• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia TBT Mafia XI: Person of Interest END

I disagree. SP would be smart enough to taunt the town to get lynched. I don't think he'd flaunt that role if he was in fact mafia trying to hide, its not smart at all because somebody thinking exactly the way you're thinking about this now.

So what if we lynch him and he is the fool? He wins? Is there a downside to that?

Only I would know the the benefits it brings to all parties playing, and I am not required to share any information of my role. :3
 
I reported you. <3

Considering how staff doesn't do warnings for post quality in the basement, I have nothing to fear :)

- - - Post Merge - - -

I disagree. SP would be smart enough to taunt the town to get lynched. I don't think he'd flaunt that role if he was in fact mafia trying to hide, its not smart at all because somebody thinking exactly the way you're thinking about this now.

So what if we lynch him and he is the fool? He wins? Is there a downside to that?

Downside is that he wins.
 
Obviously I don't think we should lynch Superpenguin. He's being a distraction but that can easily be dealt with an annoyed Vigilante; we shouldn't waste all of Day One on Sp.
 
Thank you very much - This is cause for some concern. However, in the advice it clearly says:
"Don't make it obvious that you want to be lynched. It will only result in the opposite."

Since SuperPenguin is throwing this role out there for us, it's unlikely it's the role he actually holds, because I'm sure most of us had never heard of the role (seeing as there's many new players in the game currently) and he'd be much more likely to get lynched if he didn't say anything about it. Unless he's trying reverse psychology, of course, but it's a serious long shot..
 
Thank you very much - This is cause for some concern. However, in the advice it clearly says:
"Don't make it obvious that you want to be lynched. It will only result in the opposite."

Since SuperPenguin is throwing this role out there for us, it's unlikely it's the role he actually holds, because I'm sure most of us had never heard of the role (seeing as there's many new players in the game currently) and he'd be much more likely to get lynched if he didn't say anything about it. Unless he's trying reverse psychology, of course, but it's a serious long shot..

Screw the rules!
 
Obviously I don't think we should lynch Superpenguin. He's being a distraction but that can easily be dealt with an annoyed Vigilante; we shouldn't waste all of Day One on Sp.

So what happens if he holds an evil role that will actually kill everyone that visits him at night? He might take down our Vigilantes, our Detectives, and whatever else we send to check him out. It seriously seems like making us visit him at night is exactly what he is baiting for in my opinion. Is there such a role? Tom might've certainly made one. I'd rather take the chance of lynching him than to have someone visit him.

However, if that's not how anyone else feels, then I'll simply ignore him until further notice - But in that case we should start to strongly consider other possible candidates, perhaps. We need to put this distraction aside and share suspicions about other people in that case. A few has already been mentioned on previous pages.
 
So what happens if he holds an evil role that will actually kill everyone that visits him at night? He might take down our Vigilantes, our Detectives, and whatever else we send to check him out. It seriously seems like making us visit him at night is exactly what he is baiting for in my opinion. Is there such a role? Tom might've certainly made one. I'd rather take the chance of lynching him than to have someone visit him.

However, if that's not how anyone else feels, then I'll simply ignore him until further notice - But in that case we should start to strongly consider other possible candidates, perhaps. We need to put this distraction aside and share suspicions about other people in that case. A few has already been mentioned on previous pages.

Yeah it's called the Granny
 
So what happens if he holds an evil role that will actually kill everyone that visits him at night?

I'm sure most of us had never heard of the role

CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRA****TION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION!

hue hue. Find the one that says "CONTRA****TION!"

- - - Post Merge - - -

...dammit
 
Considering how staff doesn't do warnings for post quality in the basement, I have nothing to fear :)

- - - Post Merge - - -



Downside is that he wins.

Sadly, not true. Cx
I got my first warning in a mafia game. -3-

- - - Post Merge - - -

CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRA****TION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION! CONTRADICTION!

hue hue. Find the one that says "CONTRA****TION!"

- - - Post Merge - - -

...dammit

wtf SP
What crap are you spewing
 
Try not to derail the thread too much, Fool/Jester or not, because rock will in fact start falling and someone is gon die.
 
But what if you're murdering a murderer Jen...

Anyway, I don't think that tom would hide a fool, and I think that super penguin has the skills to pull off a trick like this. I don't think we should vote yet, look at the time we have.
 
Back
Top