Mafia TBT Mafia VIII: Dark Lord Ascending [Game Over/Town Win]

[Caius]

I have no idea what I'm doing and I don't think I sound scummy lol.. that implies guilty conscience.

 

[oath2order]

[19:43] <@ProfGallows> hey guys
[19:43] <@ProfGallows> since it's hp mafia
[19:43] <@ProfGallows> wouldn't it be
[19:43] <@ProfGallows> a witch hunt

I'll have a more substantial post in a bit

 

[Kit]

One benefit to having a noisy player, we notice things
Here are some things, helpful or not, that I have noticed about each player that has posted thus far
Ashtot
He seems ready to get suspicious of many players, but if accused for it quickly backs down, and moves on to others
An example, here
-Suspect post

Okay so It's time for a post that will actually probably consist of important information maybe.

BlueLeaf
DarkNightMoon
LittleBeary
Syd
Kit

So far in the game these five players have posted that they would roleclaim to Truffle. Now, this is just a possibility, but it would make sense that the people that publicly stated that they would roleclaim to Truffle, are hiding the fact that they are scum. There is no reason to post that you are roleclaiming, we all know that we should, so there is no reason to tell us that you are. If a mafia member was trying to hid the fact that they are mafia, I think a good thing to do would be to publicly claim that they are roleclaiming to Truffle in order to gain the trust of town members.

I would also like to note that most of these players will probably not aid town, if anything, they will hinder us making the game harder for town to win. For now, I'll be watching these five closely in order to figure out whether or not they are mafia, and I recommend you do the same. I know that this doesn't mean they should be lynched or even considered. I just want the town to watch these people for the reasons stated.

-Defense

I was only mentioning the players that publicly said that they would roleclaim to Truffle, which I find is a bit of a scummy move. And the second paragraph was mostly related to that list although they definitely aren't the only players who will be a hindrance to town. The reason Syd and Moonperson were mentioned as a possible hindrance is because of the fact that SO FAR in this game they have put out nothing of significance. As for BlueLeaf, I did say MOST of the players will not benefit town. And by most I meant everyone but you.

I see nothing really wrong with Ashtot at the moment, nor do I think he should be watched. This is just something that I have no cited and thought was worth pointing out
-Superpenguin
I would love to lead an SP lynch, but everyone would think it was biased because of how he called me out.
That's the point. Why would he call me out like that, single me out when the day just started?
Imo, the answer would be, SP is scum, and he was told that by his Mafia team.
Why? Lets look at his posts shall we?

All aboard the Obvious Boat.
Captained by: Kit

This was a junky post in itself, not much differnt to what I had previously been posting
I then asked, "How is that special to you?" He then replyed with this, stating how annoying I in particular was, even though I wasnt the only one posting like that, as day just started everyone is darting around like little happy dragonflys

It's cluttering the thread when you post things like that. We all know everything you posted, and there is absolutely no point in telling the entire thread when you tell Truffle your role. PMs have timestamps on them, so if the time you sent it does ever become and issue, Truffle will have that information.
Either contribute, or just read and observe.

Ok,so just stating some things agasint me here...even tho I wasn't the only one acting like this SP thought it would be bold to single me out. Now, when I am accused, I act defensive, that is just how I play the game. It doesn't help that my last two and only two previous games I was Mafia, so that really hurt any chance I had of not being called out, when everyone began to bandwagon.

You are now digging yourself into a deeper hole.

Sort of. The thing is you're being so overly defensive here -- even when I called you out as a suspicion earlier. Interesting - you're playing very similar to AC mafia.

Why yes Karen, Maybe that because that was the only other main mafia game I ever played?

Chill, I never accused you of mafia. I find it odd how defensive you are getting just at me trying to help you. O_O

trying to help? How?

But you're going way overboard. I doubt anyone has evidence of anyone being scum so far, or even Day One, or as long as it takes to get the roleclaims sorted out.

I won't blame you, it's just my playstyle

HE SAID THAT IN THE QUOTE
He said "But I don't think we really should."
HOW MUCH MORE OBVIOUS IS THAT
he said it!

can you just please post when you have something important or noteworthy to say?? We're all trying to help you out here and all you're doing is blocking your ears and continuing spamming the thread

sorry this probably sounded really mean but it's true

Okay day 1 lynch! I already posted my suspicions and no refutes or defenses for FireNinja?

One post. You overreacted just like I did, Hypocrite much?

No, it definitely does. Good example, see Jeremy in AC Mafia.

Considering this is your second game here, I don't think you should be telling us that we'll learn.

But I am always defensive when called out, I don't brush it off or treat it calmly, and I really doubt that trend is fading anytime soon.

Justin seems willing to lynch me as well, scum team lynch bandwagon? I know these things happen, I have been scum before
Notice how both Sp and Justin seem very keen on lynching me, someone just can't wait to get there night kill in

Good start with this list. I'll be watching them as well. Interestingly enough, 2 of our brand new players this game are on the list.

Personally, Kit is giving off a lot of red vibes already this game and I wouldn't be against lynching them today if it comes to it.

Another SP post

Okay, but really. In the short time Prin's game went on for, Kit was mafia. Kit was actually playing much more pro-town in that game when she was mafia. Unfortunately, that game is gone so no quoting from it. Just take my word on it that Kit playing now compared to Prin's game is drastically different. Still, Kit is just going to hinder town and needs to be dealt with in some way.

Now, there are more posts I need to add to this, but I thought it was really worth looking at.
Anyone wanna follow up on this? I have more people to do.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I hope that got rid of the "Kit is useless" rep I have been getting

 

[oath2order]

I got nothing to add at the moment.

Are ye gonna share some more?

 

[Ashtot]

One benefit to having a noisy player, we notice things
Here are some things, helpful or not, that I have noticed about each player that has posted thus far
Ashtot
He seems ready to get suspicious of many players, but if accused for it quickly backs down, and moves on to others
An example, here
-Suspect post



-Defense


I see nothing really wrong with Ashtot at the moment, nor do I think he should be watched. This is just something that I have no cited and thought was worth pointing out

I don't really understand what you're saying because my second post wasn't a defense, I was only clearing things up for other players, I wasn't "quickly backing down". Everything I posted was in the interest of helping town, and nobody seemed to disagree hardcore or accuse me of anything.

 

[BungoTheElf]

trying to help? How?

It's cluttering the thread when you post things like that. We all know everything you posted, and there is absolutely no point in telling the entire thread when you tell Truffle your role. PMs have timestamps on them, so if the time you sent it does ever become and issue, Truffle will have that information.
Either contribute, or just read and observe.

tbh he was kinda giving you tips U:

 

[Superpenguin]

Notice how both Sp and Justin seem very keen on lynching me, someone just can't wait to get there night kill in

lol no

In case you haven't noticed. I'm defending you. I've stated numerous times how I see a drastic change in your play style. I said that I think you are Town countless times now. I'm not urging a lynch on you. I've brought up basically every other name except yours. Lynn, FireNinja, and Kuma, for example.

And are you aware this game is using a Plurity Lynch which means rushing along the votes isn't going to end Day any sooner.

so again...

lol no

 

[Kit]

I don't really understand what you're saying because my second post wasn't a defense, I was only clearing things up for other players, I wasn't "quickly backing down". Everything I posted was in the interest of helping town, and nobody seemed to disagree hardcore or accuse me of anything.

You also changed your idea of those players completly and started considering other players
I guess defense wasnt the best word for it, fault on my part. I wasnt accusing you just to make that clear, I just like to point and notice things.

- - - Post Merge - - -

lol no

In case you haven't noticed. I'm defending you. I've stated numerous times how I see a drastic change in your play style. I said that I think you are Town countless times now. I'm not urging a lynch on you. I've brought up basically every other name except yours. Lynn, FireNinja, and Kuma, for example.

And are you aware this game is using a Plurity Lynch which means rushing along the votes isn't going to end Day any sooner.

so again...

lol no

Thank you SP. again tho, I like to bring these things up. I'll drop the case on you for now..
(Butifiendupbeingrightwhenthegameendsidesevrefullbraggingrights)

 

[Justin]

Justin seems willing to lynch me as well, scum team lynch bandwagon? I know these things happen, I have been scum before
Notice how both Sp and Justin seem very keen on lynching me, someone just can't wait to get there night kill in

Holy ****, I'm not keen to lynch you, I haven't even placed a vote. (nobody has for that matter) You do seem like a good choice at the moment though.

Your entire post reeks of desperately trying to find anything possible to make a case for someone. Ashtot's case in there, he wasn't backing off, he explained to Karen who was confused.

You're trying to defend yourself by attacking other people instead directing attention to someone else, and it's hella scummy looking.

 

[Kit]

tbh he was kinda giving you tips U:

He later literally called me "annoying" which destroyed the "IM helping you" vibe I had gotten COMPLETY.

 

[KermitTea]

One benefit to having a noisy player, we notice things
Here are some things, helpful or not, that I have noticed about each player that has posted thus far
Ashtot
He seems ready to get suspicious of many players, but if accused for it quickly backs down, and moves on to others
An example, here
-Suspect post



-Defense


I see nothing really wrong with Ashtot at the moment, nor do I think he should be watched. This is just something that I have no cited and thought was worth pointing out
-Superpenguin
I would love to lead an SP lynch, but everyone would think it was biased because of how he called me out.
That's the point. Why would he call me out like that, single me out when the day just started?
Imo, the answer would be, SP is scum, and he was told that by his Mafia team.
Why? Lets look at his posts shall we?

This was a junky post in itself, not much differnt to what I had previously been posting
I then asked, "How is that special to you?" He then replyed with this, stating how annoying I in particular was, even though I wasnt the only one posting like that, as day just started everyone is darting around like little happy dragonflys

Ok,so just stating some things agasint me here...even tho I wasn't the only one acting like this SP thought it would be bold to single me out. Now, when I am accused, I act defensive, that is just how I play the game. It doesn't help that my last two and only two previous games I was Mafia, so that really hurt any chance I had of not being called out, when everyone began to bandwagon.


Why yes Karen, Maybe that because that was the only other main mafia game I ever played?
trying to help? How?

I won't blame you, it's just my playstyle

One post. You overreacted just like I did, Hypocrite much?

But I am always defensive when called out, I don't brush it off or treat it calmly, and I really doubt that trend is fading anytime soon.

Justin seems willing to lynch me as well, scum team lynch bandwagon? I know these things happen, I have been scum before
Notice how both Sp and Justin seem very keen on lynching me, someone just can't wait to get there night kill in


Another SP post



Now, there are more posts I need to add to this, but I thought it was really worth looking at.
Anyone wanna follow up on this? I have more people to do.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I hope that got rid of the "Kit is useless" rep I have been getting

I got excited that you had made a good post but tbh it's pretty much all your usual posts condensed into one, which is a slight improvement I guess.

1) Ashtot was clearing up things for other people and not what you would call "defense"
2) We are trying to help you by advising you how to post (stop spamming, actually post useful content, etc).
3) It was the only other main mafia game you played, so that's our only reference? It's fair for me to compare your current attitude to that game.
4) Sure, I overreacted, but considering you spammed like three pages with the same thing I think my comment applies to all of your posts and not that single one.
5) there's a difference between wanting to lynch you & wanting to get the day over with. I want to lynch you too (and I'm sure many other people want to as well), why didn't you mention us?
6) Please post the rest of what you have.

By all means I'm not defending Ashtot / SP / or anyone mentioned in your post. It's just that your post is confusing and I don't see how it fits in? You need to understand that you caused half of your quoted posts from your spam.

 

[Cory]

lol no

In case you haven't noticed. I'm defending you. I've stated numerous times how I see a drastic change in your play style. I said that I think you are Town countless times now. I'm not urging a lynch on you. I've brought up basically every other name except yours. Lynn, FireNinja, and Kuma, for example.


And are you aware this game is using a Plurity Lynch which means rushing along the votes isn't going to end Day any sooner.

so again...

lol no

Isn't it pituitary voting?

 

[Superpenguin]

He later literally called me "annoying" which destroyed the "IM helping you" vibe I had gotten COMPLETY.

I have unique methods.

 

[Kit]

Holy ****, I'm not keen to lynch you, I haven't even placed a vote. (nobody has for that matter) You do seem like a good choice at the moment though.

Your entire post reeks of desperately trying to find anything possible to make a case for someone. Ashtot's case in there, he wasn't backing off, he explained to Karen who was confused.

You're trying to defend yourself by attacking other people instead directing attention to someone else, and it's hella scummy looking.

"Attacking others" Is directing attention to them. Please elaborate on "scummy looking". I wasnt even accusing ash, I was just pointing out things I noticed about him, to perhaps bring up in the future to either defend him, or oppose him.
Seeming like a good choice is pretty keen, you want the day to end and you want someone lynched.

 

[KermitTea]

"Attacking others" Is directing attention to them. Please elaborate on "scummy looking". I wasnt even accusing ash, I was just pointing out things I noticed about him, to perhaps bring up in the future to either defend him, or oppose him.
Seeming like a good choice is pretty keen, you want the day to end and you want someone lynched.

It's a plurality vote, the day won't end early.

 

[Kit]

I got excited that you had made a good post but tbh it's pretty much all your usual posts condensed into one, which is a slight improvement I guess.

1) Ashtot was clearing up things for other people and not what you would call "defense"
2) We are trying to help you by advising you how to post (stop spamming, actually post useful content, etc).
3) It was the only other main mafia game you played, so that's our only reference? It's fair for me to compare your current attitude to that game.
4) Sure, I overreacted, but considering you spammed like three pages with the same thing I think my comment applies to all of your posts and not that single one.
5) there's a difference between wanting to lynch you & wanting to get the day over with. I want to lynch you too (and I'm sure many other people want to as well), why didn't you mention us?
6) Please post the rest of what you have.

By all means I'm not defending Ashtot / SP / or anyone mentioned in your post. It's just that your post is confusing and I don't see how it fits in? You need to understand that you caused half of your quoted posts from your spam.

As for 6, I'm working on that.
As for spam, not really seeing what your saying.
As for YOU, I'm not accusing.
I made it very clear that I was accusing SP and Justin and I did not say I was accusing anyone else.
Infact, if we are going at suspecting defensive, why the need to be so defensive? I didn't even accuse or suspect you, and you aren't normally like this.

- - - Post Merge - - -

It's a plurality vote, the day won't end early.

He still wants a vote in tho. Perhaps to protect himself?

 

[Justin]

"Attacking others" Is directing attention to them. Please elaborate on "scummy looking". I wasnt even accusing ash, I was just pointing out things I noticed about him, to perhaps bring up in the future to either defend him, or oppose him.
Seeming like a good choice is pretty keen, you want the day to end and you want someone lynched.

Regardless of what you want to call it, a post such as yours calling out players can be considered an attack. Your response to being accused by everyone in this thread being making your own accusations instead of defending yourself is what I would consider scummy looking. This tactic is used by Mafia very frequently, even just in the previous game alone by Pally.

As everyone else has pointed out, the Day ends at the same time regardless of what we do.

 

[Kit]

If majority is reached, then can it be changed/can voting continue?
(Sorry if this is already answered, or if the color is wrong )

 

[Justin]

If majority is reached, then can it be changed/can voting continue?
(Sorry if this is already answered, or if the color is wrong )

No when you reach Majority, the voting is effectively frozen in that state until the host can come and post the lynch.

 

[Kit]

Regardless of what you want to call it, a post such as yours calling out players can be considered an attack. Your response to being accused by everyone in this thread being making your own accusations instead of defending yourself is what I would consider scummy looking. This tactic is used by Mafia very frequently, even just in the previous game alone by Pally.

As everyone else has pointed out, the Day ends at the same time regardless of what we do.

...
Ok, I'll ask anyone who was accusing me on day 6 in the last mafia, Do you want me to defend myself?
I'm sorry Justin, but defending myself got me killed last game.

- - - Post Merge - - -

No when you reach Majority, the voting is effectively frozen in that state until the host can come and post the lynch.

Thank you