Mafia TBT Mafia V: There and Back Again [Game Over/Town Win]

[Mary]

Agreed. We should just dismiss it, and move on.

Sarcasm intended?

 

[BellGreen]

Sarcasm intended?

I wouldn't go too far with FireNinja. It's hard to base him off of his tiny amount of posts.

 

[oath2order]

We're going to have all of Day 3 to discuss it. It's still Night 2 right now and people are more concerned about getting their actions in at this point. Also, my post could easily influence who the mafia decides to kill, so it's safer to wait until Day 3. Wouldn't you want that? Less harsh kills from mafia?

Oh, no I'm perfectly fine with you waiting. I just find it funny that you decide to wait to put out your suspicions of me, but throughout night one...

beary, I've got my eye on you. You're acting a lot differently than you normally do. Keep high suspicion on beary, and if you want to see, check her posts from non mafia games compared to this one.

I've talked to Prin in PM and I've been in PM with her. I obviously trust Prin at this point, so she probably trusts me and has backed me up in agreement.

I don't see why bandwagoning is an issue. It happens every game is never quite attacked like it is this game. Time and time again, people get bandwagoned. Guess what? It's the first day. Prin chose to vote for Dolby after what was posted about him. If that's suspicious in any way other than that it's a good way for mafia to seem pro-town, then I'm baffled.

The last time beary509 was mafia, she got mad whenever something happened she didn't like. In Red Revolution, there are 2-3 posts containing beary509's anger after people discussing/accusing her. If you look through any other game, beary does not do this. Instead, she is very apologetic, easy-going, and laughable.
I've also noticed that beary509 has joined the IRC and then left seconds after once or twice today. Can't handle the heat of people directly talking to you?

I believe that beary509 may be scum.

Okay.. While I still don't understand, I'll take your word for it.
Also, did anyone notice earlier how eager beary509 was to change the topic of iLoveYou earlier? It amused me, and it only adds to my suspicion. Hopefully the actions will be sent in soon and Day 2 will hit.

You seem perfectly fine with posting your suspicions about beary throughout night one, and you seem perfectly fine defending Prin. Care to explain why you don't want to share your thoughts now, but you were fine doing so in a previous night?

 

[Byngo]

So I've been looking at the thread for a while now, and I've noticed some fishy things, so I thought I would share them:

- SirGanatar came out of no where, with no explanation of his vote, at all. Also, he's only made 5 posts, one of which was just an image, and haven't contributed at all. This inactivity certainly doesn't match up to how he played in Mini Mafia II, where he posted fairly actively, when he was a townie.

- Next, notice how four people within a little less than one hour voted, three of which had to change their votes from someone else, to River. (Jeremy, Prin and You. Lastly, I found You's constant vote changing rather odd. Yes, other people (myself included) changed their votes, but You did 5 times + his first vote. All of this could just be a coincidence, but as likely, it may not be.

- Lastly, FireNinja. He has been pretty inactive, and hasn't even voted once. But what I find most alarming is that this matches up exactly how he played as mafia in the first game. Every other game, where he was townie, he posted often. They were a lot of one liners, but nonetheless, he posted often.

These are of course just observations I'm making. I'd like to hear what the people listed have to say, particularly the inactive ones.

 

[EpicGamer12]

@oath2order

Actually, the second two posts there were made about 1-2 hours from Night 1 being over. Before that, I stated I'm suspicious of beary509, which was on Day One, and the second was an ordinary post saying that I trust Prin. There's really nothing out of the ordinary about any of these posts anyways as none of them are full cases like I will post later.
It really seems like you're trying too hard to make me look like the bad guy here.

 

[Ashtot]

So I've been looking at the thread for a while now, and I've noticed some fishy things, so I thought I would share them:

- SirGanatar came out of no where, with no explanation of his vote, at all. Also, he's only made 5 posts, one of which was just an image, and haven't contributed at all. This inactivity certainly doesn't match up to how he played in Mini Mafia II, where he posted fairly actively, when he was a townie.

- Next, notice how four people within a little less than one hour voted, three of which had to change their votes from someone else, to River. (Jeremy, Prin and You. Lastly, I found You's constant vote changing rather odd. Yes, other people (myself included) changed their votes, but You did 5 times + his first vote. All of this could just be a coincidence, but as likely, it may not be.

- Lastly, FireNinja. He has been pretty inactive, and hasn't even voted once. But what I find most alarming is that this matches up exactly how he played as mafia in the first game. Every other game, where he was townie, he posted often. They were a lot of one liners, but nonetheless, he posted often.

These are of course just observations I'm making. I'd like to hear what the people listed have to say, particularly the inactive ones.

I actually just kept switching my vote, and settled on River to make the day end faster. I know it looks suspicious but in all honesty I don't know what I'm doing.

 

[oath2order]

@oath2order

Actually, the second two posts there were made about 1-2 hours from Night 1 being over. Before that, I stated I'm suspicious of beary509, which was on Day One, and the second was an ordinary post saying that I trust Prin. There's really nothing out of the ordinary about any of these posts anyways as none of them are full cases like I will post later.
It really seems like you're trying too hard to make me look like the bad guy here.

No, I'm defending myself and calling you out on something.

 

[Elijo]

Onward to Day 3! I'm feeling good. Big Bad River is gone. Now, we must become Mafia hunters! (Sorry, in a wild mood.) Lets hope no one good dies.

 

[EpicGamer12]

No, I'm defending myself and calling you out on something.

In other words, making me look like the bad guy. I haven't even posted what I was going to say yet and you're making yourself look like you're scared of being killed. If you're really a townie, you really shouldn't have anything to be afraid of. It's pretty clear that you know there are things I'm going to call out on; therefore, the conscious of a mafia player.

 

[oath2order]

No, I'm honestly confused as to what you have to call me out on. I make claims against players, sit back, respond near the middle/end of the day. I don't most much at night. Same as MM2 when I was Detective, would have been the same in Mafia 4 had I survived night one.

My behavior has been roughly the same throughout the two most recent games, so I'm looking forward to seeing how "obvious" it is.

That said, it's 3 hours and 45 minutes until the end of the night. I'm going to be at work during this time. I look forward to reading what you have to say when I get home.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

No, I'm honestly confused as to what you have to call me out on. I make claims against players, sit back, respond near the middle/end of the day. I don't most much at night. Same as MM2 when I was Detective, would have been the same in Mafia 4 had I survived night one.

My behavior has been roughly the same throughout the two most recent games, so I'm looking forward to seeing how "obvious" it is.

That said, it's 3 hours and 45 minutes until the end of the night. I'm going to be at work during this time. I look forward to reading what you have to say when I get home.

Any moment now I'm sure.

 

[Blu Rose]

Any moment now I'm sure.

*Jeopardy theme song plays*

 

[Mary]

Nights last forever. Can't they end early?

 

[Superpenguin]

Nights last forever. Can't they end early?

They only end early if all actions are sent in. I don't even think Gandalf is online right now.
We can wait another fifty minutes.

 

[Blu Rose]

They only end early if all actions are sent in. I don't even think Gandalf is online right now.
We can wait another fifty minutes.

Isn't Karla the new Gandalf?

 

[Mary]

I'm sorry, I'm just sick of waiting to die xP

 

[Superpenguin]

Isn't Karla the new Gandalf?

What? Why do you keep posting useless garbage?

 

[Trent the Paladin]

They only end early if all actions are sent in. I don't even think Gandalf is online right now.
We can wait another fifty minutes.

Gandalf's been online but maybe someone is slackin on their action. :/

I'm sorry, I'm just sick of waiting to die xP

Oh?

 

[Mary]

Don't read too much into that. I'm just bored to death.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Don't read too much into that. I'm just bored to death.

Then go post on some other stupid basement topic, not the mafia thread. This is for killing people, not small talk.