Mafia TBT Mafia X: The Honnō-ji Incident [Game Over/Town Win]

Whoops sorry guys. I fell asleep. You'll get a pretty banner + story when I get home from college. For now here are the facts:

Night 2

Superpenguin the Bushi has died.
alise the Bushi has died.




Night will end 11pm GMT (6pm EST) Saturday 17th May.
Wow what a surprise, I never saw this coming.
 
Bye sp, sorry you had to die. So that's two suspected mafia/cult down and they turn out to be bushes, any other great ideas anyone. Some good come from this, although most people voted for him so obviously mafia is in there.
 
Superpenguin you twit.

- - - Post Merge - - -

[02:46:21] <oath2order> I know it's been said in the thread but what the **** kind of game was he playing
[02:46:50] <@ProfGallows> the pretending to be the mayor game?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Okay, now then, let's get down to business.

Pally. I've called you out quite a few times and you really haven't said much, other than spamming a few dingus one-liners about rage-quitting.



This is a little silly post, actually supporting Purpl.



Also never actually posted her suspicions iirc.

I also want to look at Farobi, Alice, Kippla, PurplPanda, Prof Gallows, lynn105, and MissNoodle for pretty much just voting without actually bloody saying anything about it.
I voted for SP because the case against him was good, and that whole not roleclaiming to anyone while roleclaiming to everyone thing was really weird. I also wanted to lynch alise, but almost everyone had already voted Superpenguin (my second choice). So, I jumped on the bandwagon and voted for him.
 
I disagree with most of the candidates up for lynch today. Everyone is looking at evidence without any context. If we take a look at past behaviour of each person up for consideration you'll find that it's highly likely none of them are scum, and they're just playing the only way they know how. They don't have the kind of experience that some of us do, that goes for Karen too. If Karen had been playing as long as some of us, she would have understood what Karla was saying. What I find most people don't do is put the situations people are in and analyze their posts through the right context. Someone who isn't as experienced in the game will almost always sound scummy compared to others. This is something very crucial that people don't take into enough consideration.

The only people I would even consider lynching right now would be Farobi, MissNoodle, PurplPanda, or Superpenguin, as they've proven so far that they either don't do anything, or have no intention of helping town.

For reference to point out that I was right.
 
[03:00:56] <@ProfGallows> literally voted for SP because I wanted to be the one that put him into majority

well that answers that.

[03:01:09] <12@Alice> SP was already majority by the time I got my vote in.
[03:01:20] <12@Alice> so I could've literally voted for anyone
[03:01:25] <12@Alice> and it wouldnt matter
[03:01:42] <12@Alice> yeah, I took too long to decide, so in the end I posted to post.

- - - Post Merge - - -

http://www.belltreeforums.com/search.php?searchid=2173456

Wataru been quiet. Bani also flying under radar hm.
Hi Oath.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Awww I hoped he was mafia :p.
Ah well.
 
Ok, so we need to start thinking more about lynches. The more we fumble and lynch townies, as much as they are less townies for cult but they can still get the rest of us townies. Now, I suggest we go back, read posts, post counts and voting to see who's been voted, explanations to why they've been voted then we look in deeper at their posts, the content and the post count.
 
Superpenguin you twit.

- - - Post Merge - - -

[02:46:21] <oath2order> I know it's been said in the thread but what the **** kind of game was he playing
[02:46:50] <@ProfGallows> the pretending to be the mayor game?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Okay, now then, let's get down to business.

Pally. I've called you out quite a few times and you really haven't said much, other than spamming a few dingus one-liners about rage-quitting.



This is a little silly post, actually supporting Purpl.



Also never actually posted her suspicions iirc.

I also want to look at Farobi, Alice, Kippla, PurplPanda, Prof Gallows, lynn105, and MissNoodle for pretty much just voting without actually bloody saying anything about it.

I voted for him because of the role claiming thing and it seemed kinda suspicious U:
 
Can the bodyguard by converted to cult and if so what happens to mayor?
 
I expected either SuperPenguin or alise (or both) to be scum. Never expected them both to turn out to be townies/bushi after all, especially from how SP was acting.
 
Personally, I must speak up against Farobi though - I felt that his post a few pages back was a very weak defense. Essentially he seemed upset that so many of us had called him out and asked him to participate in the game, even though it must've taken him nearly 50 pages or something before he finally contributed with something remotely useful. I get strong scummy vibes from him and think he's more than just a bored Townie - I think he's active in scum chat since he's clearly active on other parts of TBT, and just trying to slip by for as long as possible.

I wasn't even properly defending myself that time though. I was just honestly pissed with all the "ban/shoot farobi pls he sux and he inactive"/"why is he even in the game OMG" with something that I always do every game, that everyone seems to get on my back on. Look back at earlier Mafia games where I participated and you won't see a big difference in my play style, despite how crappy & stupid players claim it to be. I must admit Day 1 probably gave an even worse impression on me since I wasn't on time talking about the mayor candidates, as well as my lazy posting style - but I've never really been in the spotlight early in the game. Fateful June & Red Revolution look it up. I may be lazy but I'm not stupid enough to do the same mistake twice.

Also, I voted for myself because of Alice's reason too since i was asleep when the discussion was thrown around and majority has already been reached.
 
For reference to point out that I was right.
And your point is? "Look how innocent I am, not supporting lynches on these two townies"?

I wasn't even properly defending myself that time though. I was just honestly pissed with all the "ban/shoot farobi pls he sux and he inactive"/"why is he even in the game OMG" with something that I always do every game, that everyone seems to get on my back on.
Are you serious? Yes, you do it every game, and every game you promise that you'll be more active. Everyone is tired of having a lurker like you in the game. It's not helpful in the majority of games where you're actually town.
 
~@ Farobi - Well, you are entirely guilty of the majority of the "crimes" you are accused of: Namely that you aren't particularly active or helpful despite signing up to participate in the games, and despite making promises all the time that you will do better. It's not about your playstyle itself - It's the fact that you do not truly add anything to the game if you're Town yet do not bother communication with anyone about who you find suspicious and so on. A minimum of thirty minutes per 24 hour period is the recommended time investment into the game, and it's written in the first post of every round I've signed up to. You're not delivering what you're promising to do. Simple as that.
 
Back
Top