I mentioned Dolby in the thread, because his inactivity as Town is too similar as Mafia. Later on, he'll make us keep guessing on whether he's Town or Mafia. And apparently, he's been sick as both Town and Mafia. It was kind of swept under the rug, though.
-
Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.
Mafia TBT Mafia IX: The Apocalypse [Game Over/Town Win]
- Thread starter Laurina
- Start date
I mentioned Dolby in the thread, because his inactivity as Town is too similar as Mafia. Later on, he'll make us keep guessing on whether he's Town or Mafia. And apparently, he's been sick as both Town and Mafia. It was kind of swept under the rug, though.
I'm just going to go ahead and share my thoughts so far.
I feel that Superpenguin may possibly be covering up by picking on multiple users. First they picked on Sataric because of their posting style and, I'm only new here too but, I think it would've been better to take note of that post style, and to keep an eye on their future posts instead? Then they brought up oath2order and Ashtot afterwards. It just gave me the impression that they might be trying to create a distraction by bringing up several users. It could just be that they're trying to get the discussion moving though.
I'm not jumping straight to the conclusion that SP is scum though or anything.
I'm not completely sure of Purplepanda just yet, since most have already mentioned about past threads.
I'm still learning though, so this is probably not be the best observation.
I feel that Superpenguin may possibly be covering up by picking on multiple users. First they picked on Sataric because of their posting style and, I'm only new here too but, I think it would've been better to take note of that post style, and to keep an eye on their future posts instead? Then they brought up oath2order and Ashtot afterwards. It just gave me the impression that they might be trying to create a distraction by bringing up several users. It could just be that they're trying to get the discussion moving though.
I'm not jumping straight to the conclusion that SP is scum though or anything.
I'm not completely sure of Purplepanda just yet, since most have already mentioned about past threads.
I'm still learning though, so this is probably not be the best observation.
Superpenguin
Penguins! <3
Cause it's so damn obvious already. You just gave the definition of who Dolby is! That's not a "Hey guys, let's lynch Dolby."
And if you see it getting swept under the rug, bring it back up! Tell someone privately you think Dolby is deserving of lynch. Don't just stand back and wait.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I brought up oath2order and ashtot to show Lunatic how easy it is to bring up a name and start a case on any player there is. I never wanted either of them to be lynched today.
toastia
seeker of truth
That's not bringing up a distraction, that's calling out names.
Oath and SP have something going on between them, apparently. Those two are going to bicker for a while.
He also wasn't picking on people.
I think it was just a thing he blurted out rashly. He's obviously trying to cover up for it now, even though the damage is already dealt.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Boy, I hate people on invsisble in mafia games -_-
Elijo
chimken nuggie man
Alright, it has been 19 hours and thirty-seven minutes since the Day One post had been posted. Lets see what's up.
What I see in this thread so far:
I would suggest that either Superpenguin or an inactive gets lynched today, but I'm willing to vote for anyone as long as they have decent reasoning against them.
List of people that have yet to post:
With mafia practically having no safe claims now, it will be much easier to catch them, as they can't lie (well they can, but it will be much easier to tell if they are lying because of the powers the Nurse and Baker have).
What I see in this thread so far:
- Superpenguin - Acting aggressive, jumping from person to person and attacking Sataric specifically because of the format of his/her posts.
Should he be up for Day One Lynch? No. He appears to be showing several of his town behavioural traits, so I don't think he should be lynched, unless everyone wants to get rid of a distraction, of course. - Sataric - Posting regularly and adding to the discussion. Writes formal paragraphs. Currently appears town-aligned.
Should he/she be considered as Day One Lynch? Definitely not. He/she is actually trying to help town. One pair of eyes should be watching him/her though, as he/she is a new player. - Oath2Order - Defending Sataric and himself. Dissing Superpenguin's posts.
Should he be considered as a candidate for Day 1? Nope.
I would suggest that either Superpenguin or an inactive gets lynched today, but I'm willing to vote for anyone as long as they have decent reasoning against them.
List of people that have yet to post:
- Justin
- Minties
- Farobi
- ITookYourWaffles
- Dolby
- MisterNeedleMouse
With mafia practically having no safe claims now, it will be much easier to catch them, as they can't lie (well they can, but it will be much easier to tell if they are lying because of the powers the Nurse and Baker have).
That's understandable, I guess I misread your post. My mistake.
That was a figure of speech. Sorry, I should've made it clearer.
That was only Mouse'n sign up post; (s)he hasn't posted for the actual game.
toastia
seeker of truth
I really need to check the filters more often.
Would it be a hassle to link to the filters instead of the player account?
I thought you said he shouldn't be considered for day 1 lynch but then you suggest that he be lynched??
- - - Post Merge - - -
SP btw
I am sorry that you feel that way - But this is the way I express myself. As stated before, I will try to keep my posts more straight-to-the-point in the future but if you'd care to look at my post history OUTSIDE of the Mafia game then you'd see that I write just the same there as well. I am NOT annoying you or anyone else on purpose.
It's not that hard to do an advanced search of the thread yourself.
- - - -
Despite Superpenguin bringing out players in a more vicious way, I don't think he should be considered for lynch. Even if he hasn't exactly been the best at lynching scum, I think that his method of getting players to talk is staying true to himself.
I think lynching an inactive is our best bet for now.
PurplPanda
not at disneyworld
I think we should go for Dolby. As others have said, it is hard to differentiate between his mafia and town playstyle, and he generally never posts. So we may as well get him out of our way now, instead of later in the game.
Checking in here. SuperPenguin is usually highly aggressive at the start of the game. He always has been. I personally don't think that's worthy of a day one lynch, but we should probably keep an eye on him. As far as Sataric goes, I think he's just trying to not start out as a noob (as many of the newer people have) by trying to put thoughts into his posts. He acknowledged that we find his posting style annoying and agreed to change it, no reason to keep hammering.
Relatively safe lynches imo, due to constant inactivity or bad playing:
Dolby
DarkNightMoon
Purplpanda
MrKisstoefur
ITookYourWaffles
Relatively safe lynches imo, due to constant inactivity or bad playing:
Dolby
DarkNightMoon
Purplpanda
MrKisstoefur
ITookYourWaffles
I agree with that list for the most part, I'd add MissNoodle to the list. But are we going to go down the inactive route? If we are, I personally think we should knock MrKisstoefur to give him another chance and ITYW because she can be a decent player~
MrPicklez
Refined Trash
Seriously though? One game and I'm Mafia Hitler. Basketballs don't hold grudges.
No just your constant whining over being lynched when you GAVE UP and didn't even attempt to defend yourself. It's annoying and it's what Cory used to do all the time which is why he gets WotC'd.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I do agree on Kiss as long as he can stop *****ing about being killed last game (as he already did a few pages ago). Last game ITYW played, she essentially had someone spoon feed her what to say, not to mention she surrendered when she wasn't the only one left alive. I suppose it would benefit us if she was mafia.
Out of Minties' list I'd prefer Dolby over other candidates:
1) The other players generally contribute to the thread and communicate in other mediums such as irc unlike him
2) As scum, Dolby is good at his so-called "blue sniping". Whatever his role is, he's dangerous to any team he opposes.
And comments about the other players:
Mrkisstoefur - as long as he doesn't ramble on about the last game and actually try this game I'd be okay giving him another chance
ITYW - she's extremely nervous as mafia (as proven in the last main mafia), it'd be fairly easy to catch her if she's asking for other people for help on what to say
PurplPanda - posts a lot and it would be easy to tell if scum. Tbh we've been sort of unfair on him, he's been like a first day lynch for 3 games, and we've mislynched twice. I'd look at him another day and he can be a future lynch candidate if necessary.
DarkNightMoon - at least she tries and in the last game, posted quite a few times I think? I don't think she spams or anything, but she's never been scum or third party before so it would be hard to tell if she's scum unless she somehow slips up.
1) The other players generally contribute to the thread and communicate in other mediums such as irc unlike him
2) As scum, Dolby is good at his so-called "blue sniping". Whatever his role is, he's dangerous to any team he opposes.
And comments about the other players:
Mrkisstoefur - as long as he doesn't ramble on about the last game and actually try this game I'd be okay giving him another chance
ITYW - she's extremely nervous as mafia (as proven in the last main mafia), it'd be fairly easy to catch her if she's asking for other people for help on what to say
PurplPanda - posts a lot and it would be easy to tell if scum. Tbh we've been sort of unfair on him, he's been like a first day lynch for 3 games, and we've mislynched twice. I'd look at him another day and he can be a future lynch candidate if necessary.
DarkNightMoon - at least she tries and in the last game, posted quite a few times I think? I don't think she spams or anything, but she's never been scum or third party before so it would be hard to tell if she's scum unless she somehow slips up.
Actually, some might find it easy to find out if I'm mafia, when I'm town I try to make cases, post more then once per day/night cycle, voice my opinion, and occasionally, make a case on somebody who I find suspicious who doesn't have a case against them. When I'm scum, I post to avoid modkill (i.e., once per day/night cycle) , never make cases, and bandwagon with almost no reason
As for my blue sniping abilities, I'm honestly given to much credit, I call SP out on day one in mm3 and suddenly I'm a blue sniper. At best, I get three blues in a game, a leak is more reliable then me when blue sniping (such as SP finding all the roleclaims night two in Harry potter mafia, in that game, I guessed three non-townies correctly). this is probably the worst defense in the history of defenses
As for my blue sniping abilities, I'm honestly given to much credit, I call SP out on day one in mm3 and suddenly I'm a blue sniper. At best, I get three blues in a game, a leak is more reliable then me when blue sniping (such as SP finding all the roleclaims night two in Harry potter mafia, in that game, I guessed three non-townies correctly). this is probably the worst defense in the history of defenses
