Mafia TBT Mafia VI: Faithful June [Game Over/Town Win]

[toastia]

Alright, I have a player that we should maybe be aware of.
Farobi-Posting kind of useless posts. One liners, stating mostly already known info. It seems he isn't taking this very seriously. For example, this one:

Because Day 1 sucks.

He said that when I asked Champ to explain why he/she thought we were distractions. Useless, eh? Then he came back with this:

Oops that didnt answer the question

But yeah, we have to risk a kill on a random person for day 1.

Stating already known information that many others have already stated. The question was never his to answer, anyhow. Maybe he has been in cahoots with Champ? Champ has been laying suspicions on the table with no evidence to back them up. I know it's Day 1, but "gut" isn't good enough unless you have predicted the players behavior. Behavior changes with games. I haven't even posted very much, so how can you pinpoint me for beng a "distraction"? Farobi isn't really posting any useful information. Mostly one liners. If anyone seems to be the jokester, it's him.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Alright, I have a player that we should maybe be aware of.
Farobi-Posting kind of useless posts. One liners, stating mostly already known info. It seems he isn't taking this very seriously. For example, this one:

He said that when I asked Champ to explain why he/she thought we were distractions. Useless, eh? Then he came back with this:


Stating already known information that many others have already stated. The question was never his to answer, anyhow. Maybe he has been in cahoots with Champ? Champ has been laying suspicions on the table with no evidence to back them up. I know it's Day 1, but "gut" isn't good enough unless you have predicted the players behavior. Behavior changes with games. I haven't even posted very much, so how can you pinpoint me for beng a "distraction"? Farobi isn't really posting any useful information. Mostly one liners. If anyone seems to be the jokester, it's him.

Not bad, really. There are people who play this game who just assume that every game will follow the same structure (aka metagame) that need to realize that we shouldn't just lynch a random because that's what has happened previously. If we end up lynching a "random", it will definitely be someone whose posts are not beneficial, aren't very strong players, and have also had a chance to speak/defend themselves. Often times in mafia, people want to lynch people because they are inactive, but that's what modkills are for.
Either way, we need people posting and trying to contribute in any way possible. If this game, everyone played like they were townie, then it would confuse the mafia. Don't be afraid to post what you need to, especially those who are actually townies or veterans, who should lead the way. Make sure that you blues don't let your role slip in the IRC or in your posting. If a mafia suspects you of being blue, you'll be a strong target for the first few days while the mafia has a lot of KP.

 

[toastia]

Not bad, really. There are people who play this game who just assume that every game will follow the same structure (aka metagame) that need to realize that we shouldn't just lynch a random because that's what has happened previously. If we end up lynching a "random", it will definitely be someone whose posts are not beneficial, aren't very strong players, and have also had a chance to speak/defend themselves. Often times in mafia, people want to lynch people because they are inactive, but that's what modkills are for.
Either way, we need people posting and trying to contribute in any way possible. If this game, everyone played like they were townie, then it would confuse the mafia. Don't be afraid to post what you need to, especially those who are actually townies or veterans, who should lead the way. Make sure that you blues don't let your role slip in the IRC or in your posting. If a mafia suspects you of being blue, you'll be a strong target for the first few days while the mafia has a lot of KP.

Farobi really hasnet been helping much at all. The only reason I haven't voted for him yet is because it's still kind of early in the game and he hasn't defended himself yet. He seems to be lurking.

 

[Farobi]

Apologies for the useless posts, Prin-chan, it's just that, there's not much to go off of today.

 

[toastia]

Apologies for the useless posts, Prin-chan, it's just that, there's not much to go off of today.

well, if you don't bring anything to the table, nothing gets done, eh?

- - - Post Merge - - -

is that your defense...?

 

[Farobi]

well, if you don't bring anything to the table, nothing gets done, eh?

- - - Post Merge - - -

is that your defense...?

That's not my defense. But we shouldn't expect anybody to make well-constructed cases against people unless there's strong evidence that support it ! You managed to make one though, which is pretty decent. But the only flaw is, I'm not scum

I don't find anyone suspicious at the moment.

 

[EpicGamer12]

well, if you don't bring anything to the table, nothing gets done, eh?

- - - Post Merge - - -

is that your defense...?

Haha, calm down. You were just bringing up the name. The game has only just started, so obviously nothing has really been going on for him to post. If the day continues the way it is, then we can consider him for lynch, but for now, just keep him in your mind. There is nothing to bring to the table because there are almost no posts so far in the game. You could accuse more than half the players so far this game of the same thing you did above, in post #238.

- - - Post Merge - - -

post 283, sorry

 

[Byngo]

Has day 1 started?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also lunatic, you can't bring someone's behaviour in a pervious game into this one? Just because someone was inactive in previous games doesn't mean they might be in this game. We will have to see who lurks when the game goes on. For now just watch others.

Well yes, we can use past behavior as a reason to lynch. I mean... Whenever someone's lynched because of being a distraction or lurker, it's typically because of their behavior from past games. c;

 

[toastia]

That's not my defense. But we shouldn't expect anybody to make well-constructed cases against people unless there's strong evidence that support it ! You managed to make one though, which is pretty decent. But the only flaw is, I'm not scum

I don't find anyone suspicious at the moment.

pffftttt that's what they all say
When it's later in the day I might say something else, but for now I'm kinda busy with other threads. I jsu tfelt like we needed something to start the game. If no one posts a suspicion early on, how will it ever escalate into the real game?

 

[KermitTea]

Go ahead, lynch me and lynch town. It's a stupid idea to lynch me.

That's a charge word for me right there, but that's just my opinion.
Prin, are you suggesting that Farobi and Champ are working together or something? So far it seems to me as if you're trying to divert the attention from yourself to other people. Could you elaborate a bit more on why you think Champ and Farobi are working together? Is this based on previous games?
I do agree that Farobi has been posting some repeated information, and it's a pretty nice suspicion you posted there.

I think the real question here is: do we aim for a distraction or an inactive day 1, or immediately try and go for a Mafia based on these limited posts?

 

[toastia]

That's a charge word for me right there, but that's just my opinion.
Prin, are you suggesting that Farobi and Champ are working together or something? So far it seems to me as if you're trying to divert the attention from yourself to other people. Could you elaborate a bit more on why you think Champ and Farobi are working together? Is this based on previous games?
I do agree that Farobi has been posting some repeated information, and it's a pretty nice suspicion you posted there.

I think the real question here is: do we aim for a distraction or an inactive day 1, or immediately try and go for a Mafia based on these limited posts?

Because Farobi seemed to say something that went along with what champ said. Like I said, it's a stupid idea to lynch town. What am I? town. I vote distraction. The search for mafia already goes on, but we don't need someone else taking away our attention from the scum. Persoanlly, i am more worried about farobi than champ.

 

[KermitTea]

Because Farobi seemed to say something that went along with what champ said. Like I said, it's a stupid idea to lynch town. What am I? town. I vote distraction. The search for mafia already goes on, but we don't need someone else taking away our attention from the scum. Persoanlly, i am more worried about farobi than champ.

The problem is, they said you're the distraction (a few pages back). I'm not defending Farobi or Champ at all, but the thing is you didn't really defend yourself against their accusations (sure, they could be working together, but in this scenario lets just say they're not). Why would several people list you as a potential lynch candidate? You pretty much just said that you put thought into your posts. Why do you think you should be trusted? You could potentially be Mafia and we would never know at this point.

 

[toastia]

The problem is, they said you're the distraction (a few pages back). I'm not defending Farobi or Champ at all, but the thing is you didn't really defend yourself against their accusations (sure, they could be working together, but in this scenario lets just say they're not). Why would several people list you as a potential lynch candidate? You pretty much just said that you put thought into your posts. Why do you think you should be trusted? You could potentially be Mafia and we would never know at this point.

First off, no one knows who is mafia and who isn't. It's day 1. I'm just posting random suspiciouns. also, that's exactly what I've been asking them. Why did they list me as a lynch candidate? If you look through, no one has given a reason. I should be trusted because I'm not lurking. I'm posting my thoughts. The whole purpose of this game. If you want to lynch me, go ahead. You'll lynch town. No doubt about it. If i am the distraction, why isn't anybody else posting about it? The only post i could see about me was Champ's. Anything else you want to question me about? I do put thought into my posts.

 

[iLoveYou]

Some friendly advice to Blu Rose, LittleBeary & Prin : You guys are a triangle that the Mafia will most likely try to interfere with, if one of you is not Mafia yourselves. You three are more likely to be left in the game to be used as support for Mafia, rather than to be killed off during the night. It would be wise for you guys to reach out to at least one other player (especially if people are contacting you three already, looking for information) because last time you guys were in contact with Oath2Order (he was Mafia) and we wouldn't have known that had we not looked into the PMs being sent. At that moment it was more than obvious that he had to be shot.

Players who are likely to slide by:

Lynn105
tsundere
Kuma
Jawile
FireNinja1
PurplPanda

I feel like this list needs to be at least trimmed a little bit, whether by lynch or night actions. It's safe to say the Mafia will automatically go through the list of stronger players for us. There's no way they'd take the risk and allow us to remain in the game. So we can actually rely on the Mafia for that, and in turn it'll reveal their strongest player. BellBringerGreen set a perfect example when he posted evidence for Tina's lynching in Mini Mafia 3 (she was Mafia). You guys need to be ready to do stuff like that when all the stronger players are gone & there is only 1 - 2 left in the game.

I feel like I can't comment on Farobi because in every game he is always one of my first suspicions, as many of you know. It's more of a gut feeling, which usually got me wrong in accusing him in the past games, as he was Town. I would be in support of lynching him for the reasons Prin supplied though.

Spoiler: snip

That's a charge word for me right there, but that's just my opinion.
Prin, are you suggesting that Farobi and Champ are working together or something? So far it seems to me as if you're trying to divert the attention from yourself to other people. Could you elaborate a bit more on why you think Champ and Farobi are working together? Is this based on previous games?
I do agree that Farobi has been posting some repeated information, and it's a pretty nice suspicion you posted there.

I think the real question here is: do we aim for a distraction or an inactive day 1, or immediately try and go for a Mafia based on these limited posts?

We need to aim to lynch someone who we know the Mafia will not target .. ever. Those people tend to make it to the end for a reason: they don't contribute or they are easily influenced. Yes, I too am known for being easily influenced, due to poor actions from my part, but don't forget the Mafia never actually lets me live past Night Two. :/

If I had to suggest names for lynching today, it would be someone from my list of people who are likely to slide by. It's a shot in the dark for sure.

 

[KermitTea]

First off, no one knows who is mafia and who isn't. It's day 1. I'm just posting random suspiciouns. also, that's exactly what I've been asking them. Why did they list me as a lynch candidate? If you look through, no one has given a reason. I should be trusted because I'm not lurking. I'm posting my thoughts. The whole purpose of this game. If you want to lynch me, go ahead. You'll lynch town. No doubt about it. If i am the distraction, why isn't anybody else posting about it? The only post i could see about me was Champ's. Anything else you want to question me about? I do put thought into my posts.

No, not really. So I guess at this point Champ and Farobi have to elaborate a bit more on their lynch candidates. There's a lot of lurkers not posting anything <_<

 

[toastia]

No, not really. So I guess at this point Champ and Farobi have to elaborate a bit more on their lynch candidates. There's a lot of lurkers not posting anything <_<

Exactly. That's why I'm not putting in my vote yet. I need to hear their defense.
I need to see more posts, i think i have a suspicion on someone else but i don't have enough evidence to back it up yet.

 

[KermitTea]

We need to aim to lynch someone who we know the Mafia will not target .. ever. Those people tend to make it to the end for a reason: they don't contribute or they are easily influenced. Yes, I too am known for being easily influenced, due to poor actions from my part, but don't forget the Mafia never actually lets me live past Night Two. :/ .

That actually makes a lot of sense. So how did you compile your list of suggested candidates? Why would they "slide by"? Sorry if I'm asking stupid questions.

 

[toastia]

That actually makes a lot of sense. So how did you compile your list of suggested candidates? Why would they "slide by"? Sorry if I'm asking stupid questions.

They aren't posting much. They have been quite inactive. The only candidate i think would not slide by is FireNinja1. He always gets targeted sometime or another. Sadly, no one pays much attention even after several people have agreed. I know a couple more people that are much more likely to slide by.

 

[oath2order]

because last time you guys were in contact with Oath2Order

hi bby

I agree with what you're saying.

That actually makes a lot of sense. So how did you compile your list of suggested candidates? Why would they "slide by"? Sorry if I'm asking stupid questions.

Previous game behavior.

There are quite a few players who are likely to die on night one and two.

• Me
• Tom
• Superpenguin
• iLoveYou
• Trundle

What is mafia current KP? I know each mafia member counts as 0.5 KP but that's 2.5. There is nothing mentioned about rounding up or down.

The fact that Champ isn't on yet is kind of odd. He's always online.

They aren't posting much. They have been quite inactive. The only candidate i think would not slide by is FireNinja1. He always gets targeted sometime or another. Sadly, no one pays much attention even after several people have agreed. I know a couple more people that are much more likely to slide by.

Prin what the **** do you mean, "They have been quite inactive."??? Look at the game, it started roughly 14 hours ago. Most people haven't even posted yet.

 

[toastia]

that's not what i ment....