Mafia TBT Mafia III: The Murder Before Christmas [Game Over/Town Win]

[kittenrobotarmy]

Uh, my activity dropped at the beginning, around Night 1 - Day 2. I don't really have anything to say right now so I'm not saying anything at all.

Explain to me how a drop of activity in the beginning of the game after
1) I said I would be quiet

2) People also told me to be quiet

3) I went under suspicion for my excessive posting

is evidence that I am Mafia. Why would 2-3 Mafia members argue and question me in public if I were Mafia, and why have I voted for Mafia to die all this time? You could think

1) I am Town. Almost everyone who's accused me has died and flipped red with the exception of Dolby, because he believed I was innocent before he was lynched.

2) This is a grand scheme and the Mafia wants to kill themselves off to protect the other mafiaso.

 

[KarlaKGB]

Your voting record is nothing to boast about. Jumping straight onto the Godfather for the elections. Sure, you voted Mafia every time they were the clear cut choice: VD, Tina, Superpenguin. But you happily sent Creeper and Dolby to the lynch too. Too bad it didn't quite work for Oath.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Dolby was very suspicious. He was lying constantly and he kept switching from being a BD to not being one. Roleclaiming two different roles, lying and meaningless posts? Would you still think Dolby was innocent? You also voted for him, might I add.

Creeper had a solid case against her. She thought Trundle was more suspicious than VD, and basically defended the later confirmed Godfather. Besides, she wasn't very active and wasn't contributing. If I recall, you had no trouble voting for Creeper and Dolby. You voted for VD, Tina, SP, Dolby and Creeper for lynching during the game like I did, so that changes nothing.

 

[Hikari]

Oh hey Mafia, you wanted me dead apparently.



So who do you think we should lynch?

Hmm... well Like Trundle has said, Horus and Lynn have a strange voting record, and they both don't talk much. Mafia don't like talking much because they could slip up, and they try their best to keep their members alive.

 

[KarlaKGB]

Mafia don't like talking much because they could slip up, and they try their best to keep their members alive.

Speaking of which, you've not been posting much this game. Yes, even with your incarceration. Scared of slipping up? You yourself did say that you would have slipped up by now.

 

[Hikari]

Well, I don't really have much to post about. You and Trundle usually post really good evidence, so I don't really need to say much in regards to lynch candiates.

 

[KarlaKGB]

Well, I don't really have much to post about. You and Trundle usually post really good evidence, so I don't really need to say much in regards to lynch candiates.

Oh ok.

Dolby was very suspicious. He was lying constantly and he kept switching from being a BD to not being one. Roleclaiming two different roles, lying and meaningless posts? Would you still think Dolby was innocent? You also voted for him, might I add.

Creeper had a solid case against her. She thought Trundle was more suspicious than VD, and basically defended the later confirmed Godfather. Besides, she wasn't very active and wasn't contributing. If I recall, you had no trouble voting for Creeper and Dolby. You voted for VD, Tina, SP, Dolby and Creeper for lynching during the game like I did, so that changes nothing.

So your defence is that you voted exactly like I did? Reading back you've never really contributed at all, rather just rode off what the rest of us were saying. So, a few posts that stand out:

That's kind of sudden. Quick question: did all the DTs tell you their check results, or just Tina's? You seem very confident that SP is Mafia.

Following your buddy SP's method of fishing for information about my detectives. Look where it got him.

So, can we start discussing? We don't have much time, it doesn't take long for them to send in one kill.

There are two mafiaso left, and they are Mafia Goons if I can remember the roles correctly.

We can't wait until Day to discuss the lynch, the Mafia might kill Karla before he can share his suspicions. Pretty much all of them have been correct, so we need to act quickly.

Fluffy posts during last night. You seem to be awfully aware of what Mafia are up to. Suggesting we all start discussing things without actually saying anything yourself. This reads to me as trying to move discussion along to keep yourself looking sweet, while you wait for me to die. But oh look, I'm still alive, you failed.

Blu, is there a problem with me trying to keep my spam level low? Would you like me to constantly post instead? I told you all I would lurk and stay quiet in my signup post.

Well, you've lurked and have the second highest number of posts in this game. I only overtook you when you caught on that you were probably saying too much and toned it down a little.

Your move, Kippla.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

Yes, and about 100 of those posts were made around Day 1/signups. Then I shut up. Now, I've made around 60 posts since Day 2 to Day 6. See anything different?

I wasn't looking for info on the checks. I was asking if the DTs trusted you and told you all their check results. That was simply a yes/no question. I expected a no, Karla.

Oh, I was talking to YOU, Karla. Usually you're oh-so-keen to make a list of suspicions right away, I expected you to attack someone with quotes.

By the way, if I actually wanted you dead, I would've talked about that already. Nope, you're a good sheriff and we want to keep you. What I do wonder, though, is why the Mafia haven't tried to kill you yet.

 

[EpicGamer12]

As the votes went last night, I'm going to push Horus. As you all know, he voted just like Superpenguin and Oath2Order last night, and I'm nearly positive he is mafia. He has also not posted much this game, and has stayed in the shadows by "losing interest" in the game. Of course, this is perfect method of a mafia hiding from posting as to not reveal information. I'm voting Horus, and you all should too.

 

[KarlaKGB]

By the way, if I actually wanted you dead, I would've talked about that already. Nope, you're a good sheriff and we want to keep you. What I do wonder, though, is why the Mafia haven't tried to kill you yet.

Are you seriously accusing me here? Explain this post. You say I'm a good sheriff, and now you question why I'm still alive?

 

[Hikari]

Yes, and about 100 of those posts were made around Day 1/signups. Then I shut up. Now, I've made around 60 posts since Day 2 to Day 6. See anything different?

I wasn't looking for info on the checks. I was asking if the DTs trusted you and told you all their check results. That was simply a yes/no question. I expected a no, Karla.

Oh, I was talking to YOU, Karla. Usually you're oh-so-keen to make a list of suspicions right away, I expected you to attack someone with quotes.

By the way, if I actually wanted you dead, I would've talked about that already. Nope, you're a good sheriff and we want to keep you. What I do wonder, though, is why the Mafia haven't tried to kill you yet.

I wouldn't be surprised if the Mafia already attacked him. Like last night, it said a shot was fired but no one died. It implies a paramedic saved someone.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

No, I'm not accusing you. I'm just kind of curious as to why they haven't used a kill on you yet. You're a clear target because of your analysis and you've been able to kill about 4 mafiaso so far.

 

[KarlaKGB]

I wouldn't be surprised if the Mafia already attacked him. Like last night, it said a shot was fired but no one died. It implies a paramedic saved someone.

I wouldn't read too much into the the fluff text.

- - - Post Merge - - -

No, I'm not accusing you. I'm just kind of curious as to why they haven't used a kill on you yet. You're a clear target because of your analysis and you've been able to kill about 4 mafiaso so far.

Well I still don't see the point of your post. Hoping a kindly Mafia player is going to answer for you? In fact, the only possible purpose for that post is to gently push doubt in my direction.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

The other purpose is to simply voice my question and thoughts.

 

[EpicGamer12]

At this point if there is one paramedic left in the game and the mafia only has 1 KP, the paramedic probably successfully protected that person.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

That makes sense. The Mafia's going to be after you and Karla.

 

[Horus]

As the votes went last night, I'm going to push Horus. As you all know, he voted just like Superpenguin and Oath2Order last night, and I'm nearly positive he is mafia. He has also not posted much this game, and has stayed in the shadows by "losing interest" in the game. Of course, this is perfect method of a mafia hiding from posting as to not reveal information. I'm voting Horus, and you all should too.

↑
He has a point there.

 

[KarlaKGB]

So, can people start voting so we can win this game?

 

[Hikari]

Okay, I'm going to vote for Horus, since he has a similar voting record with confirmed Mafiaso.

 

[kittenrobotarmy]

I voted for Horus earlier because of his voting record and his inactivity because he's "losing interest".