Mafia TBT Mafia V: There and Back Again [Game Over/Town Win]

[oath2order]

I don't ****post like half the day two posts have been.

Reading through that was horrible. I've been lurking, and trying to figure out what the hell is going on.

Tom, the problem with your plan banks on River being the only SK. What if there's another one who kills her? Not only do we lose our sponge as you so called it, we also have another problem.

It does sound like a solid plan though, but what do you intend on doing about that?

 

[Keen]

If there was another SK, all hits were accounted for and as far as I know, there is only one, and still that one SK could soak up or waste a hit from the mafia.

 

[Minties]

Essentially I think we should take the risk on players like Minties ( I love you girl <3 pls no mad :c ) or Justin.

I knew someone would bring this up.

What I meant on Day One was not use those kind of lynches on a player like me. I will contribute to the thread. I am dedicated to Mafia. I will get people to talk. That's not a player you randomly want to lynch. Suspicious as they may be, there are other ways to deal with players like me.

I am okay with doing this on someone like Justin or Minties, because they are only posting to a certain extent (remaining too neutral). I've already explained why on Justin.

For Minties: KarlaKGB pretty much cleared the top of the Dolby voting list. The top include: Kuma, Oath2Order, FanousOnTheLoose, Minties and Superpenguin. This is generally a very pro-town thing to do .. except when you are Mafia posting like that. Essentially, he could have gotten another team mate to vote early to avoid being called out later since they knew Dolby was going to die Town. Any Mafia player could be amongst those 5 names and obviously some of them can be Town too. Why did they choose Dolby? To get Town going in one direction & not randomly start yelling names.

Blu Rose, Beary509 & Prin are a problem that need to be taken care of either today through lynching (if the Town really wish to use a majority on them) or tonight through Vigilante / Serial Killer shots. They have to be broken up. It has to be done because things from their PM have lined up with Mafia's play on Night One. It can either be a coincidence or that they are in contact with a red player. This is what makes using a lynch like that on them, better suited.

I'm not mad, don't worry. I had to catch up on 28 pages that appeared while I was asleep, so forgive the long reply.

I'm not exactly sure why you seem so incredibly dead set on lynching people that are neutral. The reason I voted for Dolby was quite obvious. He literally said okay kill me lol. How does that help us? He wasn't willing to work with the town and would make us run in circles over and over trying to find out if his title was true or not. Does that help us when we need to hit red? No not at all.

Also, you changed your vote from Jeremy to Blu Rose to me to River. What are you trying to achieve?

For those of you who didn't know, Trundle is a dwarf.

Omg, how easily you guys forget things is unbelievable. Trundle was protected last night...from a mafia shot.

Can I ask why we're NOT looking at You and Trundle? You has hardly contributed anything that wasn't exactly repeating someone else or trolling, then he comes out saying Trundle, his brother, is a dwarf? This looks ridiculously suspicious to me. Why now? Why when Trundle isn't even a candidate for lynch?

Speaking of Trundle:

I need everyone to PLEASE be wary of PMing him. I'm sure this is already too late and a lot of you have roleclaimed to him. I have found out that he PM'd a player saying that he was the detective and was going to shoot them, so they had no choice but to roleclaim. Really? Do you do this to all new players? You certainly didn't do it to me or I would have outed your scum butt right in the thread the second you did it. I want to take a good look at Trundle who was possibly protected by the Shaman.

You seem to be forgetting Kayla was shot at last night. Tom would have no reason to want to kill this Detective last night because he would've been under the impression that Kayla was dying anyway and thus a rolecheck of her would be useless since she'd be dead.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Six with Minties.

To be perfectly honest, I don't feel comfortable jumping on the lynch Justin bandwagon. I think that Beary's huge explosion of rage multiple times has made me more suspicious of her as scum. Also I think it was incredibly dumb of River to roleclaim SK, much less to roleclaim to iLoveYou. We know that Kayla claimed vet (although SHE could have been the one protected by the Shaman), but it still doesn't make sense that roleclaiming SK was just to test Kayla. Of course she's going to say that because the town needs to kill the SK as well. I'm sure anyone would have exposed that PM. If we lynch her and she does end up flipping SK, then we won't have to worry about that late game. My vote is strung between Beary and River.

- - - Post Merge - - -

errr vigilante** not detective. Sorry just woke up.

- - - Post Merge - - -

and also, I just remembered that Kayla was inspected by the DT, please ignore the brackets in the last bit of my post.

 

[Elijo]

Kayla, clearly Karla didn't highlight me and the others just to put us in the spotlight, framing us. I don't know about Fanous, Oath and Superpenguin, but I'm pretty sure Minties is a Dwarf, according to someone I know who is coincidentally in contact with her. I voted for Dolby because I couldn't believe his once in a lifetime truth. This is what happens when you lie and get caught.

Anyways, since I just heard that Lauren was supposedly shot by a Vigilante, my suspicions towards River are currently put to rest. We should decide on who to lynch. Beary? I don't exactly feel comfortable voting for her to be lynched. I just have the gut feeling that she could possibly be town. I'm not sure on who to vote for. I still have time, so I'll stay up late again on this.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I apologise if my post is confusing in anyway. I'm seriously tired.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Can I ask why we're NOT looking at You and Trundle? You has hardly contributed anything that wasn't exactly repeating someone else or trolling, then he comes out saying Trundle, his brother, is a dwarf? This looks ridiculously suspicious to me. Why now? Why when Trundle isn't even a candidate for lynch?

Speaking of Trundle:

I need everyone to PLEASE be wary of PMing him. I'm sure this is already too late and a lot of you have roleclaimed to him. I have found out that he PM'd a player saying that he was the detective and was going to shoot them, so they had no choice but to roleclaim. Really? Do you do this to all new players? You certainly didn't do it to me or I would have outed your scum butt right in the thread the second you did it. I want to take a good look at Trundle who was possibly protected by the Shaman.

Good morning, it's 7:33AM and hopefully my post makes sense
There haven't really been that many people who have roleclaimed to me. I really know nothing more than one vigilante, and then past that, I know iLoveYou, and all those people who roleclaimed townie. Here's what is off about all these people
oath2order - claims townie
beary509 - claims townie
Blu Rose - claims townie
Prin - claims townie
Trundle - I am townie
You - claims townie
Minties - townie (correct?)
Now, to me, that seems like a lot of townies. I think from this list there is at least 1 mafia, if not 2.
And yes, to many newbie players I PM them saying "I'M A DETECTIVE AND YOU SHOWED UP SCUM, I CAUGHT YOU" or something of the sort. That's just one way that sometimes gets information out of new players. I would obviously never do this to newer players and I always make sure I tell 1-2 good players that I believe are town before I do it so they can back me up.
I'm not going to mention any names, but I have had the Doctor role claim to me last night. The way they are acting in the game leads me to believe they are town.
While you may have suspicions on me, I haven't done anything so far this game that wouldn't be pro-town. I'll tell you all right now, of the townies I listed above, I am most suspicious of oath2order and beary509

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm heading to school so if I don't get back I'll probably be dead from this -35 Celsius weather today

 

[Ashtot]

For your information, I've actually been contributing to this game through PM's and posts, at least I'm trying to. It's my first game so I'm obviously not completely on the ball but you have no reason to say I haven't been contributing. Earlier in the game I wasn't posting anything really, but for the past day I've been posting much more than you, and not troll posts either.

 

[TheCreeperHugz]

Okay, finally caught up on day two, which took a lot longer than I thought it would, since it took a while to get my head around everything that has gone on.

Essentially I think we should take the risk on players like Minties ( I love you girl <3 pls no mad :c ) or Justin.

Blu Rose, Beary509, Prin: Please be careful with who you are PM'ing. For some odd reason, your PMs seriously coincide with how the Mafia made their moves on Night One. If this is a coincidence, then wow. If it's not, it'll be caught on really quickly. If anyone new tries to PM you, you need to bring their name forward immediately.


We should also pay attention to those who didn't vote Day One:

- TheCreeperHugz
- LaurinaMN
- FireNinja1
- Mary

Hikari seems to be more Town aligned which is why I left him out. These people on the list are seriously flying under everyone's radars. Disinterested Townies? Maybe. If I forgot anyone else, lemme know.

I would just like to quickly point out the fact that I did vote in day one, although for No Lynch.

Regarding today's lynch, I think it would be best to lynch River, because keeping the SK can be more of a risk to us than mafia. Although we could use her to provide us with extra opportunities to kill mafia if she complies, we don't know any confirmed mafia that we can tell her to shoot anyway. This would mean that the majority of the time, she would end up hitting townies, and there is no guarantee she would do what we ask anyway. There is also the risk of mafia PMing her with someone to kill, pretending to be town. There is just too much risk, as no matter what situation we end up in at night if she stays alive, there is a far greater chance of her shooting town than mafia. So I'll be voting for River, as I don't believe the small chance of killing an extra mafioso is worth such a large risk.

 

[oath2order]

I am most suspicious of oath2order and beary509

Do you actually have anything on me, or is it just because I claimed townie? Because if that's it, that's really ****ty evidence.

 

[Elijo]

Do you actually have anything on me, or is it just because I claimed townie? Because if that's it, that's really ****ty evidence.

I agree with you there. But what if he just has a gut feeling? I don't know.

Anyways, I may as well vote for River now. I'm sorry River, but we have to get a majority in less than twelve hours.

 

[TheCreeperHugz]

I agree with you there. But what if he just has a gut feeling? I don't know.

Anyways, I may as well vote for River now. I'm sorry River, but we have to get a majority in less than twelve hours.

Gut feelings aren't a very good reason for calling people out in mafia though... unless the person has done something thats actually suspicious, a gut feeling is more often than not wrong.

 

[oath2order]

I guess he might? Idk. It just kind of came out of nowhere.

 

[Elijo]

Gut feelings aren't a very good reason for calling people out in mafia though... unless the person has done something thats actually suspicious, a gut feeling is more often than not wrong.

I did mention that I don't actually know...

But yeah, I see what you mean.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I guess he might? Idk. It just kind of came out of nowhere.

We may never know why either, unless he has contacted you and you said something that he thought was suspicious. Oh god. More theories.

 

[TheCreeperHugz]

Okay, I have a suspicion list, which I shared with six people, you (Kayla) and beary being two of them.

Prin
Jeremy
TheCreeperHugz
Lunatic

I'm not even going to bother presenting evidence. Y'all know where I stand on TCH, Prin, and Lunatic, and I gave Beary's suspicions list to her, as, if you remember right, she said she got them from a person.

Here, I'll even get the PM:


Oh, and, I did not respond, as I said so in the main thread.

You may have already been asked this and I've just missed it, which I wouldn't doubt, but what are your reasons for suspecting that lost of people, including myself? As far as I can see, the only one there that has really been brought up at all was Prin, so why are the rest of us on there?

 

[Laurina]

So, I decided to throw in my vote for River. I don't have a clear understanding of what's happening with the game at the moment (next five days off of work to catch up and actually start contributing! Hooray), and I'm hearing a few different things from different people on River's intentions. Of course, a serial killer is a huge threat to the town whether they decide to work with us or against us. They have no side. Sure, maybe the SK helped us hit the Godfather night one, but what's in store for night two? Is there enough solid leads to direct another Mafia kill? It shouldn't matter to the SK if they strike red, blue, or green. As long as they get rid of someone. It's not safe to keep a potential serial killer around and direct it at another random lynch candidate who could end up being Lynchproof or another important role.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Do you actually have anything on me, or is it just because I claimed townie? Because if that's it, that's really ****ty evidence.

Sorry for the sudden mention. I would like to bring up what I have against you two, but we already have enough on our plate today. I'll present what I have once it hits Night 2.

 

[toastia]

I don't understand how you can control the serial killer.
You know, they'll only be used for a certain period of time. They don't have to listen to any of you. Of course, you'll have to lynch them eventually(or, rather them kill all of you).
Still, the serial killer has a choice whether to listen or not. Don't lynch 'em, and it will bound to catch up with you later. I still have my suspicions on beary, but I'll save that for another time. I will ##VOTE: River, for the reasons listed above.

 

[Jeremy]

I decided to go with River too now. Might as well speed up the day and the vote is inevitable at this point.

 

[Superpenguin]

I don't understand how you can control the serial killer.
You know, they'll only be used for a certain period of time. They don't have to listen to any of you. Of course, you'll have to lynch them eventually(or, rather them kill all of you).
Still, the serial killer has a choice whether to listen or not. Don't lynch 'em, and it will bound to catch up with you later.

I really don't like how you worded this. To me, this sounds like you are mafia and you are telling Town why we should lynch the Serial Killer, but keeping yourself out of being addressed as Town by using the pronoun "You" instead of "We." This just unnerves me, and once again, you contributed the final vote to the one to be lynched. Actually, the final vote was done by SirGanatar this time, but you still voted last thinking yours would end up counting.

 

[Justin]

River has been lynched now assuming I'm counting the votes right. Just so you all know.

 

[Justin]

Oh, SP beat me on that. And that's a good point regarding Prin's post. Could be an honest mistake but it is interesting, scum have been caught that way before.