Mafia TBT Mafia VIII: Dark Lord Ascending [Game Over/Town Win]

[Minties]

Okay so hi, I have just woken up. I just want to say that the fact that I went to sleep with this thread at 11 pages and it has made its way to 46 in 6 hours is RIDICULOUS. Prefacing that saying the Beary lynch today is obvious because she basically confessed herself.

Oh my literal god are you already doing this.
WAS I THE ONLY PERSON WHO DID THAT? NO.
WAS I THE ONLY PERSON POINTING THINGS OUT? NO.
Would you just let me play the game?

As Trundle said, you do not benefit town in any way, even if you're magically somehow town this game. You give us headaches and now we have to waste time seeing if you're just distracting for the sake of distracting or you're scum again. Personally, you're acting too much like you did in AC mafia to me. If you want to play the game, PLAY IT and stop wasting our time.

..is it bad that every game I consider FN1 for lynch first day?
Like, seriously.
Now, I really want to see a defense from him before we all start voting for him, but in almost every game I have seen him in, he doesn't really help town at all.

You consider FN1 for lynch every game (read: the two you've played) and every game you've been scum. You're considering him for lynch this game. Lol okay. He played better than you have ever played when he was posting in AC Mafia.

One benefit to having a noisy player, we notice things
Here are some things, helpful or not, that I have noticed about each player that has posted thus far
Ashtot
He seems ready to get suspicious of many players, but if accused for it quickly backs down, and moves on to others
An example, here
-Suspect post



-Defense


I see nothing really wrong with Ashtot at the moment, nor do I think he should be watched. This is just something that I have no cited and thought was worth pointing out
-Superpenguin
I would love to lead an SP lynch, but everyone would think it was biased because of how he called me out.
That's the point. Why would he call me out like that, single me out when the day just started?
Imo, the answer would be, SP is scum, and he was told that by his Mafia team.
Why? Lets look at his posts shall we?

This was a junky post in itself, not much differnt to what I had previously been posting
I then asked, "How is that special to you?" He then replyed with this, stating how annoying I in particular was, even though I wasnt the only one posting like that, as day just started everyone is darting around like little happy dragonflys

Ok,so just stating some things agasint me here...even tho I wasn't the only one acting like this SP thought it would be bold to single me out. Now, when I am accused, I act defensive, that is just how I play the game. It doesn't help that my last two and only two previous games I was Mafia, so that really hurt any chance I had of not being called out, when everyone began to bandwagon.


Why yes Karen, Maybe that because that was the only other main mafia game I ever played?
trying to help? How?

I won't blame you, it's just my playstyle

One post. You overreacted just like I did, Hypocrite much?

But I am always defensive when called out, I don't brush it off or treat it calmly, and I really doubt that trend is fading anytime soon.

Justin seems willing to lynch me as well, scum team lynch bandwagon? I know these things happen, I have been scum before
Notice how both Sp and Justin seem very keen on lynching me, someone just can't wait to get there night kill in


Another SP post



Now, there are more posts I need to add to this, but I thought it was really worth looking at.
Anyone wanna follow up on this? I have more people to do.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I hope that got rid of the "Kit is useless" rep I have been getting

No, Kit is still useless. Kit is probably the most useless person in the mafia game and I am actually angry at myself for forgetting that I hadn't used my WotC vote. You stopped being a complete and utter moron at the start of Prin's mafia game, where you were posting actual paragraphs and thoughts. Now you're back to posting the same useless filler posts that you were in AC mafia when you were scum? This is EXACTLY what you did then. Posted crap -> Someone calls you out -> You get SUPER defensive -> They die -> You go silent and live through the game. All you do is accuse people that call out your "posting style" (I like how we're calling it that now, because I guess being an idiot is a style).

You say this:

I tend to frustrate people. I'm working on a solution.

And then continue to post **** like this:

Heheh bye bye trundle.
In all seriousness though, I became the main topic, so I couldn't just walk away.
I'm sorry if I became "an annoyance" for you

---

Ugh can we just be done SO I CAN STOP POSTING.
I already posted a defense and am really not ready to post another one.
Next time someone calls me out, I won't even reply.

YOU CAN STOP POSTING. Actually we would all love it if you stopped posting. I agree with Trundle in the case of this giving me a literal headache because I have to wade through Kit's **** every time I want to read the thread. If you don't want people to attack your "posting style", POST SOMETHING WITH SUBSTANCE. Condense your 70 posts of one liners into a few single posts.

Inb4 you cry in scum chat again about how much big, bad Minties hates you. Waaaah.

---

How long has this game been open exactly?

Some people do have actual lives outside of this site and this game. And with the amount of time we have, as you clearly pointed out, gives "inactives" the time to post.

Incorrect, this game started at 8am my time and I was most definitely asleep. I feel like I continually have to pound this into people's heads with a mallet, pretty sad when it's the same people each game. Can we all just remember that there are other humans in this game that live in countries that aren't ~AMERICA~ and timezones are a thing.

---

Okay now that I have that out there, can we stop spamming this thread? I get that images and gifs are lelele funny because so trendy and edgy, but people in different timezones have to read all this **** in one go. I've been here an hour now and I'm just shaking my head. I notice we have some new people, so I just want to not let their names slip by because Jubs made new people mafia in AC mafia.

Syd
DarkNightMoon
Netflix
Murray
Zr388

Not accusing them of being mafia, just worth not letting those names slip into the background.

 

[Murray]

[01:11] <Murray> if theoretically i was a mafia, how should i act so that i dont look suspicious???
[01:11] <Tom29193> act like kit
[01:11] <Murray> asking for a friend
[01:11] <&Jubs> first step
[01:11] <&Jubs> don't ask that question
[01:12] <oath2order> POSTING IN THE THREAD LELELELEL
[01:12] <+Minties> **** kit
[01:12] <Murray> its my first game !!
[01:12] <&Jubs> ok murray well
[01:12] <&Jubs> the second step is
[01:12] <&Jubs> go into chatzy
[01:12] <&Jubs> and tell everyone you're mafia
[01:12] <&Jubs> can you do that for m
[01:12] <&Jubs> e
[01:12] <@ZR388> Murray
[01:13] <@ZR388> are you town
[01:13] <&Jubs> Murray are you mafia
[01:13] <Murray> TOO MANY QUESTIONS
[01:13] <&Jubs> wow
[01:13] <&Jubs> scum
[01:13] <Murray> what is chatzy
[01:13] <&Jubs> already melting over the pressure
[01:13] <&Jubs> we found scum guys
[01:13] <oath2order> Chatzy was the replacement IRC for weeaboo mafia

it was a set up ok

 

[Cariad]

Lynn105, ACNL noodle, ITookYourWaffles, and BellBringerGreen, please participate this game. Thank you!

I will. Don't worry. More post s on the way... Just reading everything.

 

[Murray]

<Murray> jubs
<Murray> so if i die your maf
<&Jubs> ok

 

[Caius]

Don't lie, Murray.

 

[Murray]

Don't lie, Murray.

you were there so you would know that that's the truth?

 

[Caius]

you were there so you would know that that's the truth?

Just taking what I've seen in the irc into account, it's really hard to tell one way or the other so soon. However, so far I've pegged a few people who are town, and have made some deals to cover my own backside. Moral of the story is, if I'm killed I'm fairly sure there's someone out there that would figure it out.

I have nothing to be scared of Murray, do you?

 

[Cariad]

I have posted my role pm

 

[Murray]

Just taking what I've seen in the irc into account, it's really hard to tell one way or the other so soon. However, so far I've pegged a few people who are town, and have made some deals to cover my own backside. Moral of the story is, if I'm killed I'm fairly sure there's someone out there that would figure it out.

I have nothing to be scared of Murray, do you?

o sorry i misread what you said i thought you were saying that my quote was fake - i didnt realise you took it srsly oops

 

[Caius]

o sorry i misread what you said i thought you were saying that my quote was fake - i didnt realise you took it srsly oops

I was messin mostly. It's that hour.

It's not like we've got anyone pegged yet lol... way too early. Day one sucks.

 

[Chris]

Okay now that I have that out there, can we stop spamming this thread? I get that images and gifs are lelele funny because so trendy and edgy, but people in different timezones have to read all this **** in one go. I've been here an hour now and I'm just shaking my head. I notice we have some new people, so I just want to not let their names slip by because Jubs made new people mafia in AC mafia.

I'd like to back up Minties here. I went to bed before the game even started. I woke-up at around 5:30am to see almost forty new pages using the forum's default posts per page settings. Forty! It took me until after 7am to finish reading (yes, I read slowly) and I even skimmed a lot of it because it was just garbage. I wouldn't be annoyed if they were decent posts - but it was mostly Kit spamming and the responses that generated as a result of that.

If there wasn't already a clear lynch candidate (LittleBeary) I'd be voting for Kit on the grounds that she's a distraction and won't aid town. Even her long post targeting Ashtot, Justin, and Superpenguin here just reads as over-defensive nonsense where she is trying to turn things around against other players and, with how broad her post is, it just seems like an attempt to get heat off herself by targeting the people who have criticised her play style. Right now I don't even care whether or not she's scum. She's made over 12% of the total posts in this thread so far and they're all utterly pointless and/or making excuses to avoid having to make a defence yet.

---

So, LittleBeary. Just a few observations that may or may not aid us later:

• Was on Ashtot's list of people who publicly mentioned that they had role claimed to Truffle.
  
• Had an interesting reaction to Tom wanting to lynch Cory: "Is that a joke, or are you serious? o-o"
  
• Insisted that not all scum will claim town, saying that they "are probably smarter then that". Hm, this could tell us something about the people in the mafia or just how they have chosen to claim to Truffle.
  
• Told DarkNightMoon that he/she was doing well at "acting very pro-town" (nice word choice) and that she didn't see why anyone would suspect him/her. This kind of reminds me of something Purplpanda said to scum mate Cory in Cell Mafia.

The above may not mean anything, but I think it could be beneficial to keep these points in mind.

 

[KarlaKGB]

With these circumstances will the Day end early?

No. There are potentially 5 more Mafia members to catch, use all the time you are given.

 

[Chris]

Now to be a hypocrite but a newsletter from a music shop just gave me some sound advice I think we should follow:

 

[KermitTea]

Case to raise suspicions against DarkNightMoon

Case to raise suspicions against DarkNightMoon

This is the first time I've put out a full-fledged case on one player ~ but she's really been acting strange so I feel like she needs to be brought up.

I'd like to start by saying I've been working together with Syd on this case. I've been talking to her and I believe that she is a player that can be trusted. This, again traces down to Truffle with his role claiming-census but if anyone is curious, I can PM him my reasons why I decided to trust Syd.

---

Here's a bunch of quotes along with some commentary / background info:

Agree with that. We can't depend on one person for all the info.

Alrighty, so we have suspects, but they are loose with no evidence, so of course we have to wait. But yes, I doubt we should we should just lynch someone because if they were a town or a scum other games, that makes no sense. Doesn't mean they are still scum or town in this game though.

Am I the only one who is confused by this bolded part?

I role claimed also.

-LittleBeary also said this in the thread!

That does make sense if scum post blue, but what if (long shot) they all post townie?

Asked a question

Yes, and that would make the whole game harder to do.

this was the reply. I mean, if you knew that was the answer, why ask it???

How would you know if they are obvious, because all Truffle gets is how many there are, which does make it suspicious, but how would you find out which ones are lying or not? Question them? Kill of the townies?

Trying to seem pro-town when all she's doing is asking a bunch of questions

Agreed.

In response to Cory's comment about self-aware miller claims. Why do you agree? It's as if you know Mafia's plans.

Agree with that, we should focus on day 1 lynch. Who are the other new people. We have Syd and me so far.

How many times do you need to agree??? It seems like you're trying to use that "I'm new I don't know anything" card. I posted a few times listing the new players as well as other people. It SEEMS pro-town of you to say this when in fact you just go around repeating what everyone else says.

So now we have new people and experienced. Does anyone have a want for lynch?

We know, thank you very much! Useless spammy post.

Yep, agree with that, don't really want to be alone or lynched XD. I feel like we are feeling around blindly here, good thing we have two days to figure a lynch out.

Another agreement! Why are you hopping around and agreeing with everyone??? And who said anything about lynching you? The alone part sort of dulls my suspicions a tiiiiny bit.

Alright so we have that information, we have the new people, do we have info on who was mafia before this game?

How is this relevant?

Agreed with the Truffle thing, we hardly have any evidence right now.

More agreement -- I'm feeling a Kit Jr. coming along

I know ,I'm trying to find some evidence right now. this is harder than I thought...

I would like to see this evidence, or at least tell us your train-of-thought and how you plan to find this evidence.

Alrighty so who has been acting scummy. (please don't say Kit, that topic is just getting out of hand). Any ideas?
Right now I am personally think FireNinja, most probably because when we said his name earlier and he was called out for looking but not posting, he all of a sudden posted. That seems pretty scummy to me.

Pretty much reiterated what other people said earlier.

Anybody have anyone else scummy? (don't stay on kit topic please)

Spam.

I haven't seen LittleBeary for a while, and she is viewing.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Then again, I don't know if she just left it on during the night or something. (if she went to sleep that is)

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yeah, she isn't anymore....

Along with

I am still going to slightly suspect her, not accuse her, just slightly suspect.
Has anyone else noticed anyone?

- - - Post Merge - - -


Alright...

I like how you repeated slightly suspect - almost as if you know she is mafia and is just bringing up her name to clear yourself in future situations.

---

This is a PM from Syd to me which I think sums up everything pretty well:

I know she is new, just like me and I'm kind of being a hypocrite here, but she likes to agree. She doesn't like writing her own opinions, but instead quoting someone else and sayed "Agreed." She's like a fly on the wall, she watches until someone says something that gives us a clue and decides that they are correct and no one should disagree with them. She is afraid that she will say something that will give away her role. When she doesn't say "Agreed" she asks us who is acting scummy and then asks why? This is kind of a stupid move because unless she's actually dumb and not reading people's posts, she should have somewhat an idea of someone acting scummy.

And that's some information I have acquired.

I don't know if DarkNightMoon is acting this way because either she's new or mafia, but definitely weird behavior that I am going to keep a lookout for. She's quickly become a Kit Jr. with all these little spammy posts that have gone relatively unnoticed (thanks to Kit).

Bottom line for those of you that are lazy:
-spammy posts
-agrees with everything
-publicly said had role claimed to truffle, like beary
-should not go unnoticed because she's a new player.

To DarkNightMoon: before you go around complaining that "I want to kill you", let me just say that I've clearly outlined this post to raise SUSPICIONS against you. Plus, we have our lynch candidate for today already.

Thoughts? Opinions? We have over a day to burn to hunt out the remaining scum other than Beary.

 

[unravel]

I do have a question

someone because if they were a town or a scum other games, that makes no sense. Doesn't mean they are still scum or town in this game though

Now you mention it, DarkNightMoon can you please explain it because I'm confused.

 

[KermitTea]

So, LittleBeary. Just a few observations that may or may not aid us later:

• Told DarkNightMoon that he/she was doing well at "acting very pro-town" (nice word choice) and that she didn't see why anyone would suspect him/her. This kind of reminds me of something Purplpanda said to scum mate Cory in Cell Mafia.

And this point to add to my case.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dang it waffles, you ninja'd me wanted a post merge

 

[Murray]

eh all those quotes about darknightmoon dont really sway me to strongly suspect him (not that i dont - i dont really have any opinion about his alignment yet). It kinda just looks like he's trying to participate ~ but it cant hurt to collect these quotes as we've got many hours to burn.

I just think most suspicions today are a bit plucked out of thin air (it is day 1 after all), but something useful could come out of his reactions to this ~ I am interested to see.

 

[KermitTea]

Anyways..the most dangerous thing about keeping DarkNightMoon until the end (assuming she is town) is that she can be SO EASILY manipulated & she pretty much agreed to everything. Either way she will hurt us.

- - - Post Merge - - -

eh all those quotes about darknightmoon dont really sway me to strongly suspect him (not that i dont - i dont really have any opinion about his alignment yet). It kinda just looks like he's trying to participate ~ but it cant hurt to collect these quotes as we've got many hours to burn.

I just think most suspicions today are a bit plucked out of thin air (it is day 1 after all), but something useful could come out of his reactions to this ~ I am interested to see.

It's annoying though, and like you said I'd like to see what happens.

 

[Elijo]

Good evening ladies and gentlemen. I have returned from school. I apologise for my absense as I was at school when this game had begun.

Kuma is active in the IRC though.

Do I have to repeat myself? I own a Geekshed BNC user, whichs allows me to remain in the irc channels 24/7 without having to be on the client. This does not mean that I am active 24/7. I haven't been on the irc all day. I just forget to change my username when I leave.

Anyways, thank you all for the 10 pages of posts I have to read.

Being in every channel of the IRC 24/7 is different from actually being active in it or even acive in it about the mafia game.

^^^ This. Thank you SP.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Whoops. Make that twenty pages.

 

[iLoveYou]

eh all those quotes about darknightmoon dont really sway me to strongly suspect him (not that i dont - i dont really have any opinion about his alignment yet). It kinda just looks like he's trying to participate ~ but it cant hurt to collect these quotes as we've got many hours to burn.

I just think most suspicions today are a bit plucked out of thin air (it is day 1 after all), but something useful could come out of his reactions to this ~ I am interested to see.

I agree with Murray. DarkNightMoon is being really talkative in the thread. She's making herself a threat to Mafia. We shouldn't be aiming to look at people contributing greatly in the thread because they're most likely on the Mafia hit list already.