Mafia TBT Mafia VIII: Dark Lord Ascending [Game Over/Town Win]

[Superpenguin]

How was I defensive?

You criticized Truffle for posting after his death. He already knew that he shouldn't do that. You didn't need to defend this leak of information which wasn't even much of a leak anyway, though if anything it would hurt the mafia and help the town since we now know of what Kayla's intentions were and this was a planned event.

 

[DarkNightMoon]

How was I defensive?

When Truffle posted the second screenshot, it seemed like you were very defensive, and (it seemed to me) that you wanted her to stop posting screenshots? I dont know, that evidence was weak, now that i look at it.

 

[Syd]

When Truffle posted the second screenshot, it seemed like you were very defensive, and (it seemed to me) that you wanted her to stop posting screenshots? I dont know, that evidence was weak, now that i look at it.

I want Truffle to stop posting screenshots. It is considered cheating as spoken by the rules, and it's more fun to play Mafia without anyone cheating. Although it could definitely switch up the game I'd still rather play without screenshots. Especially if you could just convince people without it.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*I want Truffle to stop posting screenshots too.

 

[Cory]

It was just a warning, I didn't want for him to get banned other games.

 

[Ashtot]

It was just a warning, I didn't want for him to get banned other games.

That's a really pathetic response and honestly the fact that you bothered to respond to any of this is sending red flags to everyone.

 

[Cory]

That's a really pathetic response and honestly the fact that you bothered to respond to any of this is sending red flags to everyone.

Okay, I'll stop responding then.

 

[Ashtot]

[21:10] <Cory> Ugh I hate this mafia
[21:10] <Cory> so BOOOORRRRRINGGGG
[21:10] <AshtotPC> cory u need to play pro town if you are actually town
[21:10] <AshtotPC> like seriously
[21:10] <Cory> But I hate being town
[21:11] <Cory> Ugh fine I'll try
[21:11] <AshtotPC> its too late now lololol
[21:11] <AshtotPC> everyone suspects you already
[21:12] <Cory> Everyone always suspects me no matter what
[21:12] <Trundle> that goes to show something about your playing
[21:13] <AshtotPC> LOL
[21:13] <Cory> You can see that I'm town due to my unintrest in the game
[21:15] <AshtotPC> cory that doesnt make any sense
[21:16] <Cory> It does
[21:16] <AshtotPC> no it doesnt
[21:16] <Cory> In all my games I was into it except this one and MVi
[21:17] <AshtotPC> ............................
[21:17] <Cory> Fine lynch me then

 

[Kit]

[21:10] <Cory> Ugh I hate this mafia
[21:10] <Cory> so BOOOORRRRRINGGGG
[21:10] <AshtotPC> cory u need to play pro town if you are actually town
[21:10] <AshtotPC> like seriously
[21:10] <Cory> But I hate being town
[21:11] <Cory> Ugh fine I'll try
[21:11] <AshtotPC> its too late now lololol
[21:11] <AshtotPC> everyone suspects you already
[21:12] <Cory> Everyone always suspects me no matter what
[21:12] <Trundle> that goes to show something about your playing
[21:13] <AshtotPC> LOL
[21:13] <Cory> You can see that I'm town due to my unintrest in the game
[21:15] <AshtotPC> cory that doesnt make any sense
[21:16] <Cory> It does
[21:16] <AshtotPC> no it doesnt
[21:16] <Cory> In all my games I was into it except this one and MVi
[21:17] <AshtotPC> ............................
[21:17] <Cory> Fine lynch me then

Ok. This is attitude we do NOT need in mafia.

 

[Syd]

Ok. This is attitude we do NOT need in mafia.

Speak for yourself Missy.

Anyways, I'm still reading up and saw Karen's claim on DNM, i'd like to point a few more things out here.

DNM is literally dodging every single question we have asked her, shouldn't you just answer them if you aren't scum?

Another thing is that she continues to claim she has no idea what she's doing. I mean yeah, she's new, but the game has been up for a day at least by now, and she should some sort of idea on what to do or what to be focusing on.

 

[DarkNightMoon]

Speak for yourself Missy.

Anyways, I'm still reading up and saw Karen's claim on DNM, i'd like to point a few more things out here.

DNM is literally dodging every single question we have asked her, shouldn't you just answer them if you aren't scum?

Another thing is that she continues to claim she has no idea what she's doing. I mean yeah, she's new, but the game has been up for a day at least by now, and she should some sort of idea on what to do or what to be focusing on.

I can tell you, I am slow on the uptake. I know we are trying to find scum, finding evidence against other people to show that they may or may not be scum. Its just the whole, "put it into words without everyone yelling at you that that is stuff they already know" part.

 

[Kit]

Speak for yourself Missy.

Anyways, I'm still reading up and saw Karen's claim on DNM, i'd like to point a few more things out here.

DNM is literally dodging every single question we have asked her, shouldn't you just answer them if you aren't scum?

Another thing is that she continues to claim she has no idea what she's doing. I mean yeah, she's new, but the game has been up for a day at least by now, and she should some sort of idea on what to do or what to be focusing on.

This may be breaking my rules a set awhile, but I was NOT acting just as Cory was/is.
I think DNM really needs to give a little for effort in her defenses, but she's trying.

 

[Gandalf]

[21:12] <Cory> Everyone always suspects me no matter what

[21:17] <Cory> Fine lynch me then

He has a point, with all the Cory 2K14 at the start. Also that second quote is going against your play-to-win scenario. Do we really want another modkill in here?

The point stands out for me either way. Whenever I've been scum, that is the exact kind of attitude I've felt when someone calls me out on day 1. You get frustrated that they are hot on your tail when you haven't really said or done anything. I felt exactly like that in game IV when the 'gandalf didn't die one he must be scum' arguments came up. It's all a laugh when you know you are town, but a whole different story when you are trying to lay low.

Looking back on DarkNightMoon's responses, the way she is acting isn't new. In the past, new players have either been treated as 'I want to lynch you because I don't know your playstyle' or "they are just learning'. I think whats happening is that we are being a bit too pushy against someone still learning the ropes. There is a lot of pressure on new players to post, and this is usually the outcome: rushed posts that seem to just pad their post count. I say we leave them, for now.

What I was looking into last night is the fact that iLoveYou was only Yaxley the death eater. That leaves the big question of is there possibly another strong play in the role of Voldemort. I say that we should keep a keen eye on:

-Justin
-Tom

The whole list is a lot longer, but those are the two that I would consider being cautious around given their current posts.

- - - Post Merge - - -

ebwop

Hate to have to repeat this, but that should be 'gandalf didn't die night one he must be scum'

 

[KermitTea]

That's interesting Gandalf, because I had a piece of info on Justin that raised my suspicions on him ~ and Tom has been relatively quiet compared to his other games (speaking of which, Trundle has also been quieter than usual).

And I also realized Prof Gallows was playing -- didn't see much of him either.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Aw Beary, you definitely could have tried to weasel your way out somehow and pass it off as a joke.

Too late for that though, looks like you just confessed.

##VOTE: LittleBeary

This was the thing Justin said that made me suspicious.

1) Shouldn't you be happy that she leaked? I mean, it's one scum down & one MP down.
2) If you are Town why are you feeling sorry for her?

Feels like a scum mate trying to give late advice lol.

 

[Syd]

That's interesting Gandalf, because I had a piece of info on Justin that raised my suspicions on him ~ and Tom has been relatively quiet compared to his other games (speaking of which, Trundle has also been quieter than usual).

And I also realized Prof Gallows was playing -- didn't see much of him either.

- - - Post Merge - - -



This was the thing Justin said that made me suspicious.

1) Shouldn't you be happy that she leaked? I mean, it's one scum down & one MP down.
2) If you are Town why are you feeling sorry for her?

Feels like a scum mate trying to give late advice lol.

More to add to this:
Personally, when I joined Mafia I thought since Justin is a admin/mod/whatever he is like almighty and can't be Mafia. Hopefully no other newbies thought this? If they did time to realize it's not true. Justin can be in Mafia, and isn't gonna be Harry Potter unless Karla says so.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

That's interesting Gandalf, because I had a piece of info on Justin that raised my suspicions on him ~ and Tom has been relatively quiet compared to his other games (speaking of which, Trundle has also been quieter than usual).

There's literally nothing to talk about to be honest. Sure we could be using time wisely to track the remaining four scum, but we run risk of changing the shape of the game too much. I'm waiting for Night to end before attempting any public scum hunt, as the kills will be most telling.

 

[oath2order]

There's literally nothing to talk about to be honest. Sure we could be using time wisely to track the remaining four scum, but we run risk of changing the shape of the game too much. I'm waiting for Night to end before attempting any public scum hunt, as the kills will be most telling.

That's what, 36 hours right?

 

[Trent the Paladin]

That's what, 36 hours right?

Yep. Plenty of time to do schoolwork, watch TV/Anime/Movies, and play video games.

Or accuse folks from behind the scenes on a list you built up procrastinating on an essay.

 

[Cariad]

Jeremy hasn't posted much has he? I have seen 6 posts from him. Maybe we should watch him.
DNM seems like a possibility, but, I think we should keep an eye on him, if we role check it could go wrong.
Justin's post made me think. It was an odd thing to suggest to an obvious mafia.
The role snape could give us confusion, so does voldemort.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Jeremy posted more in AC mafia I thought.

 

[Murray]

Jeremy hasn't posted much has he? I have seen 6 posts from him. Maybe we should watch him.
DNM seems like a possibility, but, I think we should keep an eye on him, if we role check it could go wrong.
Justin's post made me think. It was an odd thing to suggest to an obvious mafia.
The role snape could give us confusion, so does voldemort.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Jeremy posted more in AC mafia I thought.

no wai!

and jer has made more posts then alot of people so idk why he is being singled about tbh

 

[Cariad]

He is a strong player who isn't particularly posting, so I thought I'd mention it.