) but now that we see Hikari digging his grave, this kinda stands out in my mind (the fact that Prof Gallows was subtly attempting to defend Hikari).

He was trying to pin this as another "3DSFan134" lynch. :l This could be to get the Town to think about their previous unsuccessful lynches and hesitate to vote for Hikari.

- - - - -

That would be Trundle, iLoveYou, Riley, and FoxWolf.

Again, I still suspect iLoveYou as mafia 100%. No doubts in my mind, at all.

Here we see Prof Gallows attempting to help Hikari by shifting the blame completely on the first voters (Trundle, iLoveYou, Riley & FoxWolf64). This is obviously a good argument to make to get the Town thinking about bandwagons & get the Town to hesitate on voting for said player (Hikari).

Now the question is whether Prof Gallows was doing this as a Town player or a fellow Mafia player to Hikari? I do not suggest we lynch Prof Gallows right away as we do not currently have leads on him. But he is definitely someone to discuss in the future.

 

[EpicGamer12]

And this was the exact role you were PM'ed by Karla. You're not fake-roleclaiming or anything. You actually were assigned this role?

Yes, this is my role.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And it's the worst one too...

Well, this just sealed my vote for you. You must be scum considering you're not told if you're Miller.

Nice try.

hahahaha so much win

 

[radical6]

yep gonna go with my vote from yesterday
oh man that was a really big slip up.

 

[Beary]

yep gonna go with my vote from yesterday
oh man that was a really big slip up.

And what was your vote from yesterday? :/
You can't just vote so quickly.
I appreciate evidence or at least a reason why.

 

[BellGreen]

Sorry Hikari, but that slip up was just too big. You're one of my most biggest suspicions.

Prof. Gallows had many good points against him mainly by iLoveYou. He has been defending other players including Hikari and since she was discovered Mafia Goon, maybe Hikari and Prof. Gallows set this up.

That's just a theory though =P

 

[radical6]

And what was your vote from yesterday? :/
You can't just vote so quickly.
I appreciate evidence or at least a reason why.

my..vote...was...for..hikari...
i literally think hes still mafia and his attempt at roleclaiming mafia just ruined his chance of me changing my mind

- - - Post Merge - - -

miller***
that and i didnt vote so quickly?? what. many other people have voted before me..

 

[Lauren]

Holy mother of god!
I've been rarely active on here and i come back to read Hikari had revealed himself/herself I DONT KNOW YOUR GENDER PERSON.

So much is happening so quickly! I hope they're not messing with us! We could really do with another mafia dead with most of our blues going!

 

[iLoveYou]

And what was your vote from yesterday? :/
You can't just vote so quickly.
I appreciate evidence or at least a reason why.

Are you serious right now? Hikari just slipped up BIG TIME. He can not be a Miller because Millers are NOT told when they are the Miller. He was trying to put a reason onto why he appeared as "Mafia Goon" but it failed. Please do not try to put this on Tsundere now. She is voting with good reason.

I was believing you when you said you were Town to me in PM, but this is making me want to change my mind. :l

 

[Beary]

my..vote...was...for..hikari...
i literally think hes still mafia and his attempt at roleclaiming mafia just ruined his chance of me changing my mind

- - - Post Merge - - -

miller***
that and i didnt vote so quickly?? what. many other people have voted before me..

Um..I'm not so dumb that each word must be pronounced.
He did not role claim mafia.
He role claimed miller. There is a difference, my friend.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Omagosh, sorry. Your other post hadn't loaded when I posted >.<

- - - Post Merge - - -

Are you serious right now? Hikari just slipped up BIG TIME. He can not be a Miller because Millers are NOT told when they are the Miller. He was trying to put a reason onto why he appeared as "Mafia Goon" but it failed. Please do not try to put this on Tsundere now. She is voting with good reason.

I was believing you when you said you were Town to me in PM, but this is making me want to change my mind. :l

I am confused as you are. I don't know who to vote for, and this might be a mistake, or not. I 'half' believe Hikari. Did you see how he said that he found he was a miller? Because you said that they were a Mafia Goon. I'm not sure who to believe...but this might or might not be true.

And am I entitled to my opinions?

 

[MyLifeIsCake]

I wasn't going to vote for Hikari at first b/c I didn't really see any revealing evidence in their post until they said they were the Miller... Honestly, THAT was a bad slip up. I just wish someone hadn't said anything... I wanted to see how long they would of kept going with it.

 

[oath2order]

beary it is literally impossible to find out if you are miller until you are dead.

 

[Beary]

beary it is literally impossible to find out if you are miller until you are dead.

This is my first game, gosh...
I'm sorry Hikari, I kind of believe you, but I have to vote for you, for there is to much evidence against you. :C
If i'm wrong, I am sorry.

 

[iLoveYou]

Spoiler: snip

Um..I'm not so dumb that each word must be pronounced.
He did not role claim mafia.
He role claimed miller. There is a difference, my friend.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Omagosh, sorry. Your other post hadn't loaded when I posted >.<

- - - Post Merge - - -

I am confused as you are. I don't know who to vote for, and this might be a mistake, or not. I 'half' believe Hikari. Did you see how he said that he found he was a miller? Because you said that they were a Mafia Goon. I'm not sure who to believe...but this might or might not be true.

And am I entitled to my opinions?

You are definitely entitled to your own opinion & to use it to place your vote. It just really looked like you were trying to point a finger at Tsundere in specific (you quoted her after all). You called her out for voting even though she had a really good reason to vote for Hikari. At least there was clear evidence when she placed her vote.

The fact that you called her out though, surprised me. Hikari literally just made a huge slip up.

You are not forced to vote for Hikari, Beary509. Vote for who you wish. I'm just saying, pointing a finger at Tsundere will not help Hikari right now.